The Flint Water Crisis - Report Card

DGS49

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2012
15,871
13,412
2,415
Pittsburgh
Most of us who regularly read newspapers are aware that many years ago, the appointed city manager of Flint, Michigan, in partial response to a fiscal crisis, changed the feedwater of the Flint water treatment plant from someplace "good" to the Detroit river, which had a higher acidic content. This change resulted in a chemical reaction that caused the lead in water lines to leech into the water supply, and ended up increasing the amount of lead in Flint's drinking water. We all know that lead is poisonous and has all sorts of negative impacts on health, especially in children.

Bottom line: Flint's population, which is largely African American has been drinking water that is unsafe, because of this decision, which of course is characterized as "racist." The linked article outlines the problem and its aftermath.


The element of the article that I find most interesting is as follows:

"...the broader effects of the crisis, such as the major social upheaval and overall sense of crisis, beyond direct lead poisoning, had a larger impact on educational outcomes."

In other words, all the public fuss about the problem caused more harm than the problem itself. The article also states that people living in homes that got less of the lead-poisoning had the same detrimental effects as those that had more.

One suspects that if the whole thing had been kept a secret, everyone would have been better off.

And one can also notice that a lot of people got rich over this, and somewhere, somehow, about $600 Million will go to the victims, and presumably to their lawyers and "public advocates" who made this story what it was. Fortunately, the Democrats in Congress can just print that money and nobody will ever actually have to pay for it.
 
Why would anyone drink untreated tap water anywhere? Install a reverse osmosis water purification system or a distiller. The same 'health freaks' that first introduced flossing have been telling people that for decades.

Distiller.JPG
 
Last edited:
I know of galvanized steel pipes used as plumbing but that was years ago PVC and copper are used here in Florida. Lead pipes used in plumbing is odd.
 
Most of us who regularly read newspapers are aware that many years ago, the appointed city manager of Flint, Michigan, in partial response to a fiscal crisis, changed the feedwater of the Flint water treatment plant from someplace "good" to the Detroit river, which had a higher acidic content. This change resulted in a chemical reaction that caused the lead in water lines to leech into the water supply, and ended up increasing the amount of lead in Flint's drinking water. We all know that lead is poisonous and has all sorts of negative impacts on health, especially in children.

Bottom line: Flint's population, which is largely African American has been drinking water that is unsafe, because of this decision, which of course is characterized as "racist." The linked article outlines the problem and its aftermath.


The element of the article that I find most interesting is as follows:

"...the broader effects of the crisis, such as the major social upheaval and overall sense of crisis, beyond direct lead poisoning, had a larger impact on educational outcomes."

In other words, all the public fuss about the problem caused more harm than the problem itself. The article also states that people living in homes that got less of the lead-poisoning had the same detrimental effects as those that had more.

One suspects that if the whole thing had been kept a secret, everyone would have been better off.

And one can also notice that a lot of people got rich over this, and somewhere, somehow, about $600 Million will go to the victims, and presumably to their lawyers and "public advocates" who made this story what it was. Fortunately, the Democrats in Congress can just print that money and nobody will ever actually have to pay for it.

So you think it's okay for government to hide her misdeeds? ... let me get this straight ... you want any cold-blooded murder by state officials to be completely hidden, and presumably no accountability ... generally, that's a Democrat ideal ... but if Republicans want at that too ... I guess nothing's stopping them ...

Yesterday, Flint, Michigan was held in contempt of court for failing to replace the lead pipes in their water system ... {Cite} ... is there lead pipes in your water system too? ...
 
Last edited:
I know of galvanized steel pipes used as plumbing but that was years ago PVC and copper are used here in Florida. Lead pipes used in plumbing is odd.

Lead pipe is cheap to make and work ... other than gold or meteoric iron, lead was the first metal to be refined ... before copper even ... yeah, lead pipes is old school for sure but that was an thing back in the day ...
 
I suspect that any household that wanted bottled water to drink could have obtained it quite easily in the aftermath of this scandal. In fact, if the State had wanted to do so, it could have simply made bottled water available to everyone served by the water plant in question, forever.

No deaths have been reported. If there had been any deaths that could have been associated with this development, it would have been front page news in the NYT.

This is similar to the asbestos situation. Asbestos is embedded in building infrastructure all over the place. As long as it is not disturbed, it is perfectly safe, and yet how many thousands of buildings were torn up and "abated" at great cost, in reaction to the revelations about asbestos' harms.
 
the appointed city manager of Flint, Michigan, in partial response to a fiscal crisis, changed the feedwater of the Flint water treatment plant from someplace "good" to the Detroit river, which had a higher acidic content.
Uh, NO

The Detroit river is nowhere near, Flint. The Detroit river is also downstream.

Detroit does not get it's water from the Detroit river, it is too contaminated. Detroit gets it's water from Lake Huron, where Flint got it's water. Until the switchef to the nicely polluted Flint river.

why anybody would use the heavily polluted Flint river is a question everyone should ask
 
Uh, NO

The Detroit river is nowhere near, Flint. The Detroit river is also downstream.

Detroit does not get it's water from the Detroit river, it is too contaminated. Detroit gets it's water from Lake Huron, where Flint got it's water. Until the switchef to the nicely polluted Flint river.

why anybody would use the heavily polluted Flint river is a question everyone should ask

 
The Flint river is toxic, you are not even suppose to eat the fish in the Flint river.

Think Genersl Motors and DOW chemical company, for decades dumping toxins in the river
Yep. But some here don't agree with holding corporations accountable on environmental issues. They're more concerned about profits.
 
Yep. But some here don't agree with holding corporations accountable on environmental issues. They're more concerned about profits.
DOW chemical got caught red handed dumping in the Flint River, or one of the streams that feeds the Flint river back in the 1980's

The president of DOW in a public announcement asked what the big deal is, he literally stated, it is only thousands of dead fish, it is not like children are dying
 
DOW chemical got caught red handed dumping in the Flint River, or one of the streams that feeds the Flint river back in the 1980's

The president of DOW in a public announcement asked what the big deal is, he literally stated, it is only thousands of dead fish, it is not like children are dying
Shut down DOW. All Americans agree
 

Forum List

Back
Top