SSDD
Gold Member
- Nov 6, 2012
- 16,672
- 1,966
- 280
Oh it's all over the abortion threads. The question that comes up again and again is: if it's a sin to abort an embryo why is it not a sin to spill your seed on the ground?
That sounds more like a religious argument than a scientific one and has nothing whatsoever to do with killing a living human being. It is hard to get people to change their religious beliefs...as evidenced here on the environment forum...people who believe in man made climate change believe with religious fervor...they have to believe because there is precious little empirical evidence to actually create informed certainty. You can point out the failures of the hypothesis, ask for observed, measured data that they can't produce over and over again, point out the obvious flaws in the models, etc. etc. etc...and they continue to believe...
Belief in something that can't be demonstrated with observations and measurements simply is not rational...I of course it isn't proper to say that such beliefs are wrong...especially in spiritual matters where faith and belief are really all there is...even atheists "believe" in something that they can no more prove than religious zealots...in matters of science, however, and arguments on scientific topics, faith and belief simply are not rational..if you can't provide observed, measured evidence in sufficient quantity to back up your belief, then you really don't hold a scientifically valid position
Human development is a matter of science, not of faith.
Yep...once fertilization is complete, you have a developing human being...one that will continue to develop in one form or another till the day he or she dies...before fertilization, you have cells from your own body...cells that only have your own DNA, cells that have little more importance than toenail clippings...while they have the potential to be part of human development...alone, they are just your cells...if you start getting into what you do with them, and whether that is right or wrong, you have left the realm of science and entered the realm of morality...
That is the realm of faith...and faith is hard to break...again...look at the people who believe so fervently in man made global warming that they are willing to destroy economies..hurt poor people who really can't afford their solutions in terrible ways, ruin business, take financial security away from families...all for the sake of what they believe with no observed, measured, empirical evidence to support those beliefs. People will behave in most irrational ways in support of what they believe...stick to the science and keep pointing out that one involves observed, measured data and the other doesn't.