Jimmy Carter: A Rebuttal

Which of Carter's endeavors is more important than his creating the Ayatollah's barbaric Iran? How many lives does that equate to?

It is easy for rabid partisans to paint Carter's actions toward Iran in a misleadingly negative light. The truth is far more complicated. We can start by noting that Carter was getting erroneous CIA reports that were assuring him there was no immediate danger of a radical revolution in Iran. Dr. Kai Bird discusses this in his outstanding, balanced biography The Outlier: The Unfinished Presidency of Jimmy Carter.

Also, Carter was by no means the only official who believed Khomeini's assurances that he would govern as a moderate, would continue to sell oil to the U.S., etc. CIA and State Department officials likewise viewed Khomeini as a moderate alternative to the Shah's unpopular government.

Yes, Khomeini double-crossed Carter and quickly imposed radical Muslim rule. Carter responded with severe sanctions, including freezing Iranian assets held in the U.S. and banning oil trade with Iran, which devastated Iran's economy. Perhaps this is why Iran's mullah-run government responded to the news of Carter's death with harsh condemnations of Carter, one of which said Carter "will rot in hell."
 
You haven't read Carter's book, Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid, have you? He loudly condemned Palestinian terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians as "morally reprehensible" and "dastardly" (p. 18). He attacked "the refusal of some Arabs to accept Israel as a neighbor," "the rise in Islamic fundamentalism," and "the absence of a clear and authoritative Palestinian voice acceptable to Israel" (p. 13). He argued that "the Arabs must acknowledge openly and specifically that Israel is a reality and has a right to exist in peace" (p. 207). And on and on I could go.

As a proud Zionist and staunch supporter of Israel, I take issue with some of Carter's statements in the book, but no sane person who reads the book could conclude that Carter was a "passionate Jew hater." That is just absurd. Carter expressed great love for Jews and for the state of Israel, flatly condemned Arab terrorism, and insisted that Arabs had to recognize Israel's right to exist and cease attacking her.

And anyone who knows anything about modern Middle East history knows that radical Muslims were outraged by Egypt's peace treaty with Israel, which is why they assassinated Egypt's leader, Anwar Sadat, who signed the peace deal.
What make you think the book is true?

Reality is defined by actions, not words.
 
Conservatives rightly cheer Reagan for standing up to the air traffic controllers' union in the 1981 air traffic controllers strike, but they usually overlook the fact that Carter stood up to the much larger and more powerful mine workers' union (UMWA) in the 1977-78 coal miners strike.

After the UMWA rejected two contract offers brokered by Carter, he invoked Taft-Hartley and ordered the miners back to work. He even cut off food stamps to miners who defied the order! Following Carter's return-to-work order, the UMWA soon accepted a new contract.

Read what the ultra-leftists at the World Socialist Web Site have to say about Carter's dealings with the UMWA during the strike. They published this article two weeks ago, soon after Carter's death was announced:


EXCERPT:

Domestically, Carter embraced free-market economics, deregulating industries and resisting social program expansion. His administration’s . . . subsequent anti-working-class measures, including the appointment of Paul Volcker to the Federal Reserve and drawing up the plans to smash the air traffic controllers union, laid the groundwork for the attacks on labor under his successor, Republican Ronald Reagan.
 
2024 hasn’t been kind to Israel’s enemies, and how symbolic that in its final stretch, Jimmy Carter – the 1970s U.S. President – joined Nasrallah, Sinwar, Deif, Haniyeh, and Raisi. Carter, whose achievements include laying the foundation for today’s Iranian regime, fighting a rabbit, and spotting a UFO, was by all accounts a failed president. When he had the audacity to run for another four years of blunders and embarrassments, he suffered an unprecedented humiliating defeat, receiving just 49 electoral votes out of 538.

Sometimes a small cartoon says more than a thousand words: In one episode of “The Simpsons,” Springfield’s women raise money for a Lincoln statue, but when they fall short, they settle for a pathetic alternative – a Carter statue, triggering riots as angry residents trample it while police struggle to restore order. Carter’s legacy in grassroots satire.

And Carter never forgave. He dedicated his 44 post-presidency years to hating Israel, supporting Hamas, and writing books about Israel’s alleged “apartheid” in the territories. While one might somewhat understand Trudeau, Macron or Albanese, given their significant Muslim electorates, it’s harder to comprehend such anti-Semitic conspiracy theories coming from a former leader of our greatest ally – the only country in the world (besides Israel) with more Jews than Muslims. When Carter accuses Jews of oppressing people or apartheid, it carries far more weight and legitimacy than similar accusations from Erdogan, and Carter made sure to exploit that power, never lagging behind Erdogan in anti-Israel theories.

Though Carter denied being anti-Semitic or anti-Israeli, it was hard to miss his passion when speaking against Israel and his determination to seize every opportunity to do so. In an interview with Jon Stewart, Carter was asked about the causes of Muslim terrorism in Europe. Carter pounced on the question like finding treasure, responding with a hate-filled expression: “The Palestinian problem.” In other words, according to this Nobel Peace Prize laureate, Jews were to blame for Muslim terrorism in Christian Europe. “Carter continued to demonstrate his prejudices against Jews and Israel,” declared Abraham Foxman, head of the Anti-Defamation League, in response.

Naturally, Carter gravitated towards those interested in his doctrines, associating with extreme Islamic groups in the United States and even appearing as a keynote speaker at an event of the terrorist organization “Islamic Council of South America.” Carter, a known Hamas supporter who defined the terror gang as a legitimate organization, will surely find plenty to discuss with his friends mentioned at the beginning of this article, who are waiting to welcome him.

“President Carter will be remembered fondly in Israel, and his legacy will be defined by his deep commitment to peace,” President Herzog wrote this week about Carter. Amusing, considering his predecessor, President Rivlin, refused to meet Carter due to his obsessive persecution of Israel. But even the presidential political correctness and diplomatic niceties cannot change the truth:
I bid farewell, without much sorrow, to another Israel-hater under the convenient cover of “peace seeker.” Goodbye and good riddance.
 
2024 hasn’t been kind to Israel’s enemies, and how symbolic that in its final stretch, Jimmy Carter – the 1970s U.S. President – joined Nasrallah, Sinwar, Deif, Haniyeh, and Raisi. Carter, whose achievements include laying the foundation for today’s Iranian regime, fighting a rabbit, and spotting a UFO, was by all accounts a failed president. When he had the audacity to run for another four years of blunders and embarrassments, he suffered an unprecedented humiliating defeat, receiving just 49 electoral votes out of 538.

Sometimes a small cartoon says more than a thousand words: In one episode of “The Simpsons,” Springfield’s women raise money for a Lincoln statue, but when they fall short, they settle for a pathetic alternative – a Carter statue, triggering riots as angry residents trample it while police struggle to restore order. Carter’s legacy in grassroots satire.

And Carter never forgave. He dedicated his 44 post-presidency years to hating Israel, supporting Hamas, and writing books about Israel’s alleged “apartheid” in the territories. While one might somewhat understand Trudeau, Macron or Albanese, given their significant Muslim electorates, it’s harder to comprehend such anti-Semitic conspiracy theories coming from a former leader of our greatest ally – the only country in the world (besides Israel) with more Jews than Muslims. When Carter accuses Jews of oppressing people or apartheid, it carries far more weight and legitimacy than similar accusations from Erdogan, and Carter made sure to exploit that power, never lagging behind Erdogan in anti-Israel theories.

Though Carter denied being anti-Semitic or anti-Israeli, it was hard to miss his passion when speaking against Israel and his determination to seize every opportunity to do so. In an interview with Jon Stewart, Carter was asked about the causes of Muslim terrorism in Europe. Carter pounced on the question like finding treasure, responding with a hate-filled expression: “The Palestinian problem.” In other words, according to this Nobel Peace Prize laureate, Jews were to blame for Muslim terrorism in Christian Europe. “Carter continued to demonstrate his prejudices against Jews and Israel,” declared Abraham Foxman, head of the Anti-Defamation League, in response.

Naturally, Carter gravitated towards those interested in his doctrines, associating with extreme Islamic groups in the United States and even appearing as a keynote speaker at an event of the terrorist organization “Islamic Council of South America.” Carter, a known Hamas supporter who defined the terror gang as a legitimate organization, will surely find plenty to discuss with his friends mentioned at the beginning of this article, who are waiting to welcome him.

“President Carter will be remembered fondly in Israel, and his legacy will be defined by his deep commitment to peace,” President Herzog wrote this week about Carter. Amusing, considering his predecessor, President Rivlin, refused to meet Carter due to his obsessive persecution of Israel. But even the presidential political correctness and diplomatic niceties cannot change the truth:
I bid farewell, without much sorrow, to another Israel-hater under the convenient cover of “peace seeker.” Goodbye and good riddance.
This is mix of distortion, half-truths, and falsehoods. I've already answered most of this stuff in this thread and in my Carter thread. I recommend that readers who want the full story on Carter check out my website on his presidency, where you'll find undeniable evidence that Carter was center-right on many issues, that he pushed through massive deregulation, that he approved a huge amount of oil and natural gas development, and that he significantly boosted military spending, that he reduced taxes on working families:

President Carter's Real Record: The Misunderstood Presidency of Jimmy Carter

As for Carter and Israel, it is easy to cherry-pick certain facts and to omit context and clarifying facts. Carter met with Hamas to try to persuade them to recognize Israel's right to exist. If you read Carter's much-maligned book Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid, you'll see that Carter unequivocally condemned Arab terrorism and called out radical Arabs for refusing to recognize Israel's right to exist.
 
This is mix of distortion, half-truths, and falsehoods. I've already answered most of this stuff in this thread and in my Carter thread. I recommend that readers who want the full story on Carter check out my website on his presidency, where you'll find undeniable evidence that Carter was center-right on many issues, that he pushed through massive deregulation, that he approved a huge amount of oil and natural gas development, and that he significantly boosted military spending, that he reduced taxes on working families:

President Carter's Real Record: The Misunderstood Presidency of Jimmy Carter

As for Carter and Israel, it is easy to cherry-pick certain facts and to omit context and clarifying facts. Carter met with Hamas to try to persuade them to recognize Israel's right to exist. If you read Carter's much-maligned book Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid, you'll see that Carter unequivocally condemned Arab terrorism and called out radical Arabs for refusing to recognize Israel's right to exist.
Interesting....your love affair with a failed President and an anti-Semite.
 
The only thing that saves Carter from the trash heap of history is the mainstream media's loyalty to the democrat party and it's willingness to lie and obscure the truth.
 
The final fifteen months of Carter's presidential tenure were marked by several major crises, including the 1979 oil crisis, the Iran hostage crisis, and the subsequent failed Operation Eagle Claw.

Not even to mention his huge mistake of giving Panama the control of the Canal who then allowed China to come in and administer it.

 
The final fifteen months of Carter's presidential tenure were marked by several major crises, including the 1979 oil crisis, the Iran hostage crisis, and the subsequent failed Operation Eagle Claw.

Not even to mention his huge mistake of giving Panama the control of the Canal who then allowed China to come in and administer it.



I can't decide which I deplore more......Carter's lies, his anti-Semitism, or his incompetence.
 
Interesting....your love affair with a failed President and an anti-Semite.
This is just blind partisan hatred. Again, Carter was pro-Israeli and had a great love for the Jewish people.

A "failed President"? He pushed through massive deregulation, which did a great deal to make the Reagan economic boom possible. He boosted military spending every year of his presidency. He cut taxes on working families. He held the federal workforce to virtually zero growth. He vastly expanded oil and natural gas development. He rejected the bloated healthcare proposal of his party's left wing, which was a major reason that Ted Kennedy decided to oppose him in the 1980 Dem primary. He signed the Hyde Amendment, banning federal funding of abortion. Annual job growth under Carter actually exceeded annual job growth under Reagan (yes, it did). Etc., etc., etc.

Just because a President is not reelected does not mean he was a failure.

President Carter's Real Record: The Misunderstood Presidency of Jimmy Carter

BTW, someone said that Carter seemed to have an abundance of free time. Actually, Carter was one of the hardest working Presidents in American history. He was at his office by 6:00 AM most of the time, and often did not finish his work day until 5:00 or 6:00 PM. He took fewer vacations than any president in the last 60 years.
 
It's worth mentioning that when Ted Kennedy ran against Carter in the 1980 Democratic primary, he accused Carter of pushing a Republican agenda and of being hostile to liberalism. Kennedy's supporters accused Carter of being "a secret Republican." Kennedy and his backers attacked Carter for increasing defense spending, signing the Hyde Amendment banning federal funding of abortion, blocking numerous pork-barrel spending projects, etc.

It's also worth mentioning that in 1972, Carter strongly opposed George McGovern as the Democrat nominee and privately warned that nominating McGovern would lead to disaster in the general election.
 

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom