Taz
Gold Member
- Jul 8, 2014
- 22,876
- 2,119
- 190
- Banned
- #441
If we can't see the BB, then we can't see what's before it and what it's a result of: "The Big Bang state is the immediate aftermath. of the break and the cosmic inflation thereof."Your first premise supposes that the BB has been observed and that it's what you say. So that's wrong, we can't yet see the BB so can only guess at what happened there.
False. I did not say that at all! I said:
You do understand that on the Big Bang model, the Big Bang state observed in the CMB is the immediate aftermath of the break in the symmetry of the grand unification and the cosmic inflation thereof, the latter of which is the massive conversion of the compressed energy of the cosmic, quantum vacuum?The Big Bang state is the immediate aftermath. of the break and the cosmic inflation thereof.
The Big Bang state is the immediate aftermath. of the break and the cosmic inflation thereof.
The Big Bang state is the immediate culmination of the break and the cosmic inflation thereof.
The Big Bang state is the immediate culmination of the break and the cosmic inflation thereof.
This is what is observed in the CMB.
This is what is observed in the CMB.
You already agreed that we do observe the immediate aftermath/culmination of the break and the cosmic inflation thereof.
You already agreed that we do observe the immediate aftermath/culmination of the break and the cosmic inflation thereof.
I'm repeating myself because things are not sinking into that head of yours.
I'm repeating myself because things are not sinking into that head of yours.
Then I asked you a question:
But because we cannot directly observe the initial break of the four fundamental forces of nature and the cosmic inflation of the massive conversion . . . we have no evidence or proof that the universe began to exist in the finite past?!
As for your second premise, as we can't see the BB, we have no way of knowing whether it's the beginning of something, or a continuation of something.
That's the first sensible thing you've said.
Questions:
If it's the beginning of something, what precisely is it the beginning of?If it's the continuation of something, what precisely is it the continuation of?