Biden’s doctor refuses to answer questions at closed door interview

[Care4all]

He doesn’t have to agree, if the government grants it, it’s a done deal, this is how they did with mobster Giancana in the 70’s and the doctor can refuse to testify and he will be held with contempt of court.

The courts have rule against doctors privilege, it is rare but it has happened. Two such cases:

1. People v. Wharton (1984, New York)
   A doctor was nearly held in contempt for refusing to testify about a patient who had confessed to a crime during treatment. The court ruled that doctor-patient privilege did not apply because it was relevant to a criminal investigation.
2. State v. Betts (Tennessee, 1991)
   A psychiatrist was held in contempt for refusing to release mental health records in a homicide case. The court ruled that the need for justice overrode the privilege.

So it can happen, and there are other cases. But, government can file contempt charges and turn him over to the DOJ.

Having cancer is not a crime... as president.... Even having Alzheimers is not a crime, as President....

There is no criminal need or urgency for the doctor to break his privilege with Biden and his medical privacy.

 

[Zincwarrior]

But a court could order him to testify.

That was my point.

They should try. Then Trump's doctors will be next up in 2028. Fun!

 

[Rawley]

Only Biden can release him of it....the privilege is not for himself or his own privacy, but for his patient's..... is my understanding...?

Cat was out of the bag when he publicly claimed that Biden's mental health was excellent. Further, Biden waived the privilege when he released memos regarding his heath from his doctor.

 

[buckeye]

They should try. Then Trump's doctors will be next up in 2028. Fun!

I'm guessing Congress gives the doc immunity and he has to testify.

 

[ColonelAngus]

Biden was in perfect health….that is why Dems put in Kamala after the debates.



You fraud motherfuckers are still trying to say Biden was TIP TOP.

Then
Why
Run
The
Whore?

 

[Edgetho]

Having cancer is not a crime... as president.... Even having Alzheimers is not a crime, as President....

There is no criminal need or urgency for the doctor to break his privilege with Biden and his medical privacy.

The president's Health is NOT Private.

Who really signed those Pardons? Who really approved those TENS OF BILLIONS in Graft to environMENTAL Groups?

Sponge Brains Shits Pants has even said that he didn't even know abot most of hte shit going on during parts of his presidency.

You want to to lend your credibility to his defense?

You have none.

 

[BackAgain]

Only Biden can release him of it....the privilege is not for himself or his own privacy, but for his patient's..... is my understanding...?

If he signed a “report” about the President’s medical condition (including any medical opinion about the then President’s mental health) knowing that it would be shares by the “patient,” then was there ever really any doctor-patient privilege involved in the first place?

I believe the answer is “no.”

Plus, the privilege attaches to conversations between the doctor and the patient relevant to the doctor’s medical evaluation and treatment. It generally speaking doesn’t attach to unrelated conversations.

To the extent the doctor invoked his 5th Amendment privilege, that’s not a doctor-patient privilege anyway.

 

[Zincwarrior]

I'm guessing Congress gives the doc immunity and he has to testify.

Still state issues and doc patient privilege which has not been waived that I am aware of.
But as I said, lets do. Then we can do it in 2027 for Trump. Fun!

 

[Edgetho]

Only Biden can release him of it....the privilege is not for himself or his own privacy, but for his patient's..... is my understanding...?

You understand wrong.

The Docotr himself made the information Public when he PUBLICLY stated Sponge Brains Shits Pants was in good health.

You come out and make a Public Statement then claim Privacy rights. Can't do it.

This POS either talks or he does time. Hopefully, Heavy time. Hard time. No Country Club Prison for this piece of garbage.

Didn't you see the Debate? WTF is wrong with you people? Honest to God. You just puke Bald faced Lies and DEMAND that we believe them.

You're sick. Diseased. And the world will be better when you are gone

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

O'Connor has been talking about Biden's health for a very long time. He gave up his privilege then.

Nope. Wrong answer.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

You understand wrong.

The Docotr himself made the information Public when he PUBLICLY stated Sponge Brains Shits Pants was in good health.

You come out and make a Public Statement then claim Privacy rights. Can't do it.

This POS either talks or he does time. Hopefully, Heavy time. Hard time. No Country Club Prison for this piece of garbage.

Didn't you see the Debate? WTF is wrong with you people? Honest to God. You just puke Bald faced Lies and DEMAND that we believe them.

You're sick. Diseased. And the world will be better when you are gone

That's very fascist of you, don't you think? You don't think we should follow the law?

 

[marvin martian]

The 5th Amendment applies in that case.

I agree. But doctor/patient privilege was not an issue here.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

National security is above private medicine.

WHY DID WE WATCH PRESIDENT REAGANS COLON CANCER SURGERY ON NATIONAL TV?

To ensure their leader is not compromised.

Which court has ordered him to testify based on your opinion? When did Trump appoint you to the SCOTUS?

 

[Edgetho]

Nope. Wrong answer.

Incorrect. He has to answer questions pertaining to the documents he signed. He might be able to claim privilege regarding whether or not Sponge Brains Shits Pants had hemorrhoids but he can't make a public statement regarding his mental health and then claim privilege.

I would think anybody knows that. We just want him to back up what he publicly said about Sponge Brains Shits Pants. We're not interested in his 'rhoids. If you are...... I dunno

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Name a thing a Democrat has ever done that you disagree with.

Irrelevant and there are millions of examples. Just not this one.

Congress should get a court ruling saying he must violate doctor-client privilege for national security reasons (which may no longer apply if you think about it) and grant him immunity from any charges, and therefore he cannot invoke the 5th Amendment.

 

[ColonelAngus]

You stupid assholes cannot go “He is at the top of his game” to WE MUST RUN KAMALA! Without understanding you are captured people

 

[Edgetho]

That's very fascist of you, don't you think? You don't think we should follow the law?

What Law is that? The one that says you can make public statements and then not answer questions regarding those public statements?

That one?

 

[ColonelAngus]

What Law is that? The one that says you can make public statements and then not answer questions regarding those public statements?

That one?

Why dodnt Biden run in 24?

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Incorrect. He has to answer questions pertaining to the documents he signed. He might be able to claim privilege regarding whether or not Sponge Brains Shits Pants had hemorrhoids but he can't make a public statement regarding his mental health and then claim privilege.

I would think anybody knows that. We just want him to back up what he publicly said about Sponge Brains Shits Pants. We're not interested in his 'rhoids. If you are...... I dunno

What part of the 5th Amendment do you not understand?

Just suppose he lied. Do you think he should be forced to admit that when he has the right not to admit anything?

Sucks, doesn't it, but you have the same rights under our Constitution.

 

[Edgetho]

Irrelevant and there are millions of examples. Just not this one.

Congress should get a court ruling saying he must violate doctor-client privilege for national security reasons (which may no longer apply if you think about it) and grant him immunity from any charges, and therefore he cannot invoke the 5th Amendment.

**** THE COURTS!!! They have no jurisdiction in this. This is political, not judicial. And Politics out-ranks Judicial.

Every time