If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America...?

If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?
Bass-ackwards analogy.
Jews only got about 1% of the Middle East, Arabs got 99% and rule over Other groups like the Kurds.

Israel is Less than 1/10th the size of America's Indian Reservations. (8000 sq miles vs 88,000 sq miles)

abu afak/mbig
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?


I have a better suggestion.

Instead of focusing on a tiny little minority that has one minute sliver of land to call their own, why don't you focus on improving yourself, instead, so you won't need your imaginary bogeyman?

None of that was the question.

The contention has been made that the Jews are the original inhabitants of Palestine, so it rightfully belongs to them.

Why does that rule NOT apply when it comes to American Indians?






But that is not the question, that is the Jew haters stance to cloud reality

The reality is the Jews were granted 23% of Palestine for their NATIONal home by the lands legal sovereign owners, and the islamonazi Jew haters don't think that international laws should ever work on the side of the Jews
 
Hebrews are unknown in history, but American Indians are historical. No ancient history mentions Hebrews.
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?
Whether Jews have diving rights to Israel or not, none of that implicates them in doing anything illegal or unfair to any other people. How Jews came back to the Holy Land is well documented. The only ones who have problems with that are Muslims who hate Jews no matter who they are or where they live.

American Indians are not the great victims of humanity. Again, you cannot tell these stories in two paragraphs so do not expect it.

Well me I'm not a fan of Islam. But I am a fan of justice.

Why does the rule NOT apply to the American Indians?






Because the looney left don't want it to work that way
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?
Bass-ackwards analogy.
Jews only got about 1% of the Middle East, Arabs got 99% and rule over Other groups like the Kurds.

Israel is Less than 1/10th the size of America's Indian Reservations. (8000 sq miles vs 88,000 sq miles)

abu afak/mbig

If Palestine belongs to the Jews because it is the original home of the Jews, then America belongs to the American Indians because America is their original home.
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?


I have a better suggestion.

Instead of focusing on a tiny little minority that has one minute sliver of land to call their own, why don't you focus on improving yourself, instead, so you won't need your imaginary bogeyman?

None of that was the question.

The contention has been made that the Jews are the original inhabitants of Palestine, so it rightfully belongs to them.

Why does that rule NOT apply when it comes to American Indians?






But that is not the question, that is the Jew haters stance to cloud reality

The reality is the Jews were granted 23% of Palestine for their NATIONal home...

The whole thing stinks, Whites/Europeans seem to be telling everyone where they have a right to be as if they are the world's rightful rulers.

It's simple, if the rule applies for the Jews & Palestine, it applies for the American Indians and America.
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?
Bass-ackwards analogy.
Jews only got about 1% of the Middle East, Arabs got 99% and rule over Other groups like the Kurds.

Israel is Less than 1/10th the size of America's Indian Reservations. (8000 sq miles vs 88,000 sq miles)

abu afak/mbig

If Palestine belongs to the Jews because it is the original home of the Jews, then America belongs to the American Indians because America is their original home.

No it was not the original home of the Hebrews, of who we don't even know who they were to this day, but yes American Indians were real.
 
Hebrews are unknown in history, but American Indians are historical. No ancient history mentions Hebrews.






No history prior to about 1500 mentions the Amerindians, so where do you get your ancient history from. The Jews or Hebrews where known about 2000 years ago
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?
Bass-ackwards analogy.
Jews only got about 1% of the Middle East, Arabs got 99% and rule over Other groups like the Kurds.

Israel is Less than 1/10th the size of America's Indian Reservations. (8000 sq miles vs 88,000 sq miles)

abu afak/mbig

If Palestine belongs to the Jews because it is the original home of the Jews, then America belongs to the American Indians because America is their original home.

No it was not the original home of the Hebrews, of who we don't even know who they were to this day, but yes American Indians were real.






And I suppose mohamedans from before the Roman conquest are real as well
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?


The Judaic people only received about 20% of their original homelands. The Native Americans even less. Not to many tribes are on a reservation within their traditional homelands.

Israel is a great victory for native peoples everywhere

However, there really is no comparison as Native Americans are able to purchase land anywhere they want just like any other American. Judaic people on the other hand cant buy land in Jordan, which represents a forfeiture of about 80% of their traditional homeland.
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?


The Judaic people only received about 20% of their original homelands. The Native Americans even less. Not to many tribes are on a reservation within their traditional homelands.

Israel is a great victory for native peoples everywhere

However, there really is no comparison as Native Americans are able to purchase land anywhere they want just like any other American. Judaic people on the other hand cant buy land in Jordan, which represents a forfeiture of about 80% of their traditional homeland.

I can't verify your numbers, but if it all rightfully belongs to the Jews then it all rightfully belongs to the American Indians...
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?


The Judaic people only received about 20% of their original homelands. The Native Americans even less. Not to many tribes are on a reservation within their traditional homelands.

Israel is a great victory for native peoples everywhere

However, there really is no comparison as Native Americans are able to purchase land anywhere they want just like any other American. Judaic people on the other hand cant buy land in Jordan, which represents a forfeiture of about 80% of their traditional homeland.

I can't verify your numbers, but if it all rightfully belongs to the Jews then it all rightfully belongs to the American Indians...

The American Indians signed treaties which gave away all their rights. They even signed away Manhattan for some beads. They should appeal to the Supreme Court now.
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?


The Judaic people only received about 20% of their original homelands. The Native Americans even less. Not to many tribes are on a reservation within their traditional homelands.

Israel is a great victory for native peoples everywhere

However, there really is no comparison as Native Americans are able to purchase land anywhere they want just like any other American. Judaic people on the other hand cant buy land in Jordan, which represents a forfeiture of about 80% of their traditional homeland.

I can't verify your numbers, but if it all rightfully belongs to the Jews then it all rightfully belongs to the American Indians...

The American Indians signed treaties which gave away all their rights. They even signed away Manhattan for some beads. They should appeal to the Supreme Court now.

Oh, I see. That makes more sense...

Bible talks about the Jews saying that they would accept being the servants of other nations...any treaties for land in their history?
 
No, native Americans were migrants as well. Jews were Afro Hebrews in Egypt that conquered the Canaanites. No one has a claim to anything. In the modern day though, there are nation states, even those nation states dissolve or breakdown. Israel will break down in the future or the Arabs will become majority over time.
 
If Jews have rights to Israel because of history, do American Indians have rights to America because of history?
Bass-ackwards analogy.
Jews only got about 1% of the Middle East, Arabs got 99% and rule over Other groups like the Kurds.

Israel is Less than 1/10th the size of America's Indian Reservations. (8000 sq miles vs 88,000 sq miles)

abu afak/mbig

If Palestine belongs to the Jews because it is the original home of the Jews, then America belongs to the American Indians because America is their original home.

No it was not the original home of the Hebrews, of who we don't even know who they were to this day, but yes American Indians were real.






And I suppose mohamedans from before the Roman conquest are real as well

You mean arabs , yes, never a mention of Hebrews in any historical writings.
 
No, native Americans were migrants as well. Jews were Afro Hebrews in Egypt that conquered the Canaanites. No one has a claim to anything. In the modern day though, there are nation states, even those nation states dissolve or breakdown. Israel will break down in the future or the Arabs will become majority over time.

Not what the OT says in EZE.
 
No, native Americans were migrants as well. Jews were Afro Hebrews in Egypt that conquered the Canaanites. No one has a claim to anything. In the modern day though, there are nation states, even those nation states dissolve or breakdown. Israel will break down in the future or the Arabs will become majority over time.

Not what the OT says in EZE.

What does the OT say?
 
Hebrews are unknown in history, but American Indians are historical. No ancient history mentions Hebrews.

No history prior to about 1500 mentions the Amerindians, so where do you get your ancient history from. The Jews or Hebrews where known about 2000 years ago

Hahahahaha....

That would be European history then would it Phoney!

What a schmuck....

The rights of peoples to 'historical land' is just BS
 
Hebrews are unknown in history, but American Indians are historical. No ancient history mentions Hebrews.






No history prior to about 1500 mentions the Amerindians, so where do you get your ancient history from. The Jews or Hebrews where known about 2000 years ago

Weren't they Nomads? So who they are now may not have been who they were 2k years ago. Or am I completely off base?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Forum List

Back
Top