The majority of states who receive more goverment funds than they pay through taxes are red states.

[Harry Dresden]

I am glad you realize that. But our country is no more than an orgamization of states.
I know this is hard for youn to comprehend.

and that organization makes us a country not an organization like NATO.....i know this is hard for you to understand elmer.....

 

[Harry Dresden]

The analysis is on revenue received from the Federal Government compared to taxes paid to the Federal Government.

I'm pretty sure they're counting money received by the people, not just dollars given to the states. In either case, fiscally responsible states should have smaller deficits and lower debt.

Post the lists.

The states that take more money from the federal government than they pay in are a majority red states. I provided data.

States don't "pay in" to the federal government, the people pay.
Social Security payments received by the people are not money that the "state takes".

elmer thinks we are an organization like NATO....not a country,he has a hard time seeing that.....

 

[ElmerMudd]

The location of those states and the huge lead time they had as the center of money and the industrial revolution does not hurt. The money sent to the red states ended up making many major cities Prog.

Red states are red states.

and that organization makes us a country not an organization like NATO.....i know this is hard for you to understand elmer.....

You cannot see any similarities to nations paying into a central organization they belong and states paying into a centralized government they are part of.

 

[Harry Dresden]

Red states are red states.

You cannot see any similarities to nations paying into a central organization they belong and states paying into a centralized government they are part of.

we pay the taxes elmer not the states....in nato you have countries all chipping in for protection.....in America we the people,the tax payers in ALL the states,WE are the country....is it the rancher in Wyomings fault that California has more economic clout?....learn the difference elmer....

 

[BrokeLoser]

The majority of states who receive more goverment funds than they pay in taxes are red states. They ar getting more from the government than they are paying.
NY and CA pay more in federal taxes than they receive in government funds.

I say we treat states like Trump wants to treat NATO nations. If a state does not pay in equal or more in taxes than they receive from the federal goverment we kick themout of the USA. It would balance the budget.

View attachment 1009046

I say **** it, why stop at the state level, let’s break it down by city. We both know cities full of your treasured dark people are responsible for dragging the state into the shitter.

 

[ElmerMudd]

we pay the taxes elmer not the states....in nato you have countries all chipping in for protection.....in America we the people,the tax payers in ALL the states,WE are the country....is it the rancher in Wyomings fault that California has more economic clout?....learn the difference elmer....

We hear about all of the homeless and welfare receipients in California and New York. You would think they are sucking the US Treasury dry. No, both states give more than they get.

 

[ElmerMudd]

I say **** it, why stop at the state level, let’s break it down by city. We both know cities full of your treasured dark people are responsible for dragging the state into the shitter.

You are a sick human. How did you become you?

 

[BluesLegend]

The majority of states who receive more goverment funds than they pay through taxes are red states​

Not this Dem lie again, it's been debunked 100 times. You sheeple need some new material.

 

[BluesLegend]

Note how Democrats take a giant shit on poor Democrats who live in red states.

 

[Deplorable Yankee]

The majority of states who receive more goverment funds than they pay in taxes are red states. They ar getting more from the government than they are paying.
NY and CA pay more in federal taxes than they receive in government funds.

I say we treat states like Trump wants to treat NATO nations. If a state does not pay in equal or more in taxes than they receive from the federal goverment we kick themout of the USA. It would balance the budget.

View attachment 1009046

Not this shit again


So break off with the red states ...you hate the people anyway ..so why not peacefully secede and build Uber democratic socialist paradise ?

 

[Dont Taz Me Bro]

The majority of states who receive more goverment funds than they pay in taxes are red states. They ar getting more from the government than they are paying.
NY and CA pay more in federal taxes than they receive in government funds.

I say we treat states like Trump wants to treat NATO nations. If a state does not pay in equal or more in taxes than they receive from the federal goverment we kick themout of the USA. It would balance the budget.

View attachment 1009046

This topic has come up repeatedly over the years and one of the main reasons for this is because of all the military installations and contractors that are in the southern states. That aside, you people continuously vote for politicians who redistribute all of this money to these states so why do you keep crying about it?

 

[Harry Dresden]

You are a sick human. How did you become you?

you just about said the same thing elmer....kicking states out....how did you become you?...

 

[SweetTea]

The majority of states who receive more goverment funds than they pay in taxes are red states. They ar getting more from the government than they are paying.
NY and CA pay more in federal taxes than they receive in government funds.

I say we treat states like Trump wants to treat NATO nations. If a state does not pay in equal or more in taxes than they receive from the federal goverment we kick themout of the USA. It would balance the budget.

View attachment 1009046

Maybe you should check out whether Democrats or Republicans receive more government funds than they pay in. Exclude Medicare and SS because they are programs that were paid into.

The long and short of it is that Democrats in my red state are the takers and it isn’t even close. Remove Democrats and we would be far into the black as far as government funding.

 

[ElmerMudd]

Not this Dem lie again, it's been debunked 100 times. You sheeple need some new material.

Read the stats I provided. Trump and MAGA would not know the truth if it bit them on their ass.

 

[ElmerMudd]

Maybe you should check out whether Democrats or Republicans receive more government funds than they pay in. Exclude Medicare and SS because they are programs that were paid into.

The long and short of it is that Democrats in my red state are the takers and it isn’t even close. Remove Democrats and we would be far into the black as far as government funding.

It amazes me how uneducated the Trump supporters are. That is why they support Trump.
Almost everyone of us who has paid in to Social Security and Medicare will take out more than we put in.
Educate yourself

Social Security's unfunded obligations are a major contributor to the debt.
Medicare Parts B and D account for $48.5 trillion of the unfunded obligations, while Medicare Part A accounts for $4.6 trillion.
Social Security and Medicare are major contributors to the US debt, with a combined $78.4 trillion in unfunded obligations over 75 years:

 

[ElmerMudd]

you just about said the same thing elmer....kicking states out....how did you become you?...

I became me by continually educating myself. My good looks came naturally.

 

[ElmerMudd]

This topic has come up repeatedly over the years and one of the main reasons for this is because of all the military installations and contractors that are in the southern states. That aside, you people continuously vote for politicians who redistribute all of this money to these states so why do you keep crying about it?

I am educating those who are alweays pointing their fingers at others as causing the debt.
Take a look at your own house first.
Everyone of us are contributing to the debt because if any politician campaigned oh=n what we need to do to reduce the debt he would not get elected.

 

[ElmerMudd]

Not this shit again


So break off with the red states ...you hate the people anyway ..so why not peacefully secede and build Uber democratic socialist paradise ?

I have no problem with the red states secede from the Union. They have never been able to accept they lost the Civil War.

 

[Harry Dresden]

I became me by continually educating myself. My good looks came naturally.

your education wasnt good enough....you think the USA and NATO are the same type of body...

 

[Independent thinker]

The majority of states who receive more goverment funds than they pay in taxes are red states. They ar getting more from the government than they are paying.
NY and CA pay more in federal taxes than they receive in government funds.

I say we treat states like Trump wants to treat NATO nations. If a state does not pay in equal or more in taxes than they receive from the federal goverment we kick themout of the USA. It would balance the budget.

View attachment 1009046

Democrats always have to cook the books with per capita numbers in order to prove their points.