Birthright Citizenship? Yes/No

[Hafar1014]

The 14th Amendment should be interpreted to exclude children born to non-citizens because they are not subject to our jurisdiction.

Their parents are here illegally (in most cases), hence they are not afforded the rights of a U.S. Citizen.

Their parents are entitled to the process of applying for asylum or an adjustment in visa status, and depending on the result of those proceedings they may be able to acquire citizenship, but the simple act of a foriegn citizen giving birth on American soil should not automatically bestow citizenship on them or their children.

Thats exactly what it means

 

[JoeB131]

We had quotas for Jews Irish and Italians. We also had strict medical standards. You just dont know the history. We controlled immigration. Democrats didnt they just wanted bodies to be counted in the census and brought in third world garbage. Now Americans are being killed by them

Third-world garbage? Racist much? What's hilarious about you Jews is that you've managed to get into the White People's Club, and you are acting like the shittiest white people.

There were quotas fir Jews my family had to go to Canada become citizens then come into America. Elis Island wouldnt let them in

you mean Jews were seen as "undesirable"? Seems to me you should have MORE sympathy for immigrants, not less.

Thats my family history. Mother came from Poland wasnt allowed in because the Jewish quota was closed. She was escaping the NAZIs and that didnt matter. Canada took her in.

Okay. My grandparents came in From Germany. They had little trouble getting in, and my Grandfather had his citizenship within three years of arriving.

As opposed to today, where Mrs. B131 waited 7 years for her asylum claim to be processes (it never was) and it's taking us five years to go through the process of a marriage sponsorship.

 

[OKTexas]

Permanent resident is an immigration status.

Well thank you captain obvious, I think the discussion is on the spawn of illegals and visa holders.

.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Currently: A child born in the US to a US Citizen and a British Citizen has citizenship in both courties.

Under your model the child wouldn't be a US Citizen because at birth it held British Citizenship and there was subject to another jurisdiction.

Rafael Edward Cruz would not be a US Citizen because he was born to two US Citizens ( jus sanguinis, right of blood) but with Canadian Citizenship (jus soli, right of the soil) and there was subject to another jurisdiction.

WW

That is incorrect. Ted Cruz's father was not an American citizen at the time of his birth. He was a dual citizen of Canada and Cuba.

 

[WorldWatcher]

That is incorrect. Ted Cruz's father was not an American citizen at the time of his birth. He was a dual citizen of Canada and Cuba.

Thank you, jus sanguinis (right of blood) was through his mother.

However the point remains the same. Under the posters claim Rafael Edward Cruz would not have been a US citizen because of Canadian citizenship at birth.

WW

 

[Monk-Eye]

" Communist Agency Under Cover "

* The Planet Is Full Stay Home *

Who cares? Investing in the young is investing in the future.
You see, this is what you nativists never seem to get. We actually NEED immigrants. Native Born Americans aren't reproducing at replacement rates. It's why you have so many small towns in rural America which are becoming ghost towns.

This moniker is not interested in the hue mammon damned dirty ape apex predator excuses for its feral gluttonous behavior to breed into poverty , and this moniker is especially not interested in ignorance of left or right wing goofs that do not understand the literal meaning of an after life as other than genetic continuance .

The multiculturalism banter is being systemically exacted upon lineal descendants of japheth , while the lineal descendants of ham and shem maintain homogeneous cultures that are numerically over representative in the global demographic .

Fewer children were optioned to improve quality of life , to focus on efficiency over excess , however free market capitalists wanting cheap labor collaborated with secular humanism socialist communists wanting destitute fodder and fomented brood parasitism along with financial indemnity and dissolution of representation .

. Are Europe And The US Expected To Reflect Proportions Of The Global Demographic When The Left Wing Is Through With Them ? .

. Anti-Racist Racism Platform Of The Democratic Party .

. What Is A Thereof Jurisdiction ? .,

 

[San Souci]

Since it's coming up again



Let's discuss it.

On one hand you have pregnant women coming to the USA just to have a baby be an American citizen by being born here....then as the baby's mother she gets a way into the country .....

The downside?
Nobody, even naturally born to American Citizens, is free from proving their parents were Americans when they were born...

Creating room for all sorts of deportation scams and corruption by powerful people wanting to exert authority over average people.

So what do you think?

No Citizenship for children for illegals.

 

[EvilCat Breath]

Good, you just keep repeating your mindless mantras.

MEANWHILE, not sure why they needed to arrest the five year old in the Bunny Hat.

That's what happens to abandoned children. They get taken into protective custody.