The Official Discussion Thread for who is considered indiginous to Palestine?

[Indeependent]

The Greek historian Herodotus was 500 years before Rome conquered Palestine.

Every nation on Earth is living on conquered land.
You want someone's land...go to war...if you get your ass kicked...eat shit.

 

[Sixties Fan]

The Greek historian Herodotus was 500 years before Rome conquered Palestine.

And you do know that Herodotus called ONLY the area where the Greek Phillistines had lived, Palestinia
He called the region, and not the Phillistines that name. He did not recognize anyone at all as a Palestinian.

A region, area, is a region.
A People, like the Phillistines, with a history in the area, are a people .

No Palestinians of any kind lived in the area.

 

[surada]

Every nation on Earth is living on conquered land.
You want someone's land...go to war...if you get your ass kicked...eat shit.

The European Zionists we're given land.. they just wanted more.

 

[surada]

And you do know that Herodotus called ONLY the area where the Greek Phillistines had lived, Palestinia
He called the region, and not the Phillistines that name. He did not recognize anyone at all as a Palestinian.

A region, area, is a region.
A People, like the Phillistines, with a history in the area, are a people .

No Palestinians of any kind lived in the area.

All of Palestine was a province of Syria.

 

[rylah]

The Greek historian Herodotus was 500 years before Rome conquered Palestine.

This explains why people who can't even pronounce 'P-alestine'
rely their narrative on how foreign empires called the place.

Is that why Arab supremacists call it Nablus,
because they're indigenous to it?

 

[surada]

This explains why people who can't even pronounce 'P-alestine'
rely their narrative on how foreign empires called the place.

Is that why Arab supremacists call it Nablus,
because they're indigenous to it?

They say fellahin.

 

[Indeependent]

The European Zionists we're given land.. they just wanted more.

Ok, moron, most of the Eastern Hemisphere changed post WWII.
Any other bullshit you'd care to share?

 

[rylah]

They say fellahin.

They also say fellahin in Morroco, Egypt, and Iraq.

Do Arabs say Nablus, because they're indigenous,
or because they identify with names
imposed by foreign empires?

 

[Mindful]

The European Zionists we're given land.. they just wanted more.

More of what?

They settled for MUCH less than they were promised.

 

[surada]

More of what?

They settled for MUCH less than they were promised.

Have you forgotten the Sykes Picot agreement? The Arabs fought with the British to push the Ottomans out.

 

[Mindful]

Have you forgotten the Sykes Picot agreement? The Arabs fought with the British to push the Ottomans out.

Why is this topic such an intense issue for you?

Maybe you have a thing about Jews?

 

[Indeependent]

Why is this topic such an intense issue for you?

Maybe you have a thing about Jews?

She grew up watching her parents suck Arab Dick.

 

[rylah]

Have you forgotten the Sykes Picot agreement? The Arabs fought with the British to push the Ottomans out.

Ottomans were defeated by the British and Arab imperialists...

Who were the biggest winners?

 

[Uncensored2008]

The Greek historian Herodotus was 500 years before Rome conquered Palestine.

Rome never conquered "Palestine" Hezbollah Hannah,

Can't conquer what doesn't exist.

 

[Uncensored2008]

Why is this topic such an intense issue for you?

Maybe you have a thing about Jews?

She is Hezbollah.

Hezbollah Hannah.

 

[surada]

Muhammad banned Christians from Arabia. Quran, allegedly written by Muhammad, curses Christians for believing Jesus is the son of God.



View attachment 731583

Nope . There were Christians in Najran and in Tarout . Muhammad protected them and waived jizya... Especially after the Jewish king of Yemen burned so many of them to death.

 

[surada]

The Romans didn't conquer Palestine until 63 BC. Herodotus called it Syria -Palestine in 500 BC.

 

[Sixties Fan]

The Romans didn't conquer Palestine until 63 BC. Herodotus called it Syria -Palestine in 500 BC.

Herodotus called the Coastal Philistine areas PALESTINIA. Nowhere else.

The Romans, after defeating Bar Kochba, called the area Syria PALESTINIA, for the two people who had defeated the Jews before the Romans.

 

[surada]

Herodotus called the Coastal Philistine areas PALESTINIA. Nowhere else.

The Romans, after defeating Bar Kochba, called the area Syria PALESTINIA, for the two people who had defeated the Jews before the Romans.

You might want to read up on Syria.

 

[Sixties Fan]

You might want to read up on Syria.

Post a link as to where it says that.
Israel or Judea were not known as PALESTINIA, or Syria Palestinia before Herodotus or the Romans changing the name after the Bar Kochba defeat.

What was the name of the Raman Province? Judea. Not Syria Palestinia.

During the Maccabees? Judea

I do not know which historian would have written that Judea, the Greek name for the Judah tribal territory, would have been called what you say before the 2nd century CE AT that time in history.