Billy_Bob
Diamond Member
Dr Mann refuses to give up his data and methodology. He is hiding his work from scrutiny. No reputable scientist will do this. Many peer reviewed papers show his work debunked, but until he shares his data and methodology it will remain a disputed work.Then you will have no problem showing me a legitimate standard-issue peer reviewed journal of significant value that supports you claim that it has been thoroughly debunked.
(I know you won't be able to do so and you won't)
Manns inclusion of the instrument record (one year data point plots) on a long-term proxy record using 50–250-year point plots make it scientific fraud of the worst kind. IF we take the last 250 years and place that point into one point the hockey stick vanishes. That is the deception.
You can play games with Mann's work, but he lost a lawsuit over it and has yet to produce the data and methods as demanded by the court. You want to tell me why?