Big and small businesses want cheap labor. Republicans want the border protected before enacting immigration reform for illegals. Democrats like the idea of a new underclass being cultivated to vote democrat. If hispanic communities tended to overwhelmingly vote republican then we would see the republicans talking like democrats and the democrats talking like republicans.
In the end though, nothing will happen. This is all smoke and mirrors and rhetoric and hypocrisy in the form of political jousting.
Enforcing the laws that we already have in terms of hiring illegal aliens and paying under the table while constructing a fence buttressed by cameras and more border agents would solve the problem. Neither side wants to really solve any problem though. This is about votes and one-upmanship. Not about principle and fixing an economy.
I was with you up until the end. Republicans can clearly see, (especially after the demographics of the Romney loss) that they MUST control how many illegal immigrants can vote. My guess is they are willing to let big business absorb the higher costs of labor to regain their cultural strength in winning elections.
Unless you could supply a link to the contrary, I do not think the ego factor of one-upsmanship is at play here. I think it is the savings of $197,000,000 over the next five that puts illegal aliens onto the tax rolls.
This is a very difficult issue because of its complexity, and the fact that 12,000,000 illegals are already in the United States. I recall what NBC said. Most Republican members of Congress are from districts without Hispanic voters. These Republicans are relatively certain of re-election, and apparently have constituents who do not want more Hispanics in the United States.
I can not help but hope the migrant farm worker issue, which was negotiated months ago between business and labor will pass. Businesses would be required to pick up the green carded workers at the border, and return them when the season is done. They would be required to sign off any rights for themselves or their family in the United States. Failure to do something here will not only effect immigrants, but produce prices, the availability of fresh produce, and the agriculture business that is already under siege with fires, floods, and drought. It would be nice if they could just fix this aspect separately.