A Republican Farmer Asks ‘Well, Who’s Going to Milk the Cows?’ When those Immigrants form Trump's Shithole Nations are thrown out.

I live in the middle of a dairy farm area.
I grew up in a dairy farm area.
I've helped milk cows.
One of my neighbor's a few hoses down the road had one of his cows crawl through the fence to my backyard several weeks ago, helped him get her out and back into his pasture.

You on the other seem too much the townie, likely wouldn't know where to reach if milking a cow.
This is more you;
View attachment 1236825
Wrong.

You live in a world where stereotypes rule. Sad, but true. I have lived in rural areas and I've milked a cow (waaay back early teens). We're not all so ignorant as you believe us all to be, but you are -- al that ignorant
 
The H2b progrsm can be used to hire foreign farm workers

But the H2a program is aimed specifically at agriculture

Again, you are trolling and not responding to the story/news item.

When you people get stuck-on-stupid, it's like superglue on fingers and thumb.

maybe revisit starting @ the OP:

It's all political. It's divisive and it is meant to be. What is? The Immigration Issue. Many Administrations and Congresses had ample opportunity over the last 50 years to address the issue. When one side seeks "comprehensive" reform of immigration policies, the fights begin. It's as if it's a team sport where nobody wants the other side to win.


[ For two decades, Tim O’Harrow, 79, the family patriarch, has tried to persuade politicians he has voted for and donated to — most of them Republican — that they need to fix the nation’s broken immigration system.

But Washington has failed to make any meaningful changes, and Republican voters continue to be anti-immigration, particularly those in Wisconsin, a swing state where 95 percent of Republicans support mass deportation, according to a recent poll by Marquette University Law School.

That has left the O’Harrows in an uncomfortable place — stuck between what they see as an obvious truth, that immigrants are essential to America’s food supply, and a national political mood hurtling in the other direction.

And now, after generations of feeling at home in the Republican Party, the O’Harrows feel politically homeless.

“I don’t know that I’m a Republican anymore,” Tim said. “I don’t know what we are anymore.” ]


https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/27/us/politics/wisconsin-farmer-republicans-immigration-trump.html
On the farms themselves, the question of status is complicated. The O’Harrows have an I-9 federal work form filled out for every person on their staff, as called for by federal law. The form requires work authorization and identity documents, which can include a Social Security card and a driver’s license.

But workers can buy such documents on the black market. And while some states, like Wisconsin, do not issue driver’s licenses to undocumented immigrants, others, like neighboring Minnesota and Illinois, do, and employers can legally accept them.

Federal rules do not require farmers to be immigration sleuths. If an applicant’s documents “reasonably appear to be genuine,” the rules say, then they should be accepted. And penalties can be imposed if employers reject an applicant or their documents on the basis of a foreign-sounding name or accent.

...

Tim added cows, but soon had difficulty finding enough workers to care for them. It was hard and repetitive work, with long shifts that started before dawn, including on weekends. No one wanted to do it for what he could afford to pay, which at the time was several dollars above minimum wage. He hired students, single men, working mothers, people from a prison probation program.

“They would call five minutes before milking time, and say, ‘I’m not going to make it,’” Tim said. “Well, who’s going to milk the cows? We’re trying to run a business. It just wasn’t working.”

In 1999, the farm’s head herdsman went to a meeting about the labor problem. One dairyman recommended Mexican workers.



“He said, ‘Don’t talk about it, just do it,’” Tim recalled.

Eight days later, two workers signed on. The O’Harrows never looked back.

 
The H2b progrsm can be used to hire foreign farm workers

But the H2a program is aimed specifically at agriculture


snippet:

Immigrant Workers Arrive​

The O’Harrow farmworker who has been training Sullivan starts at 4 a.m., six days a week. He oversees the daily operation and the 39 workers as they tend the calves, keep the cows moving through the milking parlors, and feed them in the long barn, where, on this morning, two women were administering vaccines, even as the shots kept freezing in the cold.

Joel O’Harrow, Tim’s son, runs the farm. By 6 a.m., he is at the office — a repurposed building with an empty swimming pool in the middle — and starts handling problems. On this morning, he needed to make a decision about an older farmhand who had stopped working, because of trouble with his eyesight, but was still being paid.

The dairy industry is one of the most dependent on undocumented workers, according to David Bier, an immigration expert at the Cato Institute. Visas are available for farm work, but only if it is seasonal. Rank-and-file dairy workers do not qualify because of the year-round demands, despite the industry’s efforts to get them included.

A 2023 study by the School for Workers at the University of Wisconsin-Madison found that more than 10,000 undocumented immigrants perform roughly 70 percent of the labor on the state’s dairy farms.
 
Do you? Do you want american workers doing the job? Then pay...dont be cheap.
Do you understand economics ?
I'm suspecting you don't.
You appear as one of those ignorant left-winger that is clueless on wealth creation, money, how business runs, etc.
Labor is one of the costs involved in making a product or service. Increase what you pay for labor and that expense gets passed on into the cost of your product. Pay dairy workers more in wages and price of milk will have to increase.
 
It's all political. It's divisive and it is meant to be. What is? The Immigration Issue. Many Administrations and Congresses had ample opportunity over the last 50 years to address the issue. When one side seeks "comprehensive" reform of immigration policies, the fights begin. It's as if it's a team sport where nobody wants the other side to win.


[ For two decades, Tim O’Harrow, 79, the family patriarch, has tried to persuade politicians he has voted for and donated to — most of them Republican — that they need to fix the nation’s broken immigration system.

But Washington has failed to make any meaningful changes, and Republican voters continue to be anti-immigration, particularly those in Wisconsin, a swing state where 95 percent of Republicans support mass deportation, according to a recent poll by Marquette University Law School.

That has left the O’Harrows in an uncomfortable place — stuck between what they see as an obvious truth, that immigrants are essential to America’s food supply, and a national political mood hurtling in the other direction.

And now, after generations of feeling at home in the Republican Party, the O’Harrows feel politically homeless.

“I don’t know that I’m a Republican anymore,” Tim said. “I don’t know what we are anymore.” ]



The able bodied Democrat base can become farm hands.
 
15th post
.

God Bless Flyover Country! We've got plenty of worthy teens looking for jobs.

.
Again, you ignore the OP and the article:

Tim added cows, but soon had difficulty finding enough workers to care for them. It was hard and repetitive work, with long shifts that started before dawn, including on weekends. No one wanted to do it for what he could afford to pay, which at the time was several dollars above minimum wage. He hired students, single men, working mothers, people from a prison probation program.

“They would call five minutes before milking time, and say, ‘I’m not going to make it,’” Tim said. “Well, who’s going to milk the cows? We’re trying to run a business. It just wasn’t working.”

In 1999, the farm’s head herdsman went to a meeting about the labor problem. One dairyman recommended Mexican workers.
 
Back
Top Bottom