Modern Israel's borders

[USAF 2023]

RE: Modern Israel's borders
※→ P F Tinmore, et al,

Well, the bottom line is: The Arab Palestinians are NOT owed anything. The Right to Sovereignty or Territorial Integrity does not guarantee a country. No one owes the Arab Palestinians a country simply based on their rights. And the Arab Palestinians are not entitled to take any territory based on these rights.

What qualifications have I added?

(COMMENT)

The implication all along has been that some territorial expanse, boundaries undefined, under which the Arab Palestinians have the authority of a state to govern itself (sovereign) is their state. They do not have any territory to which they hold the supreme authority; or which they can claim they stand alone. For more than a century, every square inch of the territory formerly under the Mandate, has been controlled by an authority other than the contemporary Arab Palestinians.

Most Respectfully,
R

Then let's drop a Bomb on Israel,I suppose,for Palestinians to RECLAIM THEIR LAND is your suggestion for resolution....With respect you are an IDIOT

What you “ think?’

 

[Shusha]

Not so. All of the Jews who normally lived there became citizens of Palestine with the same rights as everybody else.

Including the inherent right to sovereignty.

 

[Shusha]

Indeed, Palestine has always been a non self governing territory under colonial and alien rule.

But you just said that the Jewish people lived there (were people of the place) and have an inherent right to sovereignty. It IS, by definition, self-governing.

 

[theliq]

Then let's drop a Bomb on Israel,

You don't have a bomb ... Australia doesn't even have a bomb.

Australian have to rely on Americans to defend them, like they did in the Battle of the Coral Sea (you're welcome).

So, if Zionists control the US, as you maintain, you might want to kiss the Zionist arse or maybe we'll decide you're not worth defending, again.

Idiot, Coral Sea that was 70 years ago...DUH

We can look after ourselves ZIONISTS are complete SHIT AND ZIONISTS ARE A BREED OF SHIT

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians was a newspaper article published in The Australian on 27 June 2013,[1] coinciding with that year's Australia Day. Compiled by News Limited journalist Billy Rule, the article listed what he considered were the top 50 individuals (including one horse) who "have helped define who we are as a people and how Australia is perceived as a country", including 'trailblazers', those who left a legacy for others to admire or benefit from, and those that engendered inspiration.

7. Sir John Monash: Australian Army general and victor of the Battle of Hamel in the First World War (born 1865, Victoria; died 1931, Victoria)

General Sir John Monash, commander of the Australian corps in France from 1917. An Australian born Jew of Prussian parentage, Monash was credited with instigating the offensive which broke the Hindeburg Line thus winning the war. In peacetime, Monash came to be regarded as the greatest living Australian. In 1927 he was made foundation President of the Zionist Federation of Australia, having presided over the opening of the NSW Jewish War Memorial, or Maccabean Hall, in Darlinghurst, Sydney, on 11 November 1923.

OOOOPPPPPSSSSS Rylah...you forget,you are addressing me Steve,a great admirer of John Monash(Monasch) who's parents came to Australia in circa 1850.

Together with his contempary, Isaac Isaacs,are two outstanding Australians of Jewish lineage that have contributed to this country.

Rylah there was much distrust of Jews and Anti-Jewish feeling in Australia at the time and through great endeavour only shows how remarkable these two men were.

But Rylah,all of what you said is correct but with Qualification...Both Isaacs and Monasch,were Anti-Zionist for various reasons....

After WW1(Where John's outstanding Military Career had Ended) He came back to Australia,in 1924 he met Israel Cohen,a Zionist Leader from England looking to bolster Zionism in Australia...offering him Governor of Palestine and other positions...which Monasch refused...

He was nowhere near converting to Zionism at that time...but you know the Zionists better than I Ry.,once they get their claws into you the Brain Washing starts

Yes Monash busied himself within the Jewish community,mainly in Sydney but mainly Melbourne, did as you say become the foundation President of the Australian Zionist Federation BUT THIS WAS ONLY A HONOURY POSITION...and the only Blot on a wonderful life..steve

 

[theliq]

RE: Modern Israel's borders
※→ P F Tinmore, et al,

Well, the bottom line is: The Arab Palestinians are NOT owed anything. The Right to Sovereignty or Territorial Integrity does not guarantee a country. No one owes the Arab Palestinians a country simply based on their rights. And the Arab Palestinians are not entitled to take any territory based on these rights.

What qualifications have I added?

(COMMENT)

The implication all along has been that some territorial expanse, boundaries undefined, under which the Arab Palestinians have the authority of a state to govern itself (sovereign) is their state. They do not have any territory to which they hold the supreme authority; or which they can claim they stand alone. For more than a century, every square inch of the territory formerly under the Mandate, has been controlled by an authority other than the contemporary Arab Palestinians.

Most Respectfully,
R

Then let's drop a Bomb on Israel,I suppose,for Palestinians to RECLAIM THEIR LAND is your suggestion for resolution....With respect you are an IDIOT

What you “ think?’

It's not what I the Magnificent think...it is the FACT of the Matter...I think your crassy comment is referring to yourself,as usual

 

[rylah]

Then let's drop a Bomb on Israel,

You don't have a bomb ... Australia doesn't even have a bomb.

Australian have to rely on Americans to defend them, like they did in the Battle of the Coral Sea (you're welcome).

So, if Zionists control the US, as you maintain, you might want to kiss the Zionist arse or maybe we'll decide you're not worth defending, again.

Idiot, Coral Sea that was 70 years ago...DUH

We can look after ourselves ZIONISTS are complete SHIT AND ZIONISTS ARE A BREED OF SHIT

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians was a newspaper article published in The Australian on 27 June 2013,[1] coinciding with that year's Australia Day. Compiled by News Limited journalist Billy Rule, the article listed what he considered were the top 50 individuals (including one horse) who "have helped define who we are as a people and how Australia is perceived as a country", including 'trailblazers', those who left a legacy for others to admire or benefit from, and those that engendered inspiration.

7. Sir John Monash: Australian Army general and victor of the Battle of Hamel in the First World War (born 1865, Victoria; died 1931, Victoria)

General Sir John Monash, commander of the Australian corps in France from 1917. An Australian born Jew of Prussian parentage, Monash was credited with instigating the offensive which broke the Hindeburg Line thus winning the war. In peacetime, Monash came to be regarded as the greatest living Australian. In 1927 he was made foundation President of the Zionist Federation of Australia, having presided over the opening of the NSW Jewish War Memorial, or Maccabean Hall, in Darlinghurst, Sydney, on 11 November 1923.

OOOOPPPPPSSSSS Rylah...you forget,you are addressing me Steve,a great admirer of John Monash(Monasch) who's parents came to Australia in circa 1850.

Together with his contempary, Isaac Isaacs,are two outstanding Australians of Jewish lineage that have contributed to this country.

Rylah there was much distrust of Jews and Anti-Jewish feeling in Australia at the time and through great endeavour only shows how remarkable these two men were.

But Rylah,all of what you said is correct but with Qualification...Both Isaacs and Monasch,were Anti-Zionist for various reasons....

After WW1(Where John's outstanding Military Career had Ended) He came back to Australia,in 1924 he met Israel Cohen,a Zionist Leader from England looking to bolster Zionism in Australia...offering him Governor of Palestine and other positions...which Monasch refused...

He was nowhere near converting to Zionism at that time...but you know the Zionists better than I Ry.,once they get their claws into you the Brain Washing starts

Yes Monash busied himself within the Jewish community,mainly in Sydney but mainly Melbourne, did as you say become the foundation President of the Australian Zionist Federation BUT THIS WAS ONLY A HONOURY POSITION...and the only Blot on a wonderful life..steve

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

 

[theliq]

Then let's drop a Bomb on Israel,

You don't have a bomb ... Australia doesn't even have a bomb.

Australian have to rely on Americans to defend them, like they did in the Battle of the Coral Sea (you're welcome).

So, if Zionists control the US, as you maintain, you might want to kiss the Zionist arse or maybe we'll decide you're not worth defending, again.

Idiot, Coral Sea that was 70 years ago...DUH

We can look after ourselves ZIONISTS are complete SHIT AND ZIONISTS ARE A BREED OF SHIT

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians was a newspaper article published in The Australian on 27 June 2013,[1] coinciding with that year's Australia Day. Compiled by News Limited journalist Billy Rule, the article listed what he considered were the top 50 individuals (including one horse) who "have helped define who we are as a people and how Australia is perceived as a country", including 'trailblazers', those who left a legacy for others to admire or benefit from, and those that engendered inspiration.

7. Sir John Monash: Australian Army general and victor of the Battle of Hamel in the First World War (born 1865, Victoria; died 1931, Victoria)

General Sir John Monash, commander of the Australian corps in France from 1917. An Australian born Jew of Prussian parentage, Monash was credited with instigating the offensive which broke the Hindeburg Line thus winning the war. In peacetime, Monash came to be regarded as the greatest living Australian. In 1927 he was made foundation President of the Zionist Federation of Australia, having presided over the opening of the NSW Jewish War Memorial, or Maccabean Hall, in Darlinghurst, Sydney, on 11 November 1923.

OOOOPPPPPSSSSS Rylah...you forget,you are addressing me Steve,a great admirer of John Monash(Monasch) who's parents came to Australia in circa 1850.

Together with his contempary, Isaac Isaacs,are two outstanding Australians of Jewish lineage that have contributed to this country.

Rylah there was much distrust of Jews and Anti-Jewish feeling in Australia at the time and through great endeavour only shows how remarkable these two men were.

But Rylah,all of what you said is correct but with Qualification...Both Isaacs and Monasch,were Anti-Zionist for various reasons....

After WW1(Where John's outstanding Military Career had Ended) He came back to Australia,in 1924 he met Israel Cohen,a Zionist Leader from England looking to bolster Zionism in Australia...offering him Governor of Palestine and other positions...which Monasch refused...

He was nowhere near converting to Zionism at that time...but you know the Zionists better than I Ry.,once they get their claws into you the Brain Washing starts

Yes Monash busied himself within the Jewish community,mainly in Sydney but mainly Melbourne, did as you say become the foundation President of the Australian Zionist Federation BUT THIS WAS ONLY A HONOURY POSITION...and the only Blot on a wonderful life..steve

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

It's Monash or Monasch and he was until after WW1......you try to make Tall,but you Zionists creep,you boasting Pharisee you'll never conquer me,though the road maybe rocky,and the Zionists Creep those Sinners,where you gonna run to,where you gonna HIDE

 

[USAF 2023]

You don't have a bomb ... Australia doesn't even have a bomb.

Australian have to rely on Americans to defend them, like they did in the Battle of the Coral Sea (you're welcome).

So, if Zionists control the US, as you maintain, you might want to kiss the Zionist arse or maybe we'll decide you're not worth defending, again.

Idiot, Coral Sea that was 70 years ago...DUH

We can look after ourselves ZIONISTS are complete SHIT AND ZIONISTS ARE A BREED OF SHIT

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians was a newspaper article published in The Australian on 27 June 2013,[1] coinciding with that year's Australia Day. Compiled by News Limited journalist Billy Rule, the article listed what he considered were the top 50 individuals (including one horse) who "have helped define who we are as a people and how Australia is perceived as a country", including 'trailblazers', those who left a legacy for others to admire or benefit from, and those that engendered inspiration.

7. Sir John Monash: Australian Army general and victor of the Battle of Hamel in the First World War (born 1865, Victoria; died 1931, Victoria)

General Sir John Monash, commander of the Australian corps in France from 1917. An Australian born Jew of Prussian parentage, Monash was credited with instigating the offensive which broke the Hindeburg Line thus winning the war. In peacetime, Monash came to be regarded as the greatest living Australian. In 1927 he was made foundation President of the Zionist Federation of Australia, having presided over the opening of the NSW Jewish War Memorial, or Maccabean Hall, in Darlinghurst, Sydney, on 11 November 1923.

OOOOPPPPPSSSSS Rylah...you forget,you are addressing me Steve,a great admirer of John Monash(Monasch) who's parents came to Australia in circa 1850.

Together with his contempary, Isaac Isaacs,are two outstanding Australians of Jewish lineage that have contributed to this country.

Rylah there was much distrust of Jews and Anti-Jewish feeling in Australia at the time and through great endeavour only shows how remarkable these two men were.

But Rylah,all of what you said is correct but with Qualification...Both Isaacs and Monasch,were Anti-Zionist for various reasons....

After WW1(Where John's outstanding Military Career had Ended) He came back to Australia,in 1924 he met Israel Cohen,a Zionist Leader from England looking to bolster Zionism in Australia...offering him Governor of Palestine and other positions...which Monasch refused...

He was nowhere near converting to Zionism at that time...but you know the Zionists better than I Ry.,once they get their claws into you the Brain Washing starts

Yes Monash busied himself within the Jewish community,mainly in Sydney but mainly Melbourne, did as you say become the foundation President of the Australian Zionist Federation BUT THIS WAS ONLY A HONOURY POSITION...and the only Blot on a wonderful life..steve

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

It's Monash or Monasch and he was until after WW1......you try to make Tall,but you Zionists creep,you boasting Pharisee you'll never conquer me,though the road maybe rocky,and the Zionists Creep those Sinners,where you gonna run to,where you gonna HIDE

 

[theliq]

Idiot, Coral Sea that was 70 years ago...DUH

We can look after ourselves ZIONISTS are complete SHIT AND ZIONISTS ARE A BREED OF SHIT

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians was a newspaper article published in The Australian on 27 June 2013,[1] coinciding with that year's Australia Day. Compiled by News Limited journalist Billy Rule, the article listed what he considered were the top 50 individuals (including one horse) who "have helped define who we are as a people and how Australia is perceived as a country", including 'trailblazers', those who left a legacy for others to admire or benefit from, and those that engendered inspiration.

7. Sir John Monash: Australian Army general and victor of the Battle of Hamel in the First World War (born 1865, Victoria; died 1931, Victoria)

General Sir John Monash, commander of the Australian corps in France from 1917. An Australian born Jew of Prussian parentage, Monash was credited with instigating the offensive which broke the Hindeburg Line thus winning the war. In peacetime, Monash came to be regarded as the greatest living Australian. In 1927 he was made foundation President of the Zionist Federation of Australia, having presided over the opening of the NSW Jewish War Memorial, or Maccabean Hall, in Darlinghurst, Sydney, on 11 November 1923.

OOOOPPPPPSSSSS Rylah...you forget,you are addressing me Steve,a great admirer of John Monash(Monasch) who's parents came to Australia in circa 1850.

Together with his contempary, Isaac Isaacs,are two outstanding Australians of Jewish lineage that have contributed to this country.

Rylah there was much distrust of Jews and Anti-Jewish feeling in Australia at the time and through great endeavour only shows how remarkable these two men were.

But Rylah,all of what you said is correct but with Qualification...Both Isaacs and Monasch,were Anti-Zionist for various reasons....

After WW1(Where John's outstanding Military Career had Ended) He came back to Australia,in 1924 he met Israel Cohen,a Zionist Leader from England looking to bolster Zionism in Australia...offering him Governor of Palestine and other positions...which Monasch refused...

He was nowhere near converting to Zionism at that time...but you know the Zionists better than I Ry.,once they get their claws into you the Brain Washing starts

Yes Monash busied himself within the Jewish community,mainly in Sydney but mainly Melbourne, did as you say become the foundation President of the Australian Zionist Federation BUT THIS WAS ONLY A HONOURY POSITION...and the only Blot on a wonderful life..steve

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

It's Monash or Monasch and he was until after WW1......you try to make Tall,but you Zionists creep,you boasting Pharisee you'll never conquer me,though the road maybe rocky,and the Zionists Creep those Sinners,where you gonna run to,where you gonna HIDE

It is quite amusing,what Don'tlove thinks is Funny......shame really

 

[USAF 2023]

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians

The Greatest of All - Our 50 Top Australians was a newspaper article published in The Australian on 27 June 2013,[1] coinciding with that year's Australia Day. Compiled by News Limited journalist Billy Rule, the article listed what he considered were the top 50 individuals (including one horse) who "have helped define who we are as a people and how Australia is perceived as a country", including 'trailblazers', those who left a legacy for others to admire or benefit from, and those that engendered inspiration.

7. Sir John Monash: Australian Army general and victor of the Battle of Hamel in the First World War (born 1865, Victoria; died 1931, Victoria)

General Sir John Monash, commander of the Australian corps in France from 1917. An Australian born Jew of Prussian parentage, Monash was credited with instigating the offensive which broke the Hindeburg Line thus winning the war. In peacetime, Monash came to be regarded as the greatest living Australian. In 1927 he was made foundation President of the Zionist Federation of Australia, having presided over the opening of the NSW Jewish War Memorial, or Maccabean Hall, in Darlinghurst, Sydney, on 11 November 1923.

OOOOPPPPPSSSSS Rylah...you forget,you are addressing me Steve,a great admirer of John Monash(Monasch) who's parents came to Australia in circa 1850.

Together with his contempary, Isaac Isaacs,are two outstanding Australians of Jewish lineage that have contributed to this country.

Rylah there was much distrust of Jews and Anti-Jewish feeling in Australia at the time and through great endeavour only shows how remarkable these two men were.

But Rylah,all of what you said is correct but with Qualification...Both Isaacs and Monasch,were Anti-Zionist for various reasons....

After WW1(Where John's outstanding Military Career had Ended) He came back to Australia,in 1924 he met Israel Cohen,a Zionist Leader from England looking to bolster Zionism in Australia...offering him Governor of Palestine and other positions...which Monasch refused...

He was nowhere near converting to Zionism at that time...but you know the Zionists better than I Ry.,once they get their claws into you the Brain Washing starts

Yes Monash busied himself within the Jewish community,mainly in Sydney but mainly Melbourne, did as you say become the foundation President of the Australian Zionist Federation BUT THIS WAS ONLY A HONOURY POSITION...and the only Blot on a wonderful life..steve

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

It's Monash or Monasch and he was until after WW1......you try to make Tall,but you Zionists creep,you boasting Pharisee you'll never conquer me,though the road maybe rocky,and the Zionists Creep those Sinners,where you gonna run to,where you gonna HIDE

It is quite amusing,what Don'tlove thinks is Funny......shame really

You’re right. Don’t think it’s funny that you’re an On the other hand, I do!!

 

[theliq]

OOOOPPPPPSSSSS Rylah...you forget,you are addressing me Steve,a great admirer of John Monash(Monasch) who's parents came to Australia in circa 1850.

Together with his contempary, Isaac Isaacs,are two outstanding Australians of Jewish lineage that have contributed to this country.

Rylah there was much distrust of Jews and Anti-Jewish feeling in Australia at the time and through great endeavour only shows how remarkable these two men were.

But Rylah,all of what you said is correct but with Qualification...Both Isaacs and Monasch,were Anti-Zionist for various reasons....

After WW1(Where John's outstanding Military Career had Ended) He came back to Australia,in 1924 he met Israel Cohen,a Zionist Leader from England looking to bolster Zionism in Australia...offering him Governor of Palestine and other positions...which Monasch refused...

He was nowhere near converting to Zionism at that time...but you know the Zionists better than I Ry.,once they get their claws into you the Brain Washing starts

Yes Monash busied himself within the Jewish community,mainly in Sydney but mainly Melbourne, did as you say become the foundation President of the Australian Zionist Federation BUT THIS WAS ONLY A HONOURY POSITION...and the only Blot on a wonderful life..steve

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

It's Monash or Monasch and he was until after WW1......you try to make Tall,but you Zionists creep,you boasting Pharisee you'll never conquer me,though the road maybe rocky,and the Zionists Creep those Sinners,where you gonna run to,where you gonna HIDE

It is quite amusing,what Don'tlove thinks is Funny......shame really

You’re right. Don’t think it’s funny that you’re an On the other hand, I do!!

DOPE HEAD

 

[USAF 2023]

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

It's Monash or Monasch and he was until after WW1......you try to make Tall,but you Zionists creep,you boasting Pharisee you'll never conquer me,though the road maybe rocky,and the Zionists Creep those Sinners,where you gonna run to,where you gonna HIDE

It is quite amusing,what Don'tlove thinks is Funny......shame really

You’re right. Don’t think it’s funny that you’re an On the other hand, I do!!

DOPE HEAD

 

[member]

The terrorist state of Israel has never declared its borders.

Because it would hinder the zionist leadership's future goal of a greater Israel by land theft. ....

just another of your friendly [juden] conversations.........

what was that? "the holocaust" is a myth"...................

idiot.

 

[Sunni Man]

just another of your friendly [juden] conversations.........
what was that? "the holocaust" is a myth"...................
idiot.

No need for the personal attacks. ...

If you feel the overwhelming need to accept the Holohoax fantasy as an actually historical event, that is fine by me.

But please don't insist that I share in your personal delusion. ...

 

[member]

just another of your friendly [juden] conversations.........
what was that? "the holocaust" is a myth"...................
idiot.

No need for the personally attacks. ...

If you feel the overwhelming need to accept the Holohoax fantasy as an actually historical event, that is fine by me.

But please don't insist that I share in your personal delusion. ...

I'm not even jewish.....and even i know when the wool is being pulled over my eyes.............

you're pathetic.....


this:

"juden and the holocuast is a myth.........."

you think i don't know who i'm talking to ?

i know who....


and that:

​

 

[USAF 2023]

just another of your friendly [juden] conversations.........
what was that? "the holocaust" is a myth"...................
idiot.

No need for the personal attacks. ...

If you feel the overwhelming need to accept the Holohoax fantasy as an actually historical event, that is fine by me.

But please don't insist that I share in your personal delusion. ...

Consider the source.

 

[Ria_Longhorn]

Sir John Moash, the founder of Zionist Federation of Australia was an anti-zionist?

You're patently insane!

It's Monash or Monasch and he was until after WW1......you try to make Tall,but you Zionists creep,you boasting Pharisee you'll never conquer me,though the road maybe rocky,and the Zionists Creep those Sinners,where you gonna run to,where you gonna HIDE

It is quite amusing,what Don'tlove thinks is Funny......shame really

You’re right. Don’t think it’s funny that you’re an On the other hand, I do!!

DOPE HEAD

tick-tock, tick-tock