You’ve got to be careful about this.
The suicide rate may be the highest it has been in 50 years. However, what is the relationship between the number of suicides today + attempted suicides compared to the suicides 50 years ago + attempts?
Today, thanks to the NRA and spineless politicians, we have more guns out there than at any other time in our history. So it stands to reason that the lethality of means to commit suicide is much greater than it has been than at any other time in our history. So…if you were contemplating killing yourself in 1968, you probably could do it but there is less likelihood that you had a revolver in the next room. Today you have a revolver on your hip, one in the next room, one in Mom’s purse, and another in the car. All lethal.
Additionally, the psychology of suicide is one where you may just do it if you’re serious. But often, you see where a police official is talking someone off a bridge. They don’t want to kill themselves, they want someone to listen. In 1968, if you were going to hang yourself, you have to find somewhere to do it (likely indoors), get a rope, a chair or platform and get to work. The same with carbon monoxide in the garage, methane in the oven, etc… It was a process that gave the person with suicidal thoughts a few moments of reflection and of course a point to back out of the enterprise. Today? Pull the trigger and you’re dead. So even if you did the calculations above, you really don’t know how many unreported suicide attempts there were where someone started their car and turned it off at the first sign of asphyxiation or stood on a chair with a rope around their neck and backed out….
Solutions? More controls on firearms to start. We all know that won’t happen with the Blob though.
You are looking at the tool used, not the cause. In aircraft crashes, they say the accident happened in the air somewhere. The crash is the result of the accident. By your standards, if we abolished the ground there would be fewer airplane crashes.
Strawest of the straw man arguments.
My argument is that, perhaps, we have a higher suicide rate today because of the lethal nature of the available tools.
For centuries, the only way to fight gangrene was to cut off the limb which was infected. We learned to go for the source of the infection, instead of just lopping off whatever was infected.
I already explained what was responsible for the increasing rate of suicides earlier in the thread.
The suicide rate is the highest it's been in half a century...why? what SOLUTIONS do you propose?
In short, pain. The FDA and DEA have decided that Doctors are proscribing too much pain medication, and mixing Pain meds and among others, Benzo’s, and Sleeping Pills, is dangerous. Despite the fact that hundreds of thousands, even millions were taking them. So we have chronic pain patients who are without any treatment, and how long could you live in agony? Agony that would prevent you from sleeping, agony that made every minute an eternity. How long could you endure before you decided that taking your own life was worth it. It also explains why there is an increase in overdose deaths, because the people are desperate for any relief.
Years ago, in response to ethanol, I said that the future would treat us badly, and with reason. I could just imagine a school girl raising her hand and in an incredulous voice demanding the teacher confirm the information they had just been given. “Wait, with starvation going around the globe, they were really turning food into fuel? Were they stupid?”
Now, that conversation is going to be repeated. “You mean they had the ability to ease the suffering of the people, and refused the people that bit of succor? What were they Sadists?”
We have grater knowledge than ever before, and less compassion for those who are suffering than ever before. So yeah, there are going to be overdoses as the desperate turn to the streets trying to find a bit of relief, and for those who are unable to do that, suicide to end the suffering.
It is the cause, not the tool, that is the issue. Reduce the cause, and the tool becomes irrelevant.