Yes, it is-
http://www.rebresearch.com/blog/crime-us-vs-uk/
Higher than Canada, as well.
Crime in the UK is much higher than here, with tough, tough gun laws.
When you consider how many guns there are here legally, 92% are never used illegally. The stats show legal gun owners are not doing the killing. Legal guns have stopped by far more crime than caused it. Three such incidents have made the news just this week, and considering most media don’t want to report that, no telling how many incidents like that are truly happening.
You take away the good guys guns 92% of gun murders would still happen, and then some, as there won’t be anyone to stop some of the attempted murders, crimes that are done today. Crime would go up even further.
And if you think gun running would be stopped or criminals would turn in their weapons, I have this really nice bridge to sell ya.
Not when you take into account the number of legal guns, no. Illegal guns do over 92% of the killing here.
But the reality is that STILL four times more people die in the US than in most other First World countries.
Go figure.
So, you have people stopping killings, which means that the number of killing attempts in the US is through the roof.
Yes, when you take into account the number of legal guns, the homicide rate is STILL four times lower.
I'm confused.
No, crime isn't higher in the UK at all.
Crime statistics are often difficult to compare, homicide is the easiest simply because a dead body is a dead body.
A while back I looked at the statistics and for crime they were about comparable for the US and the UK except for homicides.
92% of guns are used legally. That still means the US has a major problem. You can try and throw the positives, but the negatives outweigh anything. 4 times higher murder is simple to understand, it's people's lives going away.
Well, yes, sometimes you won't be able to stop the problems. Like in the UK there are still murders, still crimes. However your argument falls down in that the US has so many problems.
To be fair, the largest problem is the US govt and the whole political system. Until this changes, there's no real point in implementing gun control because the US is so rotten it just wouldn't work. But Americans seem to like living in a society where things don't really work properly.
There's a difference between what the stats say and what is actual.
The Difference Between US-UK Violent Crime Rates Depends On Definition of ‘Violent Crime’
"However, a closer look shows the U.S. has more burglaries, rapes, and murders than the U.K. The reason for the U.K.’s higher violent crime rate is their far broader definition of a “violent” crime."
"
According to the FBI, there are
four crimes classified as “violent” in crime statistics: murder/non-negligent manslaughter, forcible rape, robbery and aggravated assault.
The list does not include burglaries, which is considered a property crime in the U.S. but a violent crime in the U.K.
In addition to murder, forcible rape, robbery, aggravated assault and burglary, England and Wales classify domestic violence and all sexual offenses – not just forcible rape – as violent."
So in this case violent crimes include a lot more things in the UK than the US.
Now your site says it got the information from the Dutch, but I'm unable to see their statistics at all, which doesn't bode well.
Also it's from 1999, a long time ago
UKCrimeStats.com - The Leading Independent Crime Data Platform
United States Crime Rates 1960 - 2016
UK and US crime stats
The first problem here is that the stats for the UK are every month and just numbers, the US we have the per capita.
So, the UK says 127,776 violent crimes in one month, that'd be 1.53 million a year. There are 65 million people in the UK, that means we divide by 650. 2,353 per 100,000 people if I haven't made a mistake. The US has 397.
There's no way in hell that the UK has a violent crime rate that is 6 times higher than the US's violent crime rate. I've lived in both countries and it just isn't so.
So, we can see that the UK is including a lot more things in their violent crime.
The US has murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault.
The UK's murder rate is about 1.0 per 100,000.
Historical crime data - GOV.UK
Historical crime ending mar 2015 is what I clicked on, it's an excel document.
Rape is at 30,000 a year. But rape statistics are notorious for being misleading. Sweden has the highest rape rate in the world I think, mainly because they encourage the reporting of rape. The UK encourages rape reporting far more than the US which seems to try and hide the problem.
The US's rape rate is 29.6 per 100,000 people. The UK's is 46. However this doesn't mean that more people are being raped in the UK.
Reporting of Sexual Violence Incidents | National Institute of Justice
"The most recent research, however, indicates that a majority of rape victims still do not report their attacks to police."
"The Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) reports that the majority of rapes and sexual assaults perpetrated against women and girls in the United States between 1992 and 2000 were not reported to the police. Only 36 percent of rapes, 34 percent of attempted rapes, and 26 percent of sexual assaults were reported."
Okay, so if about 36% of rapes are actually reported, then the US rape rate is something like 90 per 100,000 rather than 30.
Sure, there'll be those in the UK who don't report rape too, the difference is the attitude towards reporting rape.
But interestingly the highest rape rate in the US is Alaska. A state with a lot of guns to protect yourself. Right?
List of United States cities by crime rate - Wikipedia
Louisiana with a lot of guns is third.
California, New York, New Jersey with stricter guns laws are at the bottom. Go figure.
So, there are lots of problems with looking at statistics and you have to understand them.