It wasn't my point it was yours
And the Indians did see here >>>>
Ancient Smelter Used Wind To Make High-Grade Steel - NYTimes.com
But you also made a distinction. I couldn't be simply "steel" it had to be the superior "carbonized steel"
And Here you have it, the Indians beat the Africans >>>
Ancient Smelter Used Wind To Make High-Grade Steel - NYTimes.com
By your own standard the Indians of 4000 BC were superior to the Africans of 4000 BC. Of course, where are they today? No, we know that Western Culture Dominates today.
The Indians didn't make carbonized steel. They made ironware. Your link is bogus or in error like every link you seem to find. Do you understand the difference between iron and steel? Iron is an element. Steel is a compound which is produced when iron is mixed with carbon at a certain percentage. The Hayas did it first. I never said it couldn't be steel. I merely specified carbonized steel so you would get a clue that iron is not steel. Also you asked for an example. What was your point in asking for an example? You said by me providing the example you would be able to prove the concept of a superior culture. Why havent you done that?
I just found it funny that of all the objects you deem worthy of a superior culture you sought it necessary to go back to "such a culture would have to have been the first to create carbonized steel." Of course, this is your only test for a superior culture. No other factors were listed. You said this because you thought you had twisted the argument in your favor by assuming that naturally I would need to admit the superiority of modern black culture because some small non-influential tribe who accidently stumbled upon carbonized steel by virtue of accidently, and very lightly, carbonizing it via the method they used to heat it up with primitive organic stoves and never knew what they had nor ever found themselves able to produce it to a higher carbonized scale in which they could become a viable power. Once we found that Indians did the same thing, and even did it at a rate of higher carbonization, you didn't know what to do with yourself. Indeed, the Africans weren't attempting to carbonize steel, nor did they ever find the virtues thereof. The light carbonization that they were able to achieve was simply an offset of the manner of which they heated it. At no time did an African say "oh, look, we just made steel." No, they thought they were dealing with the same substance not knowing the deference between the two.
Now, how do we know that they invented this? One of two methods. We have primitive tools and "oral tradition." One is valid, the other, it's garbage!
Now what does this say about modern black culture? Absolutely nothing. Indeed, it is funny how far Afrocentrics are willing to go to promote the achievements of ancestors that may or may have not been theirs so as to assign a feeling of self worth as if they could rest on their laurels. Indeed, there is nothing more of a cop-out than to attribute the achievements of others or an individual to yourself. It only breeds further ignorance as it encourages others to do the same.
To consider a culture to be superior to other cultures you must analyze a culture comparatively to other cultures of a time. Those who wish to ask about modern cultures will compare modern cultures to modern cultures. Those modern cultures that are among the least civilized and most ill-advanced will often object and look back as far as they can to find proof in the past of how superior they are today. In your case, you engaged in a very poor attempt via an example 2000 years ago. By any standard, both in Africa today and among African Americans today, black cultures have proven to foster the least advancement, and in the case where they are the minority, they foster regression from the advancement of others they did not create. This is in direct contrast to Asians who, despite being a minority in the US, fosters the admirable cultural attribute of respect for education and out preform every other demographic thereof. Nevertheless, blacks are not Asians and blacks are less likely to adopt the working model of others and zealously defend their ignorance.
Give it up. The reason why Western Civilization is among the most advanced today is their propensity to adapt their culture in light of observing others. Blacks, on the other hand, will defend black culture no matter what, often ignoring objects from other cultures they should adopt so as to spitefully preserve the indefensible against influence of people they hate. Indeed, everything advanced is white, they hate whites, so they refuse to adopt advancement. This is the current state of black America and post colonial Africa.
Note: I doubt he will actually read this. He will attack me with some non-response and the ever prevalent laughing smiley which he believes give him license to ignore fact and reason.