Quote: Originally Posted by Rshermr View Post
You are avoiding your problem, me boy. You are following an economic policy that does not work.
Actually, it worked beautifully.
Sorry, eflat. You have been unable to bring any impartial source to prove your statement. Just your opinion.
There have been many startup economies that may have had some libertarian charactoristics. But saying that the us was libertarian is a stretch that you will only find support for on nut case libertarian sitesd. So, you go to CATO. A libertarian supporting site with plenty of writers that would like to push your ideas. But no impartial ones.
How about a non libertarian source:
[
QUOTE]The roots of socialism in America can be traced to the arrival of German immigrants in the 1850s when Marxian socialist unions began, such as the National Typographic Union in 1852, United Hatters of 1856, and Iron Moulders` Union of North America in 1859. Theodore H. White, author of Fire in the Ashes: Europe in Mid-Century (1953) wrote, "Socialism is the belief and the hope that by proper use of government power, men can be rescued from their helplessness in the wild cycling cruelty of depression and boom."
Socialism in America
[/QUOTE]
Quote:
I did not say anything that is not truth.
Yes, you did. You said the US was not a libertarian economy before the Progressive movement. That is not true.
Again, your opinion. Not substantiated by a single non partial source. You loose again.
Quote:
Which is why you can not find an actual libertarian economy that worked for any period of time.
You're repeating your lies, again.
No lies, step. You still can not find a single impartial source that backs you up. Just libertarian and other right wing bat shit sites. Sad.
America until the early twentieth century for starters. Those economies doing best today, while not true libertarian economies, are a damn site closer than the more centrally planned economies that are failing all around us. Which economies are doing better...Greece, Italy, Portugal (central planners all of them) or Hong Kong, Singapore, Estonia, Switzerland (far more libertarian like)?
Quote:
You insist that the us is that country, up till the early 1900's. Problem is, that is your opinion. And you have no rational support. No link.
"It was in America that the ideas and practices of liberty initially went furthest— and thus it is not surprising that the modern libertarian movement arose here."
The Roots of Modern Libertarian Ideas | Cato Institute
Golly, that was easy.
Always easy, of course, to find a bat shit crazy con site to back up your statements. Still no impartial source.
Quote:
Now, the reason you can not find a link from an impartial source backing you up is interesting
Lots of links out there. Your Google search engine broken?
See above. And there are many others. Impartial ones, at that. Now, you are the one making the statement. Just can not back up your statement. Perhaps you have the broken browser, me boy. No impartial source at all.
Quote:
Must be lousy following an economic theory that never lasts for any length of time
1780 until about 1913. Pretty long time. It is true that the nanny staters sucking up to the central planners eventually do infect a good society. Time to rid us of the cancer. Cut it out for good.
Sorry. Even most other libertarians do not agree with you. Calling the us libertarian is a joke. We could suggest that it was libertarian, and ended in the great depression. But actually, even that was not true. As always, the people of the country would not go along with the push by cons to libertarianism.
But still, that good old man made libertarian island is on the way. Maybe you can find room.