Israel attacks civilians

when you talk of "law of armed conflict" whose law are you talking about? some war college nonsense? something you got from tom clancy? something that's actually been codified by treaty between nations. don't forget that fighting out of uniform may be what won us our independance.

last summer i saw a videotape of an israeli unit in gaza hosing down civilians who were clearly non-combatant. there have been repeated accusations of kidnapping and other improper actions taken against palestinian people.

admittedly, the media sources on both sides of the issue seem to be highly questionable.

the libel dodge is just that --- a dodge that apologists for the bad behavior of a segment of the children of israel love to use. just scream anti-semitic blood libel anytime there's an accusation that the israeli government cannot plausibly deny.

genocide is still genocide and the extremists on both sides of this conflict see that as the only real solution to the conflict.

to them both i say DAYENU!

Pallies and other Arab trash have been undergoing a population explosion since 1948, when the Arab population totaled 70 million. Today, the Arab population is 350 million with projections of 400 million in coming years.

Thus, your claim of genocide is inane.

Arabs have been attempting genocide of Jews since the creation of Islam in the 7th century, when Muhammad exterminated Jews from Arabia.

Qur'an 33:26...
Allah made the Jews leave their homes by terrorizing them so that you killed some and made many captive. And He made you inherit their lands, their homes, and their wealth. He gave you a country you had not traversed before.
 
you ducked the main question which was what are you citing when you quote something as being a "law of armed conflict"?

the claim i made about the extremists from both sides seeking genocide is not inane. go talk to a chabad rabbi about what he thinks should happen in israel. another good source is a not insignificant number of american jews with dual citizenship who have served in the IDF.

many of these people do not see any other solution to the conflict but to kill all the palestinians. granted the palestinians and other arabs have been pretty vocal about killing the jews off, but i must invoke golda again and remind you that killing is one of the least desirable behaviors any human can exhibit.
 
you ducked the main question which was what are you citing when you quote something as being a "law of armed conflict"?

the claim i made about the extremists from both sides seeking genocide is not inane. go talk to a chabad rabbi about what he thinks should happen in israel. another good source is a not insignificant number of american jews with dual citizenship who have served in the IDF.

many of these people do not see any other solution to the conflict but to kill all the palestinians. granted the palestinians and other arabs have been pretty vocal about killing the jews off, but i must invoke golda again and remind you that killing is one of the least desirable behaviors any human can exhibit.

I duck nothing.
There is a wide-ranging body of legal provisions under the umbrella of the law of international armed conflict, including Hague and Geneva law.

The number of Jewish extremists is de minimis. Jews are not teaching one another that jihad is life's highest calling as in Islam.

The Old Testament does not exhort Jews into mass murder of non-Jews, as the Quran demands of non-Muslims..

Trying to compare Jewish extremists with IslamoNazis is dumb.
 
i am not in a position to argue in favor of the majority of islamic people who almost certainly do not believe or support the jihadists.

i am also not going to try and tell you you are wrong about the old testament vs. koran --- it seems that you have armed yourself well with the relevant passages in the koran and overlooked some significant slaughters in the old testament.
 
i am not in a position to argue in favor of the majority of islamic people who almost certainly do not believe or support the jihadists.

How do you know? You're a mind-reader?

i am also not going to try and tell you you are wrong about the old testament vs. koran --- it seems that you have armed yourself well with the relevant passages in the koran and overlooked some significant slaughters in the old testament.

I'm "armed" with having read the Quran in its entirety as well as authoritative commentary on same, such as that by Ismail ibn Kathir.

The Old Testament *depicts* violence, it does not exhort Jews to go out and murder non-Jews.

The Quran exhorts Muslims to kill non-Muslims. Of this there is no debate. Ask bin Ladin.
 
most people do not want to participate in nationalistic or theocratic violence. never have. never will. the majority of all peoples, regardless of their country's ideology, just want to live comfortable lives in peace.

warmongering is something that has always been the sport of a tiny minority and the fools who buy into their agenda.
 
here's a fresh incident. unfortunately the video is at btselem and you don't believe them to be valid (just out of curiosity what's your take on alex jones and Alex Jones' Infowars: There's a war on for your mind! ?)


Palestinian demonstrator shot dead by Israeli army
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Big News Network.com Saturday 1st May, 2010

A Palestinian youth, Ahmad Sliman Salem Dib, 19, died Wednesday after Israeli security forces shot him, in the morning, near the border fence with the Gaza Strip, while he was participating in a demonstration there.

The incident was caught on video by Muhammad Sabah, a field researcher for Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem.

The video shows a group of Palestinian and international activists walking in procession from the al-Shaja'iya neighborhood in the eastern Gaza Strip to the border fence with Israel.

The youths, who were unarmed, reached a distance of a few dozen meters from the border, and stood facing an Israeli military post. The footage shows a soldier standing by the post. Some of the protestors threw stones at the post. A single shot is heard. Ahmad was shot and wounded. He was taken by ambulance to Shifaa Hospital in Gaza City, but died of his wounds later that day.

An Israeli army spokesperson said in a statement that “the force acted in order to distance the demonstrators and fired with the aim of distancing them. The area by the border fence is a combat zone and the presence of terrorist elements there endangers the residents of Israel and the security forces operating in the area.”

Using live fire “for distancing” is illegal, says B'thelem. The footage clearly shows that the demonstrators posed no threat to residents of Israel or to security forces. B’Tselem says it has documented many events in which Israeli security forces have used lethal means against stone-throwers and unarmed demonstrators in the West Bank. Since May 2008, at least eight Palestinians have been killed by security forces during demonstrations. Some of them were shot with live ammunition, while others were killed by rubber-coated metal bullets and gas canisters fired directly at them.

In addition, B’Tselem says it has gathered testimonies in recent years indicating that security forces have declared broad areas near the border fence between Israel and the Gaza Strip as “death zones”, in which open-fire regulations permit firing at anyone entering them, even if the person poses no life threat. Some of these areas closed to Palestinians are cultivated agricultural areas that are a source of livelihood for many Gazans. The present wave of demonstrations is part of a popular movement against the “death zones." In the past, officials denied that these areas had been closed to Palestinians, yet today, this procedure has become official policy and the army has even distributed pamphlets on the matter throughout the Gaza Strip, B'Tselem says.

The B'Tselem video can be viewed at:
B'Tselem - The Gaza Strip - 28 April 2010: Youth shot this morning by Israeli security forces on Gaza border dies
 
here's a fresh incident. unfortunately the video is at btselem and you don't believe them to be valid (just out of curiosity what's your take on alex jones and Alex Jones' Infowars: There's a war on for your mind! ?)


Palestinian demonstrator shot dead by Israeli army
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Big News Network.com Saturday 1st May, 2010

A Palestinian youth, Ahmad Sliman Salem Dib, 19, died Wednesday after Israeli security forces shot him, in the morning, near the border fence with the Gaza Strip, while he was participating in a demonstration there.

The incident was caught on video by Muhammad Sabah, a field researcher for Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem.

The video shows a group of Palestinian and international activists walking in procession from the al-Shaja'iya neighborhood in the eastern Gaza Strip to the border fence with Israel.

The youths, who were unarmed, reached a distance of a few dozen meters from the border, and stood facing an Israeli military post. The footage shows a soldier standing by the post. Some of the protestors threw stones at the post. A single shot is heard. Ahmad was shot and wounded. He was taken by ambulance to Shifaa Hospital in Gaza City, but died of his wounds later that day.

An Israeli army spokesperson said in a statement that “the force acted in order to distance the demonstrators and fired with the aim of distancing them. The area by the border fence is a combat zone and the presence of terrorist elements there endangers the residents of Israel and the security forces operating in the area.”

Using live fire “for distancing” is illegal, says B'thelem. The footage clearly shows that the demonstrators posed no threat to residents of Israel or to security forces. B’Tselem says it has documented many events in which Israeli security forces have used lethal means against stone-throwers and unarmed demonstrators in the West Bank. Since May 2008, at least eight Palestinians have been killed by security forces during demonstrations. Some of them were shot with live ammunition, while others were killed by rubber-coated metal bullets and gas canisters fired directly at them.

In addition, B’Tselem says it has gathered testimonies in recent years indicating that security forces have declared broad areas near the border fence between Israel and the Gaza Strip as “death zones”, in which open-fire regulations permit firing at anyone entering them, even if the person poses no life threat. Some of these areas closed to Palestinians are cultivated agricultural areas that are a source of livelihood for many Gazans. The present wave of demonstrations is part of a popular movement against the “death zones." In the past, officials denied that these areas had been closed to Palestinians, yet today, this procedure has become official policy and the army has even distributed pamphlets on the matter throughout the Gaza Strip, B'Tselem says.

The B'Tselem video can be viewed at:
B'Tselem - The Gaza Strip - 28 April 2010: Youth shot this morning by Israeli security forces on Gaza border dies

Completely bogus source and B'Tselem has a long history of anti-Israel bias.

There are numerous Arab-dominated areas of Judea and Samaria where Jews are prohibited and in danger of being shot if they enter.
 
Last edited:
here's a fresh incident. unfortunately the video is at btselem and you don't believe them to be valid (just out of curiosity what's your take on alex jones and Alex Jones' Infowars: There's a war on for your mind! ?)


Palestinian demonstrator shot dead by Israeli army
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Big News Network.com Saturday 1st May, 2010

A Palestinian youth, Ahmad Sliman Salem Dib, 19, died Wednesday after Israeli security forces shot him, in the morning, near the border fence with the Gaza Strip, while he was participating in a demonstration there.

The incident was caught on video by Muhammad Sabah, a field researcher for Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem.

The video shows a group of Palestinian and international activists walking in procession from the al-Shaja'iya neighborhood in the eastern Gaza Strip to the border fence with Israel.

The youths, who were unarmed, reached a distance of a few dozen meters from the border, and stood facing an Israeli military post. The footage shows a soldier standing by the post. Some of the protestors threw stones at the post. A single shot is heard. Ahmad was shot and wounded. He was taken by ambulance to Shifaa Hospital in Gaza City, but died of his wounds later that day.

An Israeli army spokesperson said in a statement that “the force acted in order to distance the demonstrators and fired with the aim of distancing them. The area by the border fence is a combat zone and the presence of terrorist elements there endangers the residents of Israel and the security forces operating in the area.”

Using live fire “for distancing” is illegal, says B'thelem. The footage clearly shows that the demonstrators posed no threat to residents of Israel or to security forces. B’Tselem says it has documented many events in which Israeli security forces have used lethal means against stone-throwers and unarmed demonstrators in the West Bank. Since May 2008, at least eight Palestinians have been killed by security forces during demonstrations. Some of them were shot with live ammunition, while others were killed by rubber-coated metal bullets and gas canisters fired directly at them.

In addition, B’Tselem says it has gathered testimonies in recent years indicating that security forces have declared broad areas near the border fence between Israel and the Gaza Strip as “death zones”, in which open-fire regulations permit firing at anyone entering them, even if the person poses no life threat. Some of these areas closed to Palestinians are cultivated agricultural areas that are a source of livelihood for many Gazans. The present wave of demonstrations is part of a popular movement against the “death zones." In the past, officials denied that these areas had been closed to Palestinians, yet today, this procedure has become official policy and the army has even distributed pamphlets on the matter throughout the Gaza Strip, B'Tselem says.

The B'Tselem video can be viewed at:
B'Tselem - The Gaza Strip - 28 April 2010: Youth shot this morning by Israeli security forces on Gaza border dies

Completely bogus source and B'Tselem has a long history of anti-Israel bias.

There are numerous Arab-dominated areas of Judea and Samaria where Jews are prohibited and in danger of being shot if they enter.

methinks its time for you do show a little more than simple declaratives that dismiss anything you don't agree with. sure looked to me like b'tselem has some pretty strong credentials. what are yours other than you've read the koran cover to cover and think the zionists shit doesn't stink?

that a rock throwing was responded to at a demonstration with deadly force seems to be an indisputable fact here. i suppose that justifies the act?
 
here's a fresh incident. unfortunately the video is at btselem and you don't believe them to be valid (just out of curiosity what's your take on alex jones and Alex Jones' Infowars: There's a war on for your mind! ?)


Palestinian demonstrator shot dead by Israeli army
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Big News Network.com Saturday 1st May, 2010

A Palestinian youth, Ahmad Sliman Salem Dib, 19, died Wednesday after Israeli security forces shot him, in the morning, near the border fence with the Gaza Strip, while he was participating in a demonstration there.

The incident was caught on video by Muhammad Sabah, a field researcher for Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem.

The video shows a group of Palestinian and international activists walking in procession from the al-Shaja'iya neighborhood in the eastern Gaza Strip to the border fence with Israel.

The youths, who were unarmed, reached a distance of a few dozen meters from the border, and stood facing an Israeli military post. The footage shows a soldier standing by the post. Some of the protestors threw stones at the post. A single shot is heard. Ahmad was shot and wounded. He was taken by ambulance to Shifaa Hospital in Gaza City, but died of his wounds later that day.

An Israeli army spokesperson said in a statement that “the force acted in order to distance the demonstrators and fired with the aim of distancing them. The area by the border fence is a combat zone and the presence of terrorist elements there endangers the residents of Israel and the security forces operating in the area.”

Using live fire “for distancing” is illegal, says B'thelem. The footage clearly shows that the demonstrators posed no threat to residents of Israel or to security forces. B’Tselem says it has documented many events in which Israeli security forces have used lethal means against stone-throwers and unarmed demonstrators in the West Bank. Since May 2008, at least eight Palestinians have been killed by security forces during demonstrations. Some of them were shot with live ammunition, while others were killed by rubber-coated metal bullets and gas canisters fired directly at them.

In addition, B’Tselem says it has gathered testimonies in recent years indicating that security forces have declared broad areas near the border fence between Israel and the Gaza Strip as “death zones”, in which open-fire regulations permit firing at anyone entering them, even if the person poses no life threat. Some of these areas closed to Palestinians are cultivated agricultural areas that are a source of livelihood for many Gazans. The present wave of demonstrations is part of a popular movement against the “death zones." In the past, officials denied that these areas had been closed to Palestinians, yet today, this procedure has become official policy and the army has even distributed pamphlets on the matter throughout the Gaza Strip, B'Tselem says.

The B'Tselem video can be viewed at:
B'Tselem - The Gaza Strip - 28 April 2010: Youth shot this morning by Israeli security forces on Gaza border dies

Completely bogus source and B'Tselem has a long history of anti-Israel bias.

There are numerous Arab-dominated areas of Judea and Samaria where Jews are prohibited and in danger of being shot if they enter.

methinks its time for you do show a little more than simple declaratives that dismiss anything you don't agree with. sure looked to me like b'tselem has some pretty strong credentials. what are yours other than you've read the koran cover to cover and think the zionists shit doesn't stink?

that a rock throwing was responded to at a demonstration with deadly force seems to be an indisputable fact here. i suppose that justifies the act?

Time for you to be better informed.

Middle East NGOs, notably B'Tselem, rely on Arab "eyewitnesses" with an anti-Israel agenda that renders their "findings" unreliable. Hamas and other Muslim terrorist groups watch over such eyewitnesses and any "accounts" that are not anti-Israel are deemed collaboration with Israel placing the so-called eyewitnesses in danger of being executed.

Furthermore, the donors funding these NGOs usually have an anti-Israel tilt who expect those groups to collect anti-Israel "information", further discrediting their findings.

Now, even you know.
 
what is an "NGO"? if the answer is news gathering organization, i will probably want to vomit.

sorry but what i see about b'tselem does not agree with what you are claiming. their donor list didn't look particularly anti-israel and their statement of mission seems pretty righteous and straightforward.

what constitutes a reliable news source in the middle east to you? since avrum natan retired there seems to be a vacuum under the heading of "non-partisan" news reporting from the region
 
what is an "NGO"? if the answer is news gathering organization, i will probably want to vomit.

sorry but what i see about b'tselem does not agree with what you are claiming. their donor list didn't look particularly anti-israel and their statement of mission seems pretty righteous and straightforward.

what constitutes a reliable news source in the middle east to you? since avrum natan retired there seems to be a vacuum under the heading of "non-partisan" news reporting from the region

NGO=Non-Governmental Organization.

You don't even know what "NGO" is and your views on B'Tselem are equally uninformed

Do your homework before you post.
 
Last edited:
so i am uninformed on an obscure piece of alphabet soup, BFD

you on the other hand have not given me anything of substance to back up your opinion of b'tselem. until you do, their mission statement and donor list do not support your claims.

while we're at it, would you care to give me a list of news organizations you trust to provide unbiased objective reporting on events in the region? i daresay you will be hard pressed to name one that reports on rather than tries to influence the news.
 
so i am uninformed on an obscure piece of alphabet soup, BFD

you on the other hand have not given me anything of substance to back up your opinion of b'tselem. until you do, their mission statement and donor list do not support your claims.

while we're at it, would you care to give me a list of news organizations you trust to provide unbiased objective reporting on events in the region? i daresay you will be hard pressed to name one that reports on rather than tries to influence the news.

I just gave you 2 significant reasons that B'Tselem is discredited.

That you choose to ignore them is reflective of either your inability to comprehend or lack of desire to do so because it demolishes your viewpoint.
 
you gave nothing to support your claim. saying something is just so does not make it just so especially when it comes from the console of someone who is clearly biased.

the only thing you are succeeding at demolishing is my idea that there is some hope for the jews to regain grace and fulfill the covenant of the doctrine of love. so long as they refuse to recognize the rights of others and insist on winning a shooting war, the whole world loses.
 
you gave nothing to support your claim. saying something is just so does not make it just so especially when it comes from the console of someone who is clearly biased.

the only thing you are succeeding at demolishing is my idea that there is some hope for the jews to regain grace and fulfill the covenant of the doctrine of love. so long as they refuse to recognize the rights of others and insist on winning a shooting war, the whole world loses.

Now, you're reverting to idiot mode. I just informed you of B'Tselem's inherently flawed information-gathering methodology.

Are you just plain dumb?

Goldstone, himself, who relied heavily on B'Tselem, has conceded his report is discredited and could not even be admitted into court.
 
and you are reverting to name calling instead of showing your evidence. just because you say something is true does not make it true. show your evidence otherwise all you've given me is empty claims.
 
and you are reverting to name calling instead of showing your evidence. just because you say something is true does not make it true. show your evidence otherwise all you've given me is empty claims.

You have embarrassed yourself in not even being familiar with the term NGO, in attempting to pass yourself off as knowledgeable about...NGOs.

You're either stupid or ignorant...or, both.
 
and you are reverting to name calling instead of showing your evidence. just because you say something is true does not make it true. show your evidence otherwise all you've given me is empty claims.

You have embarrassed yourself in not even being familiar with the term NGO, in attempting to pass yourself off as knowledgeable about...NGOs.

You're either stupid or ignorant...or, both.

therein lies the difference between us. i have never been and never will be ashamed to admit that i don't know something. i also would never claim to know something without giving credit to the source of that knowledge.

since i have joined usmb, i have observed you to effectively derail the point of this and every other thread related to the middle east with your profane, vulgar, racist judgemental declarations.

you are such a fool that you don`t even realize what a dim bulb you look like to someone like me who has read hundreds of these threads on dozens of sites most days for the past thirty years.

you are cosmic food, sonny. i want to be there when you meet HASHEM you ignorant putz.

you're a zit waiting to be popped.
 
RAFAH, (PIC)-- Israeli occupation forces (IOF) razed to the ground Addehnia mosque in Rafah city, south of the Gaza Strip, on Tuesday and bulldozed agricultural lands in the same area.

Local sources told the PIC reporter that IOF soldiers mounting 15 army jeeps and military bulldozers advanced hundreds of meters east of Rafah and bulldozed lands in Addehnia area and leveled the abandoned mosque amidst random firing.

Meanwhile, large numbers of Israeli border police on Tuesday destroyed a number of homes and property for Palestinian citizens in the Negev area, occupied in 1948.

IOF troops raze Rafah mosque
 

Forum List

Back
Top