I agree. This is the problem with mandatory sentencing. The father and son definitely deserved to be found guilty and do time in prison. But, at the end of the day, there was a fight over the gun and it went off. Does that mean the son shouldn't go to prison? No, he needs to do at least 30 years. But the other two? I guess it all comes down to intent. Having not followed the case in terms of evidence presented, I don't know what was said, but it does seem harsh. Especially for the guy who took the video and wasn't armed. His lack of having a firearm would be a huge mitigating factor for me with regards to intent.
Georgia law and in fact the law of many states disagrees with you.
The getaway driver is just as guilty as the person who kills the clerk robbing the store. That is the idea that participation in a criminal event means you get to share the risk, and the penalties.
Thirty Years is the minimum you can serve before you can apply for Parole. Roddy is in his 50’s. I don’t think he’ll make it thirty years. But the sentence was the least that could be handed down with the convictions he got. The Judge was lenient as could be by the mandatory minimums, and suspended the sentence on the other convictions.
For example. Travis got Life without Parole plus 20 years.
Greg got Life without Parole plus 20 years.
Roddy got Life with Parole plus ten, but the ten were suspended. So as soon as he is eligible for parole, he can get it, assuming the board grants it. Which they might considering he would be eighty then.
Mandatory Minimums by the way, were a Conservative’s idea. The ability to take the ability of the Judge to be swayed by some i was abused and all that argument from the Convicted Criminal. So Mandatory Minimums became the normal across the nation, to show we were tough on crime.
Now, as long as this case has been in the news, I’ve said that the only one I saw getting a Not Guilty on the day, a slim chance, but a chance, was Roddy. I said the Jury might, and it was unlikely but possible. The jury might decide he had been acting in good faith, and not convict him. The others, I was certain they would be convicted