I read Caillons paper first time in 2005 here is the ABSTRACT from the
Caillon 2003 paper you didn't read:
The analysis of air bubbles from ice cores has yielded a precise record of atmospheric
greenhouse gas concentrations, but the timing of changes in these gases
with respect to temperature is not accurately known because of uncertainty in the
gas age–ice age difference. We have measured the isotopic composition of argon
in air bubbles in the Vostok core during Termination III (240,000 years before the
present). This record most likely reflects the temperature and accumulation change,
although the mechanism remains unclear.
The sequence of events during Termination
III suggests that the CO2 increase lagged Antarctic deglacial warming by
800 200 years and preceded the Northern Hemisphere deglaciation.
bolding mine
===
I
KNOW you didn't look in the Caillon or Fisher or Monnin published papers in the Jo Nova article because they are DEAD links thus you have been exposed for not reading the
abstracts, you want to go on denying your laziness over this?
ALL of the papers say that CO2 changes LAGS Temperature changes and you ignored the Charts based on the Petit data all posted for you showing obvious lags of CO2 in them, from Jo Nova,
"It’s impossible to see a lag of centuries on a graph that covers half a million years so I have regraphed the data from the original sources, CO2 Data here and Temperature data here (Petit 1999), and scaled the graphs out so that the lag is visible to the naked eye. What follows is the complete set from 420,000 years to 5,000 years before the present."
===
Here is the only linked paper that still works,
Mudelesee:
5. Conclusions
This study has estimated the phase relations (leads/lags) of Vostok's CO2 record relative to air temperature and global ice volume over the last 420 ka, extending the range of previous phase determinations by about 200 ka. Lagged GLS regression proved to be an e$cient and precise estimation technique because it uses all data, and recognizes persistence inherent in the data. Bootstrap resampling allowed account to be taken of measurement and timescale errors.
On long timescales, variations in Vostok's CO2 record lag behind those of its air-temperature record (dD) by 1.3$1.0 ka, and lead over global ice-volume variations (derived from Vostok's d18O!*3 and marine d18O.!3) by 2.7 $1.3 ka. Signi"cant short-term changes in lag time occurred not only subsequent to glacial Termination II, but also subsequent to Termination III. A summary of the results of this study is shown in Fig. 6. As regards causal explanations of Late Pleistocene glacial cycles, it has to be considered that Vostok's air temperature (dD) represents, at best, the Southern Hemisphere. Blunier et al. (1998) estimated that Greenland temperature variations lag behind those of Vostok by 1}2.5 ka over the period 47}23 ka. Thus, the geological relationships between variations in atmospheric CO2 content, global temperature and ice volume a.
red bolding mine
=====
Reinydays writes,
"You've taken more time to call me lazy than it would have telling me the theory you're advocating ... sad ..."
I am trying hard not to call you liar about this statement you keep saying I am advocating a "theory" when I never talked about theories at all, it has always been about what the those papers saying there are CO2 change is lagging behind Temperature changes that is it.
You have been exposed for not reading the abstracts that backs me up 100% because you didn't bother to check those DEAD links at all since you never mentioned them being dead links.
I gave you enough and you come back with more bullshit about something I never talked about that is ....... sad.
