"Insurance" is an investment.
Insurance companies take your money then invest in stocks, bonds, real estate, private equity, hedge funds, infrastructure, timber, etc.
Yet, only SS invests in government debt obligations.
SS is, in fact, an annuity, which is pretty much the same thing as a defined benefit pension obligation, i.e. it's a pension
SS wouldn't pass ERISA standards if it were anything other than SS, which is pathetic.
SS invests solely in government obligations, which compounds over time at about 4%-5% a year, though its 2%-3% today. A typical pension plan is invested 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds and compounds over time at 8% per year. $100 million invested at 4% is worth $460 million in 50 years. $100 million invested at 8% is worth $4.6 billion in 50 years. We can secure SS for centuries and give people a tax cut if we start treating SS like other countries do, and start investing it like every single other pension plan in the country.
It's not 1930 anymore. It's time to stop acting like it when it comes to SS.
BTW "keep government off my SS" is about as ridiculous as "keep government out of my Medicare."
Sure it is. But you see, we live in a representative republic. Most of the time people get what they want and what they pay for. Funny how that works.
So, sorry you do not like it. No, actually i could care less.
But here is the deal. People want their money safe. They could care less if you have a better scheme for THEIR money. They want the insurance to pay back while they live. They do not want another great republican recession of 2008 to happen to them, and the gov to say "Damn, if only you had retired last year, we would have had a million for you. But, now, well, you are on your own".
But, if you are a politician, the financial industry is pushing for you to change SS to an investment program, so that they can make a few Trillion bucks over time. And you just have to try to get interest. And you will get interest from the voters, if you push it. And you can find a new job.
Then, you can post about how stupid SS is. And how it is not insurance, but an annuity. An annuity that goes to zero, if you die before you are paid. Or if the market tanks again. And you can talk about how stupid ss is, and that the public still wants it. Maybe you should look in the mirror, and see if you see stupid there.