Would you allow everyone to own a fully auto M4 carbine?

[Otis Mayfield]

Scalia explained it in Heller. Read Heller. Educateyourself.

Scalia is dead.

Heller was a 5 to 4 decision.

 

[progressive hunter]

Then why mention Militia at all?

it sets the context for why THE PEOPLE need weapons of war as opposed to hunting weapons,,

example,,
a good hunting rifle being necessary to get meat for the family,,

 

[M14 Shooter]

The fully auto weapon has to be made before 1981 for it to be legal with documentation.
An M4 Carbine was made well after 1981.

1986. Registered w/ the BATF before may 1986.
A M16 lower receiver can made into M4 Carbine, so it is perfectly possible to legally have one.

 

[M14 Shooter]

Scalia is dead.
Heller was a 5 to 4 decision.

Given the courrent composition of the court, why do you think this is relevant?

 

[2aguy]

Scalia is dead.

Heller was a 5 to 4 decision.

So.......that doesn't end the decision....

 

[westwall]

Then why mention Militia at all?

Because everyone was the militia you retard. Fuck, crack open a history book!

 

[M14 Shooter]

Because everyone was the militia you retard. Fuck, crack open a history book!

You know he chooses to be wrong- right?

 

[westwall]

You know he chooses to be wrong- right?

of course, he's a chinese stooge.

 

[M14 Shooter]

of course, he's a chinese stooge.

Wow. You're kind.

 

[westwall]

Wow. You're kind.

Not really, a chinese stooge is a target in the coming war. The stupid will die on their own.

 

[Crepitus]

Scalia explained it in Heller. Read Heller. Educateyourself.

No, Scalia rationalized it in the he Heller decision. There's a difference.

 

[Dadoalex]

Yeah, then they were STOLEN by criminals. Criminals that you constantly let free from prison.

STOP IT!

The operative word here is "responsible."
If gun owners were "responsible" guns would not be stolen, meaning the criminal has no gun to commit a crime and go to prison from which they are released.

See?
"Responsible" gun owners are the single source for all gun crime in the US.

Truth's a bitch ain't it?

 

[westwall]

The operative word here is "responsible."
If gun owners were "responsible" guns would not be stolen, meaning the criminal has no gun to commit a crime and go to prison from which they are released.

See?
"Responsible" gun owners are the single source for all gun crime in the US.

Truth's a bitch ain't it?

Less than one tenth, of one percent of gun owners commit crimes with them. Seems pretty responsible to me.

 

[Dadoalex]

Are you really this dumb?

Please show me the gun that was NEVER EVER EVER in the hands of a "Responsible" gun owner.
UNLESS, of course, you're repeating the clam that there are companies that manufacture guns only for criminals.


BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

 

[Dadoalex]

not sure what crazy conspiracy youre trying to concoct,, but you sound like an idiot,,

ALL guns come from "responsible" gun owners.
ALL, 100%
All gun crime originates with "responsible" gun owners.
Unless, of course, you're making the claim that the gun industry is a criminal enterprise?

 

[Dadoalex]

You said there are no responsible gun owners, so go fuck yourself. We know what you want.

Prove me wrong.

 

[progressive hunter]

ALL guns come from "responsible" gun owners.
ALL, 100%
All gun crime originates with "responsible" gun owners.
Unless, of course, you're making the claim that the gun industry is a criminal enterprise?

good to see youve seen the mistake you made in your claim,,,

 

[westwall]

Prove me wrong.

Your claim is so absurd that you have placed yourself into the classification of extremist lunatic. You ain't worth wasting any more time on.

Goodbye mr. troll.

 

[Otis Mayfield]

ALL guns come from "responsible" gun owners.
ALL, 100%
All gun crime originates with "responsible" gun owners.
Unless, of course, you're making the claim that the gun industry is a criminal enterprise?

What?

Why can't an irresponsible person buy a gun? They buy guns all the time.

There are crazy people who buy guns at noon and murder a dozen people at 3PM. How are they responsible in any way?

 

[AZrailwhale]

The operative word here is "responsible."
If gun owners were "responsible" guns would not be stolen, meaning the criminal has no gun to commit a crime and go to prison from which they are released.

See?
"Responsible" gun owners are the single source for all gun crime in the US.

Truth's a bitch ain't it?

That’s the most twisted “logic” I’ve ever heard. That’s like saying if people didn’t “let” their cars get stolen, they wouldn’t be used on crimes. When I was a teenager, I remember seeing and hearing PSAs saying “don’t let a good kid go bad, lock your car”. Even then I thought that was stupid. A “good” kid isn’t going to steal you car even if you leave the keys in it, the doors open and the engine running. Anyone who takes anything that doesn’t belong to them is a criminal, period dot.