Women's Studies??? Really?

PoliticalChic

Diamond Member
Gold Supporting Member
Oct 6, 2008
124,897
60,268
2,300
Brooklyn, NY
Women's Studies??? I thought that would be parallel parking and balancing the checkbook...
What The Heck Happened to Feminism?


1. It is so difficult to discuss feminism, when keeping up with definitions of who is female is becoming a full time job. "Transgendered - an umbrella term that includes a wide range of identities and includes pre-operative, postoperative, and non-operative transsexual people. In its general sense, it refers to anyone whose behavior or identity falls outside of stereotypical expectations for their gender." http://handouts.aacrao.org/am08/finished/T0415p_K_Posey.pdf

2. But, for a moment, let's be quaint and pretend that 'anatomy is destiny,' and there are only males, and females. And the latter is the group to whom the term 'feminism' applies. Simply arguendo.





3. Gender studies departments are ubiquitous in colleges, but incorrectly named, as they are oriented toward only one gender. In fact, 'studying' the female experience and female sexuality, students explore the male experience and male sexuality, but from a feminist perspective. What this means, with few exceptions, is the interpretation of men's lives in line with the doctrine that men are, by definition, oppressors, warmongers, potential rapists, the beneficiaries of patriarchal social structures, and should be views through this negative feminist lens.

a. "Any expressed wish for a traditional career as a homemaker is quashed at a young age by a prevailing feminist mentality in schools and colleges. The resulting mental conflict often makes young women confused and angry."
Angry young women
Any wonder why many refer to the departments as "Angry Women's Studies"?

4. While Women's Studies was supposed to give a voice to 'silenced' women, those who dissent from its orthodoxy have themselves felt silenced by intolerant professors and even students, the fierce enforcers of dogma.

a. In "Professing Feminism," Patai and Koertge found the following with respect to women's studies.... "Students are being cheated. I feel really bad for them, because they're not being given an education. And you know, once they're in women's studies, it's like Stepford Wives. Women's studies turns them into ideologically inflamed Stepford Wives. I was always able to recognize it when these kids come, kind of zombified, and start uttering stock phrases. Politics is driving out their ability to think."

b. From the blurb of Katie Roiphe's "The Morning After: Sex, Fear and Feminism on Campus":
"To Katie Roiphe, feminism had always meant freedom — but as an undergraduate at Harvard and a graduate at Princeton, she was shocked to discover that the same movement that had once promised women a voice was now being used to tell them what they ought to say and think and feel."





5. The widespread antagonism toward male-identified traditions results in a slovenly approach to the whole business of teaching: a lack of preparedness, sloppily written syllabi, and so on. For many Women's Studies practitioners, the attempt is made to reject the entire edifice of civilization as a product of male culture. If Friedan and Greer encouraged women to charge boldly into formerly male-dominated fields, and to strive for excellence in competition with men, in Women's Studies today, the entire concept of merit is often viewed with suspicion as too masculinist, and as some sort of threat to harmony and self-esteem.






6. Can we mention the 'math problem'? Yes....many female students fall behind in math and science, but rather than encourage them to work harder, Women's Studies professors are likely to inform them that the problem lies not in their own shortcomings, but in the fields themselves. Math and science, they are told, are of limited value because these subjects are based on "male" ways of knowing, i.e., rationality, that ignores "female," or emotionally centered ways of understanding the world. We should beware, it seems, of strictly intellectual endeavors.
Bawer, "The Victim's Revolution"

a. "Words of Power: A Feminist Reading of the History of Logic (Thinking Gender)" by Andrea Nye...." In a series of studies of the logics of historical figures--Parmenides, Plato, Aristotle, Zeno, Abelard, Ockham, and Frege--she traces the changing interrelationships between logical innovation and oppressive speech strategies, showing that logic is not transcendent truth but abstract forms of language spoken by men, whether Greek ruling citizens, or scientists."
[ame=http://www.amazon.com/Words-Power-Feminist-Reading-Thinking/dp/0415902002]Words of Power: A Feminist Reading of the History of Logic (Thinking Gender): Andrea Nye: 9780415902007: Amazon.com: Books[/ame]

b. And this, from Nye's book, is what passes for learning in many Women's Studies courses: "Desperate, lonely, cut off from the human community which in many cases has ceased to exist, under the sentence of violent death, wracked by desires for intimacy that they do not know how to fulfill, at the same time tormented by the presence of women, men turn to logic."
What????


Separatism, gender superiority or inferiority.....is this how we wish to raise our daughters?


A reminder:In colleges and universities, programs, and departments of African-American Studies, Ethnic Studies, Feminist Studies, Peace Studies, and LGBT (Lesbian/Gay/Bi-sexual/Transgender) Studies can all be traced to the ascendance of neo-Marxism, and the drumbeat attacks on Western civilization.
 
Women's Studies??? Women should be in the kitchen, barefoot and pregnant.

They could take up Engineering, or Accounting, or Comp Sci, you know, something useful.

A WS degree makes you able to teach WS as a professor, and thats about it.
 
Women's Studies??? Women should be in the kitchen, barefoot and pregnant.

Now you're gonna get it.....
Do you know who you’re messing with? When ghosts go camping, they tell PoliticalChic stories! Running with the bulls? I’m the one chasing ‘em!
I have a black belt in Karioke!

And....for edification....if that's possible...

"The Natural Superiority of Women, 5th Edition [Paperback]
Ashley Montagu

Among the central issues of the modern feminist movement, the debate over biology and culture over sex and gender, over genetics and gender roles has certainly been one of the most passionately contested. Making revolutionary arguments upon its first publication in 1953, The Natural Superiority of Women stands as one of the original feminist arguments against biological determinism. An iconoclast, Montagu wielded his encyclopedic knowledge of physical anthropology in critique of the conventional wisdom of women as the "weaker sex," showing how women's biological, genetic, and physical makeup made her not only man's equal, but his superior."
[ame=http://www.amazon.com/The-Natural-Superiority-Women-Edition/dp/076198982X/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1367249127&sr=8-2&keywords=on+the+natural+superiority+of+women]The Natural Superiority of Women, 5th Edition: Ashley Montagu: 9780761989820: Amazon.com: Books[/ame]
 
Women's Studies??? Women should be in the kitchen, barefoot and pregnant.

And wearing a burka making biryani.

Now for you:

1."In the twentieth century, the big-brained female—Femina sapiens, if you will—found herself living in an utterly reshaped habitat, free from sepsis, unplanned children, sewing, bread baking, and arduous trips to the well. She was ready to use her brain in new ways, not coincidentally at a time when the intellectually gratifying jobs of an advanced economy were becoming more plentiful.

a. In a 2007 paper, economists Justin Wolfers and Betsy Stevenson noted that young women attach greater importance than in the past to “being successful in my line of work,” “being able to find steady work,” “making a contribution to society,” and “being a leader in my community.”

2. Evolution selected for women who wanted to hold and nurse their infants. There may or may not be a “maternal instinct”— but there is a hormone that amounts to almost the same thing. It inclines females to feed, cuddle, and fuss over their young, and leaves men at peace.

3. If that were evolutionary psychology’s whole story about women, then its experts would be proclaiming patriarchy as our destiny, which they don’t tend to do. In fact, as neuroscientists and geneticists piece together the human brain’s evolution, it’s becoming clear that, if it’s natural for a woman to go crazy over her babies, it’s also natural for a woman to run the State Department. The same human female brain that’s primed with oxytocin is, like the male brain, a fantastically complex machine, capable of reasoning, innovative problem solving, and maneuvering through hugely varied social environments—whether the PTA, a corporate headquarters, or Congress."
Femina Sapiens in the Nursery by Kay S. Hymowitz, City Journal Autumn 2009


Consider this a three finger snap in a z-formation!
 
You do realize that there are courses in men's studies. Today there is almost no area of human activity that is not studied.
 
Women's Studies??? Women should be in the kitchen, barefoot and pregnant.

Some women don't belong in the kitchen. Just ask Gordon...

483788_225824624223433_310949738_n.png
 
You do realize that there are courses in men's studies. Today there is almost no area of human activity that is not studied.

That hardly speaks to whether or not the study is efficacious...or, in connection with the OP, if it reflects education at all.

And, along that line:

"More than 900 four-year colleges and universities allow students to develop their own programs of study with an adviser's help, up 5.1% from five years ago, based on data from the College Board, a New York-based nonprofit organization of colleges and universities. University officials say at least 70 go a step further, providing programs with faculty advisers, and sometimes specialized courses, to help students develop educational plans tailored to their interests, while still meeting school standards.
A sampling of some students' D-I-Y majors
• Ethnobotany
• Magic
• Ethology (animal psychology and behavior)
• Music promotion
• Anthropology of mental health and illness
• Peace and conflict resolution
• Historical clothing
• Sociology of fashion
• Environmental racism
• Complex organizations and informational systems
• Neuroscience, human behavior and society
• Asian-American studies
• Bioethics in crosscultural perspectives
Can't Pick a College Major? Create One - WSJ.com


Most are simply frivolous.....some, such as related in the OP....are harmful.
 

Forum List

Back
Top