Texas Abortion law stands

[Faun]

What that means is that slaveholders instead of small farmers wrote the CSA constitution

So? The farmers still fought for their Constitution which enshrined slavery.

 

[Mac-7]

So? The farmers still fought for their Constitution which enshrined slavery.

Are there any middle relievers in your bullpen?

Because your starting pitching is in trouble

Confederate soldiers fought for their family, neighbors and their state

Slavery was not an issue for them

 

[Faun]

Are there any middle relievers in your bullpen?

Because your starting pitching is in trouble

Confederate soldiers fought for their family, neighbors and their state

Slavery was not an issue for them

They fought for their constitution. You said so yourself...

Don't we fight in wars to defend our Constitution?

We do

The confederates fought for the Constitution in numerous wars

 

[Mac-7]

They fought for their constitution. You said so yourself...

And so did the union soldiers when slavery was still legal

 

[Faun]

And so did the union soldiers when slavery was still legal

False. The U.S. Constitution did not enshrine slavery. It neither protected nor endorsed slavery. So no, Union soldiers did not fight for slavery.

 

[Mac-7]

False. The U.S. Constitution did not enshrine slavery. It neither protected nor endorsed slavery. So no, Union soldiers did not fight for slavery.

Slavery was legal under the Constitution

 

[Faun]

Slavery was legal under the Constitution

But the Constitution didn't enshrine, protect or endorse it. As a result, there were stares in the north which banned it. Something prohibited by the Confederacy's constitution, which made slavery permanent and prohibited states from banning it. So while I note your desperation, Union soldiers were not fighting for slavery. Confederate soldiers were.

 

[Mac-7]

But the Constitution didn't enshrine, protect or endorse it. As a result, there were stares in the north which banned it. Something prohibited by the Confederacy's constitution, which made slavery permanent and prohibited states from banning it. So while I note your desperation, Union soldiers were not fighting for slavery. Confederate soldiers were.

You are wasting my time by playing a weak game of Gotcha

The Confederate soldiers were brave and honorable men and trying to demonize them 150 years late shows desperation on your part

 

[Faun]

You are wasting my time by playing a weak game of Gotcha

The Confederate soldiers were brave and honorable men and trying to demonize them 150 years late shows desperation on your part

It's not a gotcha game. They were fighting to preserve slavery. For some reason, you're hell bent on denying that.

 

[Mr Natural]

You are wasting my time by playing a weak game of Gotcha

The Confederate soldiers were brave and honorable men and trying to demonize them 150 years late shows desperation on your part

Brave and honorable men willing to die so their betters didn’t have to pay the help.

 

[Mac-7]

They were fighting to preserve slavery.

They were fights for independence from the north

 

[Faun]

They were fights for independence from the north

To preserve slavery.

 

[Mac-7]

To preserve slavery.

For independence

Slave states were represented on both sides

 

[Faun]

For independence

Slave states were represented on both sides

But only one side enshrined slavery in their Constitution. Confederate soldiers fought for that.

 

[Mac-7]

But only one side enshrined slavery in their Constitution. Confederate soldiers fought for that.

I see you never heard of the 3/5ths compromise which was part of the US Constitution during the Civil War

Understanding the three-fifths compromise | Constitutional Accountability Center

[Note: this op-ed is not by Constitutional Accountability Center, and does not represent our views of the three-fifths compromise, but is on our website because the author refers to us directly. For our response to this piece, see the article published in the same outlet–the San Antonio...

www.theusconstitution.org

 

[Faun]

I see you never heard of the 3/5ths compromise which was part of the US Constitution during the Civil War

Understanding the three-fifths compromise | Constitutional Accountability Center

[Note: this op-ed is not by Constitutional Accountability Center, and does not represent our views of the three-fifths compromise, but is on our website because the author refers to us directly. For our response to this piece, see the article published in the same outlet–the San Antonio...

www.theusconstitution.org

That was in terms of apportioning seats in Congress, it didn't endorse or protect slavery as states were free to ban slavery if they wanted to; and some did.

But the Confederacy made slavery permanent within Confederate states, Confederate territories, and states admitted into the Confederacy. That's what Confederate soldiers fought for. You lied when you denied they fought for slavery.

 

[Mac-7]

That was in terms of apportioning seats in Congress, it didn't endorse or protect slavery as states were free to ban slavery if they wanted to; and some did.

Of course the constitution recognized and allowed slavery

 

[Faun]

Of course the constitution recognized and allowed slavery

I didn't say it didn't. It allowed the states to decide for themselves and northern state were banning it. That's what Union soldiers fought for.

The South enshrined slavery in the Constitution and prohibited banning it, making it permanent in ALL Confederate states and territories. That's what Confederate soldiers fought for.

 

[Mac-7]

I didn't say it didn't. It allowed the states to decide for themselves and northern state were banning it. That's what Union soldiers fought for.

Not all states that remained in the union and fought on the union side banned slavery

 

[Faun]

Not all states that remained in the union and fought on the union side banned slavery

So? The U.S. Constitution still didn't institutionalize slavery. The Confederacy's Constitution did. Slavery in the north was vanishing and fighting with the south over that issue. So the south seceded to keep their slaves. That's what Confederate soldiers fought for. And they're heroes to you. How sad.