Michigan Democrat Mallory McMorrow compares the Trump administration to Nazi Germany

I pay federal income taxes on my savings account interest whether I made a withdrawal or not that year.

It's true, you pay income tax on your interest income. And?
You're not pretending to not understand by any chance? Re-define non-withdrawn interest as another type of capital gain and vee-oh-la! I no longer pay taxes on interest until I withdraw it. Just like the millionaires with their capital gains. That or re-define capital gains as earned income whether they spend it or not that year. Just like my savings account. Then watch the increased tax revenues start to solve our fiscal crises.
 
You're not pretending to not understand by any chance? Re-define non-withdrawn interest as another type of capital gain and vee-oh-la! I no longer pay taxes on interest until I withdraw it. Just like the millionaires with their capital gains. That or re-define capital gains as earned income whether they spend it or not that year. Just like my savings account. Then watch the increased tax revenues start to solve our fiscal crises.

Re-define non-withdrawn interest as another type of capital gain and vee-oh-la!

Interest when earned is taxable income. Even if you leave it in the bank.

Capital gains aren't income until they are realized.
 
Re-define non-withdrawn interest as another type of capital gain and vee-oh-la!

Interest when earned is taxable income. Even if you leave it in the bank.

Capital gains aren't income until they are realized.
Yes, because that is the law. Can the law not be changed? I think you are deliberately being dense to avoid debate, but this is a debate forum, Todd.
 
Yes, because that is the law. Can the law not be changed? I think you are deliberately being dense to avoid debate, but this is a debate forum, Todd.

Yes, because that is the law. Can the law not be changed?

Which law needs to be changed? Post it.

Pointing out your error isn't avoiding debate.
 
Re-define non-withdrawn interest as another type of capital gain and vee-oh-la!

Interest when earned is taxable income. Even if you leave it in the bank.

Capital gains aren't income until they are realized.
That’s only because it was legislated that way. Both are unrealized income and that could easily change
 
Yes, because that is the law. Can the law not be changed?

Which law needs to be changed? Post it.

Pointing out your error isn't avoiding debate.
Okay you're being deliberately obtuse. I don't need to "post it" you already agreed that the law says interest on my savings account gets taxed whether I withdraw it this year or not and capital gains don't get taxed until they are withdrawn. That's what should change. Real answer or :hhello:
 
Okay you're being deliberately obtuse. I don't need to "post it" you already agreed that the law says interest on my savings account gets taxed whether I withdraw it this year or not and capital gains don't get taxed until they are withdrawn. That's what should change. Real answer or :hhello:

Yes, your interest income is taxable when it is deposited into your account.

capital gains don't get taxed until they are withdrawn.

Capital gains are neither deposited nor withdrawn.
 
Yes, your interest income is taxable when it is deposited into your account.

capital gains don't get taxed until they are withdrawn.

Capital gains are neither deposited nor withdrawn.
Something has to happen (a sale) in order to hold those gains in your hand

In order to hold interest income in your hand you have to withdraw it

In both cases until you DO something… you don’t have that money
 
15th post
Something has to happen (a sale) in order to hold those gains in your hand

In order to hold interest income in your hand you have to withdraw it

In both cases until you DO something… you don’t have that money

Something has to happen (a sale) in order to hold those gains in your hand

I can sell stock without "holding the gain in my hand".

In order to hold interest income in your hand you have to withdraw it

It's not the holding it's the realizing.

In both cases until you DO something…

I haven't done anything to the stock I bought 20 years ago to be taxed on it yet.
 
Something has to happen (a sale) in order to hold those gains in your hand

I can sell stock without "holding the gain in my hand".

In order to hold interest income in your hand you have to withdraw it

It's not the holding it's the realizing.

In both cases until you DO something…

I haven't done anything to the stock I bought 20 years ago to be taxed on it yet.
When you sell stock you “do something “ that provides you money. Money you can hold in your hand, spend, put in the bank… whatever
 
When you sell stock you “do something “ that provides you money. Money you can hold in your hand, spend, put in the bank… whatever

Right. When I sell the stock, that's a taxable event because a realized gain is income. Whether I withdraw the money or let it sit.

If I don't sell it, there is no taxable event.
 

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom