DACA Ruled Illegal

[meaner gene]

The illegal.part was / is that Barry bypassed Congresx to impose an edict, his own law that even HE admitted he didn't have the authority to do

Article 2 gives the president the power to enact temporary rules upon the executive branch.
6 years is not temporary.

 

[pknopp]

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

hahaa no. If it was legal he wouldn’t said it had to end

EO's are not supposed to last forever. Trump tried to end them and the court wouldn't let him. That is the issue.

 

[pknopp]

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

hahaa no. If it was legal he wouldn’t said it had to end

If it was illegal he wouldn't have to have said that. He allowed those covered to still be covered.

 

[meaner gene]

Please post a link to the EO maobama did on DACA. I think you'll find it doesn't exist.

.

The policy, an executive branch memorandum, was announced by President Barack Obama on June 15, 2012.

 

[pknopp]

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

Damn, post after post you keep proving you're illiterate. That's already been addressed in the thread.

.

You can say that all day BUT if it was illegal those covered are no longer covered but they are.

 

[struth]

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

hahaa no. If it was legal he wouldn’t said it had to end

EO's are not supposed to last forever. Trump tried to end them and the court wouldn't let him. That is the issue.

that’s not the issue before the court i this case, that case was already decided. The court said he could but had to follow the APA

Obama created an illegal EO is the issue and thousands of people relied on it is the issue…because the dems in congress refused to do their job.

there are many EO that have been in place permanently

 

[Turtlesoup]

The Racist Latino Nationalist wing of the Democrat Cult doesn't accept that America is a sovereign country with the right to control her border crossings and immigration.

View attachment 513847

Basically if they can get or steal something for free---they are going demand it.

 

[meaner gene]

haha say what? when did he make it temporary?

It was an executive memorandum.

 

[easyt65]

The illegal.part was / is that Barry bypassed Congresx to impose an edict, his own law that even HE admitted he didn't have the authority to do

Article 2 gives the president the power to enact temporary rules upon the executive branch.
6 years is not temporary.

You know damn-well Obama wanted DACA to be permanent - stop playing stupid

 

[easyt65]

haha say what? when did he make it temporary?

It was an executive memorandum.

You keep changing g your story...

 

[OKTexas]

Where did he get the Constitutional power to VOID FEDERAL LAW?????

Nowhere!

He has the temporary power under Article 2

No president has power under Article 2 to violate the law. In fact Article 2 demands they "shall take care that the laws be faithfully executed".

.

 

[meaner gene]

Article 2 gives the president the power to enact temporary rules upon the executive branch.
6 years is not temporary.

You know damn-well Obama wanted DACA to be permanent - stop playing stupid

Obama could not make it permanent, which is what he said was unconstitutional. So he did it temporarily, which was perfectly legal.


You just stepped on your own argument about what Obama said.

 

[struth]

haha say what? when did he make it temporary?

It was an executive memorandum.

what was? please provide this and why didn’t it simply end at the expiration date obama supposeicely put? when was this date?

 

[Burgermeister]

Obviously the right ruling. Little late.

 

[pknopp]

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

hahaa no. If it was legal he wouldn’t said it had to end

EO's are not supposed to last forever. Trump tried to end them and the court wouldn't let him. That is the issue.

that’s not the issue before the court i this case, that case was already decided. The court said he could but had to follow the APA

Obama created an illegal EO is the issue and thousands of people relied on it is the issue…because the dems in congress refused to do their job.

there are many EO that have been

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

hahaa no. If it was legal he wouldn’t said it had to end

EO's are not supposed to last forever. Trump tried to end them and the court wouldn't let him. That is the issue.

that’s not the issue before the court i this case, that case was already decided. The court said he could but had to follow the APA

Obama created an illegal EO is the issue and thousands of people relied on it is the issue…because the dems in congress refused to do their job.

there are many EO that have been in place permanently

Setting aside the very serious moral and ethical debate about President Trump’s decision to scrap DACA, let’s clear up a foundational legal question. Obama’s DACA policy was — in all likelihood — constitutional as a matter of his Article II authority for the same reasons that Trump’s decision to rescind DACA was constitutional.

Obama and Trump are both right on DACA

 

[struth]

haha say what? when did he make it temporary?

It was an executive memorandum.

You keep changing g your story...

they are going to great lengths to defend their Messiah Obama

 

[meaner gene]

No president has power under Article 2 to violate the law. In fact Article 2 demands they "shall take care that the laws be faithfully executed".

.

Does that include 3 USC 15?

 

[struth]

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

hahaa no. If it was legal he wouldn’t said it had to end

EO's are not supposed to last forever. Trump tried to end them and the court wouldn't let him. That is the issue.

that’s not the issue before the court i this case, that case was already decided. The court said he could but had to follow the APA

Obama created an illegal EO is the issue and thousands of people relied on it is the issue…because the dems in congress refused to do their job.

there are many EO that have been

There was nothing illegal about what he did. He can state that his administration would not pursue deportation of those who were brought here as kids.

What was done wrong is extenuating that into the next administration. This fall in the lap of Obama. He promised the Hispanic community that if they supported him the first thing he would do is address immigration reform. He did not. He issued an EO on his way out.

the courts disagre with you on DACA.

DACA did more then simply decide who to prosecute for illegal crossing, it gave a new legal status, that’s the illegal act by obama

If it was ruled illegal, those previously covered would no longer be.

The ruling said those previously covered can't renew, coverage only lasts 3 years at a time.

.

Which means it was legal.

hahaa no. If it was legal he wouldn’t said it had to end

EO's are not supposed to last forever. Trump tried to end them and the court wouldn't let him. That is the issue.

that’s not the issue before the court i this case, that case was already decided. The court said he could but had to follow the APA

Obama created an illegal EO is the issue and thousands of people relied on it is the issue…because the dems in congress refused to do their job.

there are many EO that have been in place permanently

Setting aside the very serious moral and ethical debate about President Trump’s decision to scrap DACA, let’s clear up a foundational legal question. Obama’s DACA policy was — in all likelihood — constitutional as a matter of his Article II authority for the same reasons that Trump’s decision to rescind DACA was constitutional.

Obama and Trump are both right on DACA

well the op-ed was wrong about obama…as the courts have made clear

 

[easyt65]

Article 2 gives the president the power to enact temporary rules upon the executive branch.
6 years is not temporary.

You know damn-well Obama wanted DACA to be permanent - stop playing stupid

Obama could not make it permanent, which is what he said was unconstitutional. So he did it temporarily, which was perfectly legal.


You just stepped on your own argument about what Obama said.

Obama could not do what he did...a cording to HIM, the Constitution, & this judge.

You are all over the place attempting to justify / defend something Obama called un-Constitutilnal. That's the funny part.

 

[meaner gene]

what was? please provide this and why didn’t it simply end at the expiration date obama supposeicely put? when was this date?

The policy, an executive branch memorandum, was announced by President Barack Obama on June 15, 2012.

Apparently government can't change policy, just because they feel like it.