- Moderator
- #21
If you don't see the difference between burning perceived evil at the stake and a fight against being forced to redefine marriage then you're out of your mind.
Witches weren't trying to force their values on people. Heck, they didn't even really exist there.
There is a huge difference between criminal punishment for behavior and retaining civil traditions and values. The two aren't even comparable
It would appear that you didn’t read my post very carefully, or understand it very well. The point is that the same mind set, the same dynamics are involved when a minority is demonized and vilified, whether or not it involves actual violence against them. I call it the continuum of intolerance. They are not distinct or mutually exclusive issues. And by the way, acts of violence have been committed against LGBT people in this country and even more so in other parts of the world.
Secondly, if you want to say that marriage has been redefined you are perfectly welcome to do so. I prefer to say that it was simply broadened to include another group. It really doesn’t matter. These are just words. The fact is that anyone who still believes that marriage is between a man and a woman is free to continue to do so and act accordingly. Everyone defines the meaning of marriage for themselves. Those who are so bothered by it being more inclusive need to take a good hard look at their own relationships to try to understand why they are so threatened by why other people do.
You’re right to say that Witches- who were indeed real in the minds of the colonist- were not “forcing their values on anyone", but neither are gays. Anyone who is so weak minded as to let someone else influence what they think and believe has serious problems.
In addition, the behavior and tactics that I have documented go beyond voicing opposition to same sex marriage. If they had a legitimate argument against it, they would be able to oppose it in a civil manner. Instead, they resort to lies and distortions, intended to drive gay people back into the shadows.
Lastly, you mentioned “a huge difference between criminal punishment for behavior and retaining civil traditions and values.” Let me remind you that these same right wing nuts that I have highlighted here do in fact bemoan the decriminalization of homosexuality. Again, the rhetoric goes way beyond opposition to marriage equality. And as far as values go, logical fallacies in the form of an appeal to tradition do not work-either philosophically or legally.
In other words, "I can't refute you so you're stupid."
Much easier to just say that instead of creating straw men to pretend you are saying more. Saves us all time.