JimBowie1958
A.
if anyone abuses a gun, if any criminals or mentally ill people get possession of guns,
if anyone suffers from a crime, abuse, trauma or other damage from abuse of a gun,
YES, we as a society have a problem with guns getting abused.
No, you confuse the tool with the tool user. The user is the problem, not the tool. It's as if you want to prevent deforestation by banning pull saws, seemingly unaware that there are still other options to the users and people are going to use chain saws any damned way.
A. I would compare this with how "problems with drunk driving"
are BOTH a driver safety issue AND a drinking/addiction problem.
I posted this comparison on another thread:
"If we don't solve the problem with drinking addictions, which aren't always visible,
we end up with drunk driving problems to find out where there was unchecked alcoholic addiction.
Same with the gun problem: if we don't solve the problem with mental illness, which isn't always visible,
we end up with gun problems to find out where there was unchecked mental illness.
It trickles or escalates into the worse problem, though both stem from mental illness or addiction first."
As for power tools, I read of ONE case in the news, where a mentally ill person got hold of a power tool and cut himself up:
Man slices arms with saws at Calif. Home Depot
If this happened a lot, yes, we would then notice a problem with "power tools getting abused by the mentally ill." And measures would focus on how to avoid this particular type of disaster.
B. RE: "You cannot place a requirement on a natural right. Imagine that you were telling feminazis that they have to get training before they can go get an abortion to murder their own babies, except that in the case of guns we are talking about a real natural right, not some SCOTUS myth."
Dear
JimBowie1958 Freedom of Choice/Free will/Freedom of religion are natural rights.
However choosing things that don't exist in nature, such as
* guns (as opposed to unarmed defense that we have with or without manufactured weapons)
* induced abortions (as opposed to miscarriages without outside procedures)
DO require certain knowledge or understanding in order
to guarantee that person using that thing is fully informed or trained (such as in the case of guns, cars, or other mechanical equipment that takes more than natural instinct to use).
It is abusive or negligent to "let someone choose abortion" who isn't fully informed of the effects
or risks involved. Just because this may be more common than acknowledged doesn't make it right.. The risks of coercion and/or damage emotionally run high
compared with the low percentage of people with no ill effects from post-abortion syndrome.
With guns, if people are not safely trained and screened to handle arms responsibly,
(including treating all guns as if they are loaded, and locking them away safely)
this risks endangering the safety of others.
This becomes similar to training people to drive a car responsibly for the safety of oneself and others (though driving is a privilege not a right).
Yes, "human free will" is in our nature, and these other variations of the concept of "free choice."
But depending on the choices, some of these involve greater responsibility and/or training to ensure proper safety so there is no endangerment, abuse or negligence from lack of knowledge, experience, and/or safety precautions. Otherwise, endangering others can violate 'equal protection or security' which is an equal principle within the same set of Constitutional laws.
I would say the issue is how to address guns WITHIN THE CONTEXT of the rest of the Constitution. We don't want abuses of our rights and freedoms to create a breach of the peace and threats to security, or that will threaten other parts of the law on public safety and equal protections.
The key is how to find the right balance, where we neither have too much freedom (that is negligently getting abused) or imposing restrictions too much on freedom unnecessarily (where it deprives liberty without due process and is unfair to law abiding citizens).