Honest question: Is supporting Communism over America “treason”?

R

rdean

Guest
Definition of Treason:
n.
1. Violation of allegiance toward one's country or sovereign, especially the betrayal of one's country by waging war against it or by consciously and purposely acting to aid its enemies.

Legal definition:
From the 'Lectric Law Library's Lexicon
Treason

TREASON
This word imports a betraying, treachery, or breach of allegiance.
The Constitution of the United States, Art. III, defines treason against the United States to consist only in levying war against them, or in adhering to their enemies, giving them aid or comfort. This offence is punished with death. By the same article of the Constitution, no person shall be convicted of treason, unless on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or on confession in open court.

Legal Definition of Treason

Say you send millions of American Jobs to China, building up that communist country, as well as inventions and new technologies and that leads to a collapse here, would that be considered “treason”? If not, why not?

What about if you closed important industries, say, the only rare earths mine in the country? One that our military depends on, thereby possibly crippling our military. Would that be considered “treason”?

What if you asked foreign countries to send money here for political campaigns to keep jobs from returning to this country? Would that be considered “treason”?

At what point does bringing harm to this country turn from spite or greed, to “treason”?
 
As far as the US is concerned, Treason is making war against the US or giving aid and comfort to its enemies.

Just because you buy a lenovo computer over a Dell computer is not treason.
 
When Clinton, Bush 41 and Gore got all nipply about China I suggest that we do the following.

The USA is a big country, why don't we carve 10 square miles out on New Mexico and call it New China and run it like the CHiComs ran their country, then see if we still would want to buy products from them.

Deal?
 
Oh, this is an Rdean thread.

It needs three things:

only 6% of scientists are Republican,

90% of Republicans are white

rdeanii.jpg
 
As far as the US is concerned, Treason is making war against the US or giving aid and comfort to its enemies.

Just because you buy a lenovo computer over a Dell computer is not treason.

So communism isn't our enemy? Are communists our friends?
 
Sending them military secrets is treason, buying their products is not.

See the difference?
 
Sending them military secrets is treason, buying their products is not.

See the difference?

Isn't it just as bad if you teach them the technology behind those secrets and make our military dependent on their materials?
 
Why is it bad if it is Chinese, as opposed to Russians, French or Sweads? You some kind of Racist or something?
 
Why is it bad if it is Chinese, as opposed to Russians, French or Sweads? You some kind of Racist or something?

Are you saying you have no problem with communism?

The reason companies want to move there is because the population are basically slaves to the government. It's why they are paid a hundred dollars a month and live in dorms. For companies, this is a fantastic cost savings. I'm sure those companies pay a lot to the government. In return the government gets "technology, modernization and money.
 
Sending them military secrets is treason, buying their products is not.

See the difference?

Isn't it just as bad if you teach them the technology behind those secrets and make our military dependent on their materials?

We don't teach them, they have spies at our labs.

Again, see the difference?

Let me get this straight. We take poor Chinese peasants then suddenly, they are making iPods, transistors, liquid crystal displays and computers, but we don't "teach" them? Is that what you mean? Perhaps you could restate that?
 
So why did FDR take the advise of Communist spies and abandon Chiang Kai Shek in favor of Mao?
 
Isn't it just as bad if you teach them the technology behind those secrets and make our military dependent on their materials?

We don't teach them, they have spies at our labs.

Again, see the difference?

Let me get this straight. We take poor Chinese peasants then suddenly, they are making iPods, transistors, liquid crystal displays and computers, but we don't "teach" them? Is that what you mean? Perhaps you could restate that?

They build consumer products not cruise missiles.

See the difference?
 
We don't teach them, they have spies at our labs.

Again, see the difference?

Let me get this straight. We take poor Chinese peasants then suddenly, they are making iPods, transistors, liquid crystal displays and computers, but we don't "teach" them? Is that what you mean? Perhaps you could restate that?

They build consumer products not cruise missiles.

See the difference?

What is the difference between a computer chip used in an X-box and one used in a "cruise missile"?
 

Forum List

Back
Top