Montana Supreme Court Nixes Extremist Anti Abortion laws, Citing onstitutional Privacy Rights

[Moonglow]

Legal semantic weeds. Make something obvious and simple into something disingenuously and unnecessarily complicated.
Abortion was not considered when most law was established.
Copulation is a contract. Duh.

Really, can we see Adam and Eve's?

 

[Rawley]

50 years as a constitutional right thrown down the tubes because of an activist SCOTUS.

Uh, It wasn't a Consitutional right.

 

[Mac-7]

Montana’s Republican-controlled legislature abrogated privacy rights guaranteed by the state constitution, the court ruled:

“nder Montana’s Constitution, the right of individual privacy—that is, the right of personal autonomy or the right to be let alone—is fundamental.

“It is, perhaps, one of the most important rights guaranteed to the citizens of this State, and its separate textual protection in our Constitution reflects Montanans’ historical abhorrence and distrust of excessive governmental interference in their personal lives.”

The high court sided with an advanced practice nurse practitioner and a clinician who challenged a 2005 law, styled “Control of Practice of Abortion,” that limited who could provide health services.

The health professionals also are called advanced practice registered nurses (APRNs), family nurse practitioners (FNPs), certified nurse-midwifes (CNMs), and physician assistants (PAs).

The district court ruled that the legislature violated a woman’s “fundamental right of privacy to seek abortion care from a qualified health care provider of her choosing” when enacting the 2005 law.

Montana Supreme Court nixes extremist anti-abortion laws, citing constitutional privacy rights

Montana’s highest court unanimously upheld a a district court ruling that overturned a 2005 law restricting who could provide abortion services. The 7-0 decision cited privacy rights enumerated in Montana’s constitution, in a ruling that likely also...

www.dailykos.com

Hang on America. We will get rid of these anti American extremist assholes, state by state. Election by election.

It's coming, and may take longer in certain areas of the country where the most extreme anti American fringe lunatics are. But it's coming.

Privacy is more fundamental than life itself?

I dont think so

 

[Stann]

Uh, It wasn't a Consitutional right.

It was. Until the minority opinion of Scalia and Thomas was supported by the radicals trump deceptively got on the Supreme Court. The result is chaos now because emotions triumphed over reason on this issue.

 

[Catsnmeters]

Uh, It wasn't a Consitutional right.

Yes it was.

No offense intended but please read up on the constitution.

It's important that Americans have a good understanding of how their rights work.

 

[Stann]

Privacy is more fundamental than life itself?

I dont think so

Freedom of the individual is what America is about. Fetuses aren't and never will be individuals. They aren't " babies " that's why they're properly / factually called fetuses.

 

[Rawley]

It was. Until the minority opinion of Scalia and Thomas was supported by the radicals trump deceptively got on the Supreme Court. The result is chaos now because emotions triumphed over reason on this issue.

OK. The other side is that the chaos started with Roe that established a Constitutional right that didn't exist. Even RBG argued it was ill times and ill considered.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2022/05/06/ruth-bader-ginsburg-roe-wade/

 

[Rawley]

Yes it was.

Nope

No offense intended but please read up on the constitution.

Backacha

It's important that Americans have a good understanding of how their rights work.

Yup

 

[Stann]

OK. The other side is that the chaos started with Roe that established a Constitutional right that didn't exist. Even RBG argued it was ill times and ill considered.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2022/05/06/ruth-bader-ginsburg-roe-wade/

When the president and the republicans use deception to get a ruling passed that should be the first indication of corruption of the law. This is what they did. It's undeniable , that's why all the unrest and outrage. No one should have such power over another person's personal life decisions.

 

[Rawley]

When the president and the republicans use deception to get a ruling passed that should be the first indication of corruption of the law. This is what they did. It's undeniable , that's why all the unrest and outrage.

OK, I'll bite. What are you talking about?

 

[Mac-7]

Fetuses aren't and never will be individuals.

Unborn children have unique DNA

They are individual human beings

 

[Stann]

OK, I'll bite. What are you talking about?

The three new republican supreme court judges all lied when they said Roe vs Wade was settled law and they wouldn't mess with it. This was an organized effort to decide the American public.

 

[Catsnmeters]

Nope

Backacha

Yup

So you are not familiar with the 9th amendment and unenumerated rights?

Do you want me to explain it to you or will you do the research yourself?

 

[Rawley]

The three new republican supreme court judges all lied when they said Roe vs Wade was settled law

Yup. So was Plessy

and they wouldn't mess with it.

Nope. None of them promised "they wouldn't mess with it."

This was an organized effort to decide the American public.

There's always impeachment. Your party seems to be a big fan of that process.

 

[Stann]

Unborn children have unique DNA

They are individual human beings

You obviously don't understand the simple idea of what an individual human being is.

 

[Rawley]

So you are not familiar with the 9th amendment and unenumerated rights?

Good luck with that.

Do you want me to explain it to you or will you do the research yourself?

Condescension is a tell that you're not comfortable with your argument.

 

[Stann]

Yup. So was Plessy

Nope. None of them promised "they wouldn't mess with it."


There's always impeachment. Your party seems to be a big fan of that process.

I'm not as foolish as you are , I put my faith in no political party , especially ones that practice deception and rule without reason. I am an Independent.

 

[Stann]

Condescension is a tell that you're not comfortable with your argument.

No , it means you're appear to be very ignorant that's all.

 

[Rawley]

I'm not as foolish as you are , I put my faith in no political party , especially ones that practice deception and rule without reason. I am an Independent.

You poopyhead. I win

 

[Rawley]

No , it means you're appear to be very ignorant that's all.

Have a blessed day