Jury deadlocked on Daniel Penny manslaughter trial

[Dante]

Mr. Neely was threatening to kill other people.

Penny stepped in and stopped him.

Nope.

Anybody living in a big city has been around nuts like Neely.

Poor Penny was fed up and decided to work out his own issues.

Murdered another man. Manslaughter is still murder

 

[martybegan]

Yes he killed.

That issue is being debated. He subdued a man threatening other passengers on a closed subway car.

On the F train the doors between cars aren't operable.

 

[martybegan]

Nope.

Anybody living in a big city has been around nuts like Neely.

Poor Penny was fed up and decided to work out his own issues.

Murdered another man. Manslaughter is still murder

I've been around nuts talking to themselves, this one went face to face with people threatening to kill them.

So we require absolute perfection from any good Samaritan trying to protect others?

 

[lafayette]

He killed a man is not debatable.

 

[lafayette]

I've been around nuts talking to themselves, this one went face to face with people threatening to kill them.

So we require absolute perfection from any good Samaritan trying to protect others?

Not killing Neely is not absolute prefection. It is a common sense.

 

[Dante]

I've been around nuts talking to themselves, this one went face to face with people threatening to kill them.

Nope.

 

[martybegan]

Not killing Neely is not absolute prefection. It is a common sense.

Neely started it. He was threatening other passengers.

So just sit there and wait for the nutjob to cross the line and actually hurt people?

 

[martybegan]

Nope.

Yep.

Figures Dainty sympathizes with the mentally ill asshole and not the people he threatened.

White liberal twat syndrome,

 

[lafayette]

Penny had control of Neely with the help of two other people.

 

[Dante]

Yep.

Figures Dainty sympathizes with the mentally ill asshole and not the people he threatened.

White liberal twat syndrome,

Live in a big city. Take public transit all the time.

Benn on a bus with a guy who violently punches into the air. Makes threatening noises. Looks directly at you.

Got used to him. he's harmless. Often have to explain to others like you on that bus that he is harmless. That's how I STEP In

 

[Dante]

Penny had control of Neely with the help of two other people.

 

[martybegan]

Live in a big city. Take public transit all the time.

Benn on a bus with a guy who violently punches into the air. Makes threatening noises. Looks directly at you.

Got used to him. he's harmless. Often have to explain to others like you on that bus that he is harmless. That's how I STEP In

Until he isn't harmless, and he gets the first shot in.

So the rule is now don't help anyone, just sit there and take it. maybe pee your pants to discourage them.

 

[Dante]

Yep.

Figures Dainty sympathizes with the mentally ill asshole and not the people he threatened.

White liberal twat syndrome,

you made up a scenario that is lacking any factual basis

 

[martybegan]

View attachment 1050797

He didn't know anyone's names, so he couldn't threaten anyone directly.

That's a dodge and you know it.

 

[Dante]

Until he isn't harmless, and he gets the first shot in.

So the rule is now don't help anyone, just sit there and take it. maybe pee your pants to discourage them.

please

People like you are more of a danger to society than most of those mental retards

 

[martybegan]

you made up a scenario that is lacking any factual basis

"factual"

People testified being scared of Neely.

 

[martybegan]

please

People like you are more of a danger to society than most of those mental retards

Until one throws you on the tracks, or stabs you, or throws their shit on you.

 

[Dante]

He didn't know anyone's names, so he couldn't threaten anyone directly.

That's a dodge and you know it.

People on that train have seen it before. Penny was like you -- frustrated and angry. He lashed out.

He took a man's life because of what?

You agree the man deserved the death penalty

 

[Dante]

"factual"

People testified being scared of Neely.

Scared. Wow! That justifies killing a man.

enough

You're pathetic on this one

Optics. Biases. Bullshit fears of your own.

 

[martybegan]

People on that train have seen it before. Penny was like you -- frustrated and angry. He lashed out.

He took a man's life because of what?

You agree the man deserved the death penalty

I've seen them in a limited area, and doing it without actually approaching people and going the length of the car.

I agree the man killed himself by being a fucking asshole.

He was trying to restrain him, not kill him.