Trump Said This Policy Would Make Manhattan a ‘Ghost Town.’ As Usual, He Was Wrong.

Dante

simulacrum..facsimile..imitation..replica...copy
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
82,792
Reaction score
40,499
Points
2,300
Location
Rebellion Central
By The NYT Editorial Board - March 27, 2026

Trump Said This Policy Would Make Manhattan a ‘Ghost Town.’ He Was Wrong.​

It's incredible. A man who hasn't driven his own automobile in Manhattan in maybe his whole life time, is somehow a Stable Genius who knows what will and will not work with the average citizen.

I lived in NYC and remember how out of touch Donald Trump and people like him were with the average Newyorker. Even know, think about it: The man could not carry his hometown in an election. In politics, that is a sure sign of a Loser



[ Early last year, New York flipped a switch on an audacious system to charge drivers entering Midtown or Lower Manhattan, the first of its kind in the United States. Passenger cars with an E-ZPass had to pay $9 to enter Manhattan below 61st Street from morning until 9 p.m., with lower prices overnight and higher prices for larger vehicles.

To hear the furious objections and lawsuits at the time, it was as if the city and state wanted to return the island’s streets to horses and buggies. “It’s nothing more than a scam — a cash grab,” said Representative Mike Lawler, a Republican congressman from New York City’s northern suburbs. “A disaster,” said New Jersey’s governor at the time, Philip Murphy, a Democrat. “Businesses will flee,” warned Donald Trump, who was then president-elect and vowed to kill the plan when he took office. He predicted that it would be “virtually impossible for New York City to come back as long as the congestion tax is in effect.”

The scaremongers were wrong. Over its first 14 months, the congestion pricing system has exceeded even the high hopes of many supporters. It has reduced traffic, improved the quality of life and even provided a boost for businesses. Talk of killing it has faded. This month, a federal judge ruled that the Trump administration’s attempt to end the program was illegal.

While the program could still use some tweaks, its success should encourage some other large cities to consider their own congestion pricing plans as part of broader efforts to improve public transit
... ]

...
 
By The NYT Editorial Board - March 27, 2026

Trump Said This Policy Would Make Manhattan a ‘Ghost Town.’ He Was Wrong.​

It's incredible. A man who hasn't driven his own automobile in Manhattan in maybe his whole life time, is somehow a Stable Genius who knows what will and will not work with the average citizen.

I lived in NYC and remember how out of touch Donald Trump and people like him were with the average Newyorker. Even know, think about it: The man could not carry his hometown in an election. In politics, that is a sure sign of a Loser



[ Early last year, New York flipped a switch on an audacious system to charge drivers entering Midtown or Lower Manhattan, the first of its kind in the United States. Passenger cars with an E-ZPass had to pay $9 to enter Manhattan below 61st Street from morning until 9 p.m., with lower prices overnight and higher prices for larger vehicles.

To hear the furious objections and lawsuits at the time, it was as if the city and state wanted to return the island’s streets to horses and buggies. “It’s nothing more than a scam — a cash grab,” said Representative Mike Lawler, a Republican congressman from New York City’s northern suburbs. “A disaster,” said New Jersey’s governor at the time, Philip Murphy, a Democrat. “Businesses will flee,” warned Donald Trump, who was then president-elect and vowed to kill the plan when he took office. He predicted that it would be “virtually impossible for New York City to come back as long as the congestion tax is in effect.”

The scaremongers were wrong. Over its first 14 months, the congestion pricing system has exceeded even the high hopes of many supporters. It has reduced traffic, improved the quality of life and even provided a boost for businesses. Talk of killing it has faded. This month, a federal judge ruled that the Trump administration’s attempt to end the program was illegal.

While the program could still use some tweaks, its success should encourage some other large cities to consider their own congestion pricing plans as part of broader efforts to improve public transit
... ]

...


Wow, broad generalizations with zero statistical analysis to back it up. Typical of the NY slimes. One wonders how much the mass exodus from NY has contributed to their claims.

.
 
Wow, broad generalizations with zero statistical analysis to back it up. Typical of the NY slimes. One wonders how much the mass exodus from NY has contributed to their claims.
Wow! thank you for that .. uneducated reply

for OKTexas
Here’s how effective the system has been:

  • Less traffic. Each day, about 73,000 fewer cars enter Manhattan below 61st Street than before the system was in place. That is an 11 percent drop. “I never drive into the city anymore,” one Brooklyn resident told The Times. “I only take the subway. It’s a relief.” Overall, vehicles travel 4.5 percent faster within the zone — and much faster at key crossings. Car speeds are up 51 percent at the Holland Tunnel and 25 percent at the Lincoln Tunnel. Traffic has also eased in parts of Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and the suburbs, because fewer cars are moving through those neighborhoods to get to Manhattan.
  • More mass transit riders. About 300,000 more people rode the city subways each day last year than in 2024, an 8.9 percent increase. Ridership is also up on New York City’s buses — which are moving more quickly now — and on suburban railroads. The new system can also help the transit system in the future, because increased ridership and the new congestion fee bring in money that can be used for mass transit improvements and expansions. (The base congestion fee will rise from $9 to $12 in 2028 and $15 in 2031.)
  • A safer, quieter city. The number of people seriously injured in a car crash declined by 9 percent in the zone in 2025. Vehicle noise complaints are down 17 percent. “Fewer cars honking, fewer cars running red lights, fewer cars blocking crosswalks,” another Brooklyn resident told The Times. Air quality appears to be improving, too, although it is not clear how much of that is because of congestion pricing.
  • A better business environment. Defying Mr. Trump’s prediction that Manhattan would become a commercial “ghost town,” business revenue in the city rose more quickly last year than in the surrounding suburban counties. Congestion pricing is obviously not the only reason, but it has helped. The city is a more pleasant place to walk, and pedestrian traffic below 61st Street has risen.
 
Last edited:
Wow! thank you for that .. uneducated reply

for OKTexas
Here’s how effective the system has been:

  • Less traffic. Each day, about 73,000 fewer cars enter Manhattan below 61st Street than before the system was in place. That is an 11 percent drop. “I never drive into the city anymore,” one Brooklyn resident told The Times. “I only take the subway. It’s a relief.” Overall, vehicles travel 4.5 percent faster within the zone — and much faster at key crossings. Car speeds are up 51 percent at the Holland Tunnel and 25 percent at the Lincoln Tunnel. Traffic has also eased in parts of Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and the suburbs, because fewer cars are moving through those neighborhoods to get to Manhattan.
  • More mass transit riders. About 300,000 more people rode the city subways each day last year than in 2024, an 8.9 percent increase. Ridership is also up on New York City’s buses — which are moving more quickly now — and on suburban railroads. The new system can also help the transit system in the future, because increased ridership and the new congestion fee bring in money that can be used for mass transit improvements and expansions. (The base congestion fee will rise from $9 to $12 in 2028 and $15 in 2031.)
  • A safer, quieter city. The number of people seriously injured in a car crash declined by 9 percent in the zone in 2025. Vehicle noise complaints are down 17 percent. “Fewer cars honking, fewer cars running red lights, fewer cars blocking crosswalks,” another Brooklyn resident told The Times. Air quality appears to be improving, too, although it is not clear how much of that is because of congestion pricing.
  • A better business environment. Defying Mr. Trump’s prediction that Manhattan would become a commercial “ghost town,” business revenue in the city rose more quickly last year than in the surrounding suburban counties. Congestion pricing is obviously not the only reason, but it has helped. The city is a more pleasant place to walk, and pedestrian traffic below 61st Street has risen.


See, that wasn't so hard, just proves the old saying, the more you tax something, the less of it you'll get. Wonder when they'll be raising the subway fares, now they have a semi-captive ridership?

.

.
 
Wow, broad generalizations with zero statistical analysis to back it up. Typical of the NY slimes. One wonders how much the mass exodus from NY has contributed to their claims.

.
Where's Trump's statistical analysis back up his claim instead of talking out of his ass as usual?

It's absolutely mind boggeling how you MAGA rubes still support him despite the fact that the clown is 100% wrong about everything he babbles about.

Will you MAGA toadies EVER learn with this guy?

Today, I went to Staples to pick up a few gel pens & they were out of stock. Now, I know why. For chrissakes, leave some for the next guy, willya? :abgg2q.jpg:
 
See, that wasn't so hard, just proves the old saying, the more you tax something, the less of it you'll get. Wonder when they'll be raising the subway fares, now they have a semi-captive ridership?
The world you live in is a sad and poor substitute for reality
 
Where's Trump's statistical analysis back up his claim instead of talking out of his ass as usual?

It's absolutely mind boggeling how you MAGA rubes still support him despite the fact that the clown is 100% wrong about everything he babbles about.

Will you MAGA toadies EVER learn with this guy?

Today, I went to Staples to pick up a few gel pens & they were out of stock. Now, I know why. For chrissakes, leave some for the next guy, willya? :abgg2q.jpg:


Yeah, in about 3 years. Then you'll be calling another republican president a liar. When Trump first announced he was running for his first term, I said the one quality I liked about him, was his ability to piss off you dems. That really hasn't changed. LMAO

.
 
Oh, ok. Trump pisses off
Yeah, in about 3 years. Then you'll be calling another republican president a liar. When Trump first announced he was running for his first term, I said the one quality I liked about him, was his ability to piss off you dems. That really hasn't changed. LMAO

.
Oh, ok. Trump pisses off Dems so it's ok that he's a liar playing you for a fool & a conman.

Thanx for coming clean.
 
Democrats are pretending that New Yorkers like, no love, being thrown onto railroad tracks, be set on fire alive, be assaulted, robbed, have their businesses robbed out of existence. The business class and the middle class are leaving the city in droves and leaving the state chugging along. But, New York can still claim that more people are moving into the city than moving out. That's because commerce is leaving and the homeless immigrants are arriving.
 
Oh, ok. Trump pisses off

Oh, ok. Trump pisses off Dems so it's ok that he's a liar playing you for a fool & a conman.

Thanx for coming clean.


I'll have you know, I'm neither a liar or a conman. This thread is a perfect example of what I said, TDS gone to seed.

.
 
See, that wasn't so hard, just proves the old saying, the more you tax something, the less of it you'll get.
No shit, the point of pricing congestion is to decrease it. Hard to find public policies that are as unambiguously successful as this one has been. Less traffic and faster rides and fewer traffic fatalities, greater public transit use and less crime in the subway, more foot traffic and retail activity, reduced pollution, new revenue for transit improvements. Win after win since it was implemented.
 
No shit, the point of pricing congestion is to decrease it. Hard to find public policies that are as unambiguously successful as this one has been. Less traffic and faster rides and fewer traffic fatalities, greater public transit use and less crime in the subway, more foot traffic and retail activity, reduced pollution, new revenue for transit improvements. Win after win since it was implemented.


We'll see what the public thinks about it after the next two scheduled price increases. BTW, I haven't seen any evidence of lower crime on the subway.

.
 
15th post
Wow! thank you for that .. uneducated reply

for OKTexas
Here’s how effective the system has been:

  • Less traffic. Each day, about 73,000 fewer cars enter Manhattan below 61st Street than before the system was in place. That is an 11 percent drop. “I never drive into the city anymore,” one Brooklyn resident told The Times. “I only take the subway. It’s a relief.” Overall, vehicles travel 4.5 percent faster within the zone — and much faster at key crossings. Car speeds are up 51 percent at the Holland Tunnel and 25 percent at the Lincoln Tunnel. Traffic has also eased in parts of Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and the suburbs, because fewer cars are moving through those neighborhoods to get to Manhattan.
  • More mass transit riders. About 300,000 more people rode the city subways each day last year than in 2024, an 8.9 percent increase. Ridership is also up on New York City’s buses — which are moving more quickly now — and on suburban railroads. The new system can also help the transit system in the future, because increased ridership and the new congestion fee bring in money that can be used for mass transit improvements and expansions. (The base congestion fee will rise from $9 to $12 in 2028 and $15 in 2031.)
  • A safer, quieter city. The number of people seriously injured in a car crash declined by 9 percent in the zone in 2025. Vehicle noise complaints are down 17 percent. “Fewer cars honking, fewer cars running red lights, fewer cars blocking crosswalks,” another Brooklyn resident told The Times. Air quality appears to be improving, too, although it is not clear how much of that is because of congestion pricing.
  • A better business environment. Defying Mr. Trump’s prediction that Manhattan would become a commercial “ghost town,” business revenue in the city rose more quickly last year than in the surrounding suburban counties. Congestion pricing is obviously not the only reason, but it has helped. The city is a more pleasant place to walk, and pedestrian traffic below 61st Street has risen.
You have a source for these "facts" ?
We to assume they are in your OP link ?

BTW, I'm not paying a fee to NYslimes to read their pravda. Do you have a non-pay to read source ?

Or a different link ?
Did you just pull these out of your rectum ?

This would suggest it may be too soon to make a clear assessment;
  • (The base congestion fee will rise from $9 to $12 in 2028 and $15 in 2031.)
 
Last edited:
By The NYT Editorial Board - March 27, 2026

Trump Said This Policy Would Make Manhattan a ‘Ghost Town.’ He Was Wrong.​

It's incredible. A man who hasn't driven his own automobile in Manhattan in maybe his whole life time, is somehow a Stable Genius who knows what will and will not work with the average citizen.

I lived in NYC and remember how out of touch Donald Trump and people like him were with the average Newyorker. Even know, think about it: The man could not carry his hometown in an election. In politics, that is a sure sign of a Loser



[ Early last year, New York flipped a switch on an audacious system to charge drivers entering Midtown or Lower Manhattan, the first of its kind in the United States. Passenger cars with an E-ZPass had to pay $9 to enter Manhattan below 61st Street from morning until 9 p.m., with lower prices overnight and higher prices for larger vehicles.

To hear the furious objections and lawsuits at the time, it was as if the city and state wanted to return the island’s streets to horses and buggies. “It’s nothing more than a scam — a cash grab,” said Representative Mike Lawler, a Republican congressman from New York City’s northern suburbs. “A disaster,” said New Jersey’s governor at the time, Philip Murphy, a Democrat. “Businesses will flee,” warned Donald Trump, who was then president-elect and vowed to kill the plan when he took office. He predicted that it would be “virtually impossible for New York City to come back as long as the congestion tax is in effect.”

The scaremongers were wrong. Over its first 14 months, the congestion pricing system has exceeded even the high hopes of many supporters. It has reduced traffic, improved the quality of life and even provided a boost for businesses. Talk of killing it has faded. This month, a federal judge ruled that the Trump administration’s attempt to end the program was illegal.

While the program could still use some tweaks, its success should encourage some other large cities to consider their own congestion pricing plans as part of broader efforts to improve public transit
... ]

...
Oh I am sure congestion has decreased, people are businesses are fleeing NYC

 
Trump Said This Policy Would Make Manhattan a ‘Ghost Town.’
1775060782202.webp
 
You have a source for these "facts" ?
We to assume they are in your OP link ?

BTW, I'm not paying a fee to NYslimes to read their pravda. Do you have a non-pay to read source ?

Or a different link ?
Did you just pull these out of your rectum ?

This would suggest it may be too soon to make a clear assessment;
  • (The base congestion fee will rise from $9 to $12 in 2028 and $15 in 2031.)
Stay ignorant. I don't believe normal people believe you can rejoin the human race
 
Back
Top Bottom