Question For Harry Potter Fans

[ChristisKing]

I was originally just going to post this in a DM for mudwhistle, but I wanted different opinions about this. Could Crookshanks be the Potter's old cat?

 

[mudwhistle]

I was originally just going to post this in a DM for mudwhistle, but I wanted different opinions about this. Could Crookshanks be the Potter's old cat?

No.....Crookshanks was in the pet store when Harry got his pet Owl, Hedgwig.
Hermoine felt sorry for him and adopted him on the spot.

 

[ChristisKing]

No.....Crookshanks was in the pet store when Harry got his pet Owl, Hedgwig.
Hermoine felt sorry for him and adopted him on the spot.

I know that but we don't know what happened before he got there.

 

[mudwhistle]

I know that but we don't know what happened before he got there.

Lilly Potter had a cat that disappeared on the night she was killed.....but there's no evidence it was Crookshanks.

 

[ChristisKing]

Lilly Potter had a cat that disappeared on the night she was killed.....but there's no evidence it was Crookshanks.

No it's just a theory but just so you know JK Rowling spells the name L-i-l-y not L-i-l-l-y. I don't mean to be a grammar Nazi, just informing you. Me personally, I like both spellings but L-i-l-y is my favorite now because it's spelled like the flower. It didn't use to be until I realized how pretty that is.