Would One of Our Jewish Members Please Explain the Nakba?

[ShahdagMountains]

^^^^

No need to get upset, you two..

 

[gipper]

And the Palestinians are still taking out Israeli tanks and troops. So it is too early for Israel to claim victory.

Unfortunately for the people of Gaza including the one million children, this awful war has resulted in terrible death and destruction.

Hamas had to know Israel would respond this way, before they attacked on 10/7. I’m not minimizing Israel’s war crimes. We all know Israel is a genocidal state. What Hamas did on 10/7 was doom the Palestinian people to inevitable death and destruction.

 

[gipper]

^^^^

No need to get upset, you two..

Yeah it’s just a little genocide. Kill those babies! No one gives ****. It’s funny!!!

 

[gipper]

^^^^

No need to get upset, you two..

This is certainly true of you, right?

 

[ShahdagMountains]

This is certainly true of you, right?

You seem to be more interested in me than the issues of the day.

 

[ShahdagMountains]

Yeah it’s just a little genocide. Kill those babies! No one gives ****. It’s funny!!!

You certainly don’t give a f… about little Ariel Bibbas. And other babies who were burnt alive in ovens.

 

[gipper]

You certainly don’t give a f… about little Ariel Bibbas. And other babies who were burnt alive in ovens.

Just like a good little Nazi.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Palestine: A Four Thousand Year History by Nur Masalha · Audiobook preview​

 

[WelfareQueen]

So you believe that. Lol. What else has God said?

If you think Jesus supports genocide, you’re one fucked up idiot.

Down you go!

You mean like "From the River to the Sea?" That genocide?

 

[Dogmaphobe]

You seem to be more interested in me than the issues of the day.

Gipper has more than just a few uncorrected personality traits.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

The maps in my Bible call it Palestine.

How many muslims lived there, according to your Bible?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

My guess is 90% of Americans (maybe more) never heard of the Nakba, prior to Israel’s genocide of Gazans.

We all heard the Arab losers whining, for decades, before their recent whiny losses.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Now, we have dumb Americans saying too bad for the Palestinians they lost. Essentially this ignorant mindset equates to might makes right.

That's crazy! Might never makes right, just ask the Third Reich.
Or look at Constantinople, the seat of Eastern Christianity and capital of the Byzantine Empire.
And have you seen their great church? Wow!

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

And the Palestinians are still taking out Israeli tanks and troops. So it is too early for Israel to claim victory.

Yeah, Hamas is really kicking ass. DURR

 

[ShahdagMountains]

And the Palestinians are still taking out Israeli tanks and troops. So it is too early for Israel to claim victory.

It’s not about victory, you moron.

Release the hostages!

 

[gipper]

You mean like "From the River to the Sea?" That genocide?

That’s what you MFing murderous Zionists like to say and you’re accomplishing it by committing mass murder.

You support mass murder, but are too dumb to know it.

In former times, you'd have supported Hitler, Stalin, and Mao.

 

[Grau]

Unless you can find me some living Canaanites who still practice Canaanite culture, religious practices, and speak the Canaanite language it is entirely irrelevant to modern discussions.

You are welcome to your opinion as to who has a right to self determination in Palestine but it is a simple fact that direct descendants of Palestine's earlier residents currently live in Southern Lebanon.
Foreign Zionist occupiers from afar have no more right to former Palestine than any of its earlier residents.

When did Hebrew become the official language of the Levant?

 

[Shusha]

Foreign Zionist occupiers Jews from afar have no more right to former Palestine than any of its earlier residents.

Yes. They do. Because they are indigenous and their culture originated in that place and they still exist. You have no right to deny it to that collective.

When did Hebrew become the official language of the Levant?

Never said it did. But the language originated in that place and is still spoken by a distinct cultural group.

What do you think the criteria for self-determination should be if not indigeneity and cultural collectiveness?

 

[Grau]

Yes. They do. Because they are indigenous and their culture originated in that place and they still exist. You have no right to deny it to that collective.

Never said it did. But the language originated in that place and is still spoken by a distinct cultural group.

What do you think the criteria for self-determination should be if not indigeneity and cultural collectiveness?

As I have repeatedly shown, todays Israelis are no more related to the Ancient Hebrew warriors than they are to the Eskimos.

Countless residents of the Levant have a more valid claim to Palestine than recently arrived, Nazi armed and trained European Zionist terorrist gangs:


“Living Descendants of Biblical Canaanites Identified Via DNA"

National Geographic

Explore National Geographic. A world leader in geography, cartography and exploration.

news.nationalgeographic.com

EXCERPT "More than 90 percent of the genetic ancestry of modern Lebanese is derived from ancient Canaanites, according to a paper published today in the American Journal of Human Genetics.

Researchers supported by The Wellcome Trust were able to sequence the Canaanite genome from the remains of five individuals buried in the ancient port city of Sidon (modern Saïda, Lebanon) around 3,700 years ago. The results were compared against the DNA of 99 modern-day Lebanese residents." CONTINUED

Even the genocidal Ancient Hebrews are relative newcomers to the Levant:


"Forgotten Civilizations of the Holy Land"


EXCERPT "The 3rd millennium BCE Levantine civilizations that rivaled the greatness of Egypt and Mesopotamia. Historians have long considered the Levant, also known as Syria-Palestine, a land bridge connecting the older and more important civilizations of Mesopotamia and Egypt.

We'll look at the recent archaeological finds which suggest the inhabitants of this region --known as Natufians-- developed pre-neolithic permanent settlements that may be the earliest in the world. Overtime, these sites grew into great cities at the centre of great civilizations, most notably Ebla, considered by some the first recorded world power, and its rival Mari." CONTINUED


The only reason you believe this mythical "Jewish homeland" nonsense it that Zionist propagandists have weaponized archeology and been careful to destroy evidence of earlier Levantine civilizations..


"Israel Is Using Archeology To Erase Non-Jewish History"

Opinion | Israel Is Using Archeology To Erase Non-Jewish History

Israel's claiming sovereignty based on archaeological finds isn't a reflection of Jerusalem's multi-cultural archaeological reality.

forward.com

EXCERPT "The fact that both sides engage in archaeological warfare doesn’t mean the playing field is level. Israel controls the Historic Basin and the quantity of ancient sites under its auspices give it the capacity to shape the historic city.

Moreover, archaeology in Israel has always been linked to the project of nation building. The historian Amos Elon once commented that Israeli archaeologists do not only dig for knowledge and objects, but for a reassurance of their roots." CONTINUED


Re:

What do you think the criteria for self-determination should be if not indigeneity and cultural collectiveness?

Most all Zionist / Israeli leaders and Israel's PMs are from Europe. How are they "indigenous" to Palestine / Israel.

Finally, please define "cultural collectiveness" and explain how it justifies genocide and expulsion of Palestine's native Arab residents who comprised 85% of Palestine's population as late as 1900.

Thanks,

 

[Shusha]

I think he is confused because so many Palestinians ACT like they are followers of Baal.

He's going to play some sort of blood quantum card that "90% of the people of Lebanon share DNA with Canaanites, therefore Jews don't exist."

EXCERPT "More than 90 percent of the genetic ancestry of modern Lebanese is derived from ancient Canaanites, according to a paper published today in the American Journal of Human Genetics.

Oh lookie.