You know, Robert, the more I consider Benjamin Button, the more disappointed I become. It really is such a direct ripoff of Forrest Gump. I hope to God it doesn't win Oscars for Best Picture and/or Screenplay. It just doesn't deserve them. First of all, it's hardly an adaptation of Fitzgerald's short story, the only commonality is a man who ages backwards (which appeared in literature centuries ago with Merlin the wizard). Secondly, the Forrest Gump formula was basically replicated for this film.
Found this over at IMDb, very enlightening:
Forrest Gump
It must be love: Forrest meets and falls for Jenny, the love of his life, when both are children.
A little extra support: Forrest relies on leg braces early in life.
An early loss: He is abandoned by his father.
Big mamma's house: His self-sacrificing mother runs a boarding house.
A soldier, a friend: He goes to war with Lt. Dan, who became a friend.
Soothing a broken heart: When Jenny rejects him, Forrest finds comfort in running.
Nature's signals: A feather appears to symbolize the connectedness of life.
Setting sail to the future: Forrest gets a job on a shrimp boat.
Swept away by a plot point: Hurricane Carmen blows through the plot.
Long-lost loves: After Jenny suffers a health crisis, she returns home to Forrest.
A father's fears: Forrest worries his son will have his same affliction.
Mothers' wisdom: His mamma always told him: "Life is like a box of chocolates. You never know what you're going to get."
Benjamin Button
It must be love: Benjamin meets and falls for Daisy, the love of his life, when both are children.
A little extra support: Benjamin relies on leg braces early in life.
An early loss: He is abandoned by his father.
Big mamma's house: His self-sacrificing mother runs a boarding house for the aged.
A soldier, a friend: He goes to war with Capt. Mike, who became a friend.
Soothing a broken heart: When Daisy rejects him, Benjamin takes comfort in running around with other women.
Nature's signals: A hummingbird appears to symbolize the connectedness of life.
Setting sail to the future: Benjamin gets a job on a tugboat.
Swept away by a plot point: Hurricane Katrina blows through the plot.
Long-lost loves: After Daisy suffers a health crisis, she returns home to Benjamin.
A father's fears: Benjamin worries his child will have his affliction.
Mothers' wisdom: His mamma always told him: "You never know what's coming for you."