Catch or pic?

[task0778]

Bills vs Broncos, you know the play I'm talking about. I think Cooks initially caught the ball but lost control at or just before he hit the ground, but the ball looked like it didn't touch the ground. So McMillian snatches the ball and it's a pick. Tough call to make IMHO, if it touched the ground before McMillian stole it then it should be an incomplete pass. But did McMillian have ball control after he stole it? Can't tell, but it's a tough way to end your season.

 

[BackAgain]

Bills vs Broncos, you know the play I'm talking about. I think Cooks initially caught the ball but lost control at or just before he hit the ground, but the ball looked like it didn't touch the ground. So McMillian snatches the ball and it's a pick. Tough call to make IMHO, if it touched the ground before McMillian stole it then it should be an incomplete pass. But did McMillian have ball control after he stole it? Can't tell, but it's a tough way to end your season.

I see it a bit differently. He held the ball on a valid reception and was down by contact before the ball was taken from him.

It was a major blown call. It is, actually, quite suspect.

 

[Couchpotato]

Bills vs Broncos, you know the play I'm talking about. I think Cooks initially caught the ball but lost control at or just before he hit the ground, but the ball looked like it didn't touch the ground. So McMillian snatches the ball and it's a pick. Tough call to make IMHO, if it touched the ground before McMillian stole it then it should be an incomplete pass. But did McMillian have ball control after he stole it? Can't tell, but it's a tough way to end your season.

Either way why wasn't it reviewed? Pivotal call in a playoff game there's no reason to not take a look at it.