Just think. To regain 50% (or thereabouts) of, yes, actual CONTROL over our OWN borders !!! The day we manage that would surely be a day of celebration ... yes ?
Well, it could be less than a month away ! Prepare the champagne .....
Does the UK not have control over its own borders?
Come off it? The UK is not in the Schengen Agreement.
Norway and Switzerland are. The UK could join if it left the EU.
Limited control, yes. Leaving the EU would substantially enhance that control, however.
Here's an example of why it matters - why the current situation is not only 'far from ideal', but actually has wide-ranging security implications ...
Britain part of group of EU countries pushing for firmer border controls over Isil threat
Britain and seven EU countries will push for European Union to restrict free movement rights at Europe's borders over jihadist threat, confidential document reveals.
Officials estimate that there are up to 3,000 "foreign fighters" who are Europeans in Syria and Iraq who benefit from EU free movement rights that allow them to return from conflict zones without border checks.
The EU's open border regime is nothing short of absolute madness. Quite apart from the 'immigration numbers' argument (highly valid in its own right), the EU's immovability over what it's pleased to call a 'foundling principle' - in defiance of sheer commonsense ! - is something that'll give us all an immense security headache for years, possibly decades, ahead.
Again -- the sooner we can get shot of these EU nutters, the better ....
Well it could, but doesn't mean it will increase that control. Seeing as a lot of people are still entering the UK from OUTSIDE of the EU.
Also, it causes a problem. The UK exports old people abroad, and imports workers to the UK, if that were to change, then what? A lot of people living in the UK who aren't working any more. Doesn't exactly help, does it?
What happens if the UK government decides it has to join the Schengen Agreement? Then what?
So, the UK is pushing for tighter border controls WITHIN the EU. So why does it need to leave? Just push for tighter border controls.
No, the EU's open border situation isn't madness. What is madness is when different countries can let in whoever they like and then move them on straight away. If the EU is going to have open borders, those borders need to be much tighter with non-EU countries.
Your first point is surely disingenuous ? Yes, a lot of people are entering the UK from outside the EU, but that particular issue is as much a part of our control as we choose it to be,
whereas .. in the case of EU citizens coming over here, they have a right to do so, sanctioned NOT exclusively by us, but instead by the EU - acting on its own authority, NOT ours.
Your second point is simplistic. We don't 'export' old people ... such people choose to move. We import 'workers' to the UK, but this is far from controllable by our own authorities, which is, after all, the point !! And these 'workers' ... do they take jobs that our own, UK-based people, could otherwise take on ?
How many of our own citizens are denied employment opportunities that these others take instead ?
You say 'What happens if the UK government decides it has to join the Schengen Agreement?'.
Kindly clarify. By 'has to', are you saying we will have this dictated to us, or, be otherwise FORCED to take it on ? Surely, the central reason for getting shot of the EU is for us to gain the freedom to govern our own affairs, as WE see fit ? Are you saying that European influences will be brought to bear to
still deny us our freedoms ?
You say 'So, the UK is pushing for tighter border controls WITHIN the EU. So why does it need to leave? Just push for tighter border controls.'
Such a 'push' would of itself guarantee ... NOTHING. Such controls would be conferred to us .. we'd have no direct means of ensuring they were brought in. The UK vote is very much a minority compared with all those other EU Member States.
Self-determination is what the Brexit side is fighting for, and stands for. Denying us this is what its opposition is all about.
You think I'm not being honest?
Yes, the immigration from outside the EU is in our control, and it seems the people aren't happy with how we wield that control. And yet somehow think that by leaving the EU our problems with immigration will be solved. How? The UK govt isn't, apparently according to the Brexit people, dealing with this outside EU immigration problem, but leaving the EU will mean they will suddenly be dealing with the EU citizens better than they're dealing with the non-EU citizens.
I don't get it.
Maybe simplistic, but I don't think I need to explain the whole thing in immense detail to you, do I?
People who are "denied employment opportunities" are generally people who haven't been trained well enough, or are too inefficient or something.
This whole issue isn't one about immigration, it's one about EDUCATION.
Now, it's funny, Sol Campbell came out and said we should leave the EU to have British kids playing more. His answer wasn't "let's train British kids properly like the Germans and Spanish do", no, it was "let's leave the EU and somehow these kids will play better because.... because.... the competition they're up against will be weakened and they won't be better trained." Do you see the logic in that argument? Same with the employment situation in general. If a Pole can go to the UK and get a job, earn less money and do a better job, then you have to ask what the hell the problem is with British workers.
The clarification for joining the Schengen Agreement is this.
Firstly, the Brexit people used to say "we could have the Norway option", that was their massively amazing way of saying "we have no fucking clue", but Norway is in the Schengen Agreement.
Secondly, the Brexit people have suggested that trade won't be diminished because we'll just pull some amazing special deal out of our arse. The reality is, if you listen to businessmen like Alan Sugar who has spent a lot of time dealing with EU trade, if you want better trade (which means more money for British businesses) is to have easy access. This easy access, as the Swiss and the Norwegians will tell you, can come from the Schengen Agreement.
Thirdly, the govt in charge of the UK is the Tory Party, Cameron would be open to joining the Schengen Agreement, the Labour Party would be absolutely in favor of joining. This whole argument of "get the country back" is ridiculous, seeing as the UK people have voted for a pro-EU government for the last, I don't know, four decades or more.
Fourthly, would it be forced on the UK? Forced no, but it might be a choice between poor trade possibilities and joining the Schengen Zone. How much are the UK people willing to lose from leaving the EU?
What freedoms are the British people being denied by being in the EU? This sounds like a silly argument that no one will ever back up, but people will support it because they want to believe they have lost freedoms. I've lived in countries with less freedoms, I know what it's like. I've been to countries with even less freedoms than that.
What freedoms will the British people suddenly get from leaving the EU?
No, pushing for something would guarantee nothing. Leaving the EU would also guarantee NOTHING. Why? Because you still have the govt in charge of the country, and they might just decide to do deals with the EU (which surrounds the UK) in order to have better trade.
Self-determination is NOT what Brexit is all about.
Brexit is all about "hope". Too many people without hope thinking leaving the EU will somehow take their miserable lives and make them better. It won't .