Is Peyton Manning the greatest NFL player ever?

[LA RAM FAN]

He's the all time leader in total offense and has 5 regular season MVPs while no one else has more than 3. The big knock on him is he only has one super bowl ring while other contenders like brady and montana have 4.

shady brady is a cheating lying fraud so dont even put him in the same breath as Montana.try Montana and Bradshaw.

now to answer your question. clearly no.He is a clone of Dan Marino.someone who was great in the regular season but goes into panic mode in the big game. Greatest ever would be Johnny Unitas.

 

[LA RAM FAN]

No


Dick Butkus or mean Joe green was

Better than that Clown Manning thats a no brainer.lol

 

[Desperado]

Peyton Manning isn't even the greatest quarterback let alone the greatest player in the NFL

5 reg season MVPs is mighty impressive. You just hate him because he's white.

Are kidding me? Yes it is impressive but that still does not make him the best NFL player of all time.

 

[LA RAM FAN]

No

Dick Butkus or mean Joe green was

Sorry troll, but this is a serious thread.

A serious thread and you pick Peyton? No wonder you drive like a grandma

you OWNED him there.He claims this is a serious thread he picks manning as best player ever and he calls YOU the troll? comedy gold.

 

[LA RAM FAN]

I not sure the best. but he's up there with some of the best. Bradshaw, Montana, Elway and quite a few more

Yeah Bradshaw,Montana,Elway,and Unitas were all easily better.

 

[HUGGY]

He's the all time leader in total offense and has 5 regular season MVPs while no one else has more than 3. The big knock on him is he only has one super bowl ring while other contenders like brady and montana have 4.

Thanks! I needed a good laugh!

 

[Jarlaxle]

Manning is, at best, third best QB, behind Tom Brady and Joe Montana.

 

[Jarlaxle]

No

Dick Butkus or mean Joe green was

Sorry troll, but this is a serious thread.

A serious thread and you pick Peyton? No wonder you drive like a grandma

you OWNED him there.He claims this is a serious thread he picks manning as best player ever and he calls YOU the troll? comedy gold.

The OP here is as much of a troll as you are.

 

[ShootSpeeders]

Jim Brown

I've already proved that incorrect. Brownie only played 9 years. Pay attention.

 

[rightwinger]

Jim Brown

I've already proved that incorrect. Brownie only played 9 years. Pay attention.

Which means shit
Nine years is a full career......nobody did it better than Jim Brown

 

[westwall]

Jim Brown

I've already proved that incorrect. Brownie only played 9 years. Pay attention.

And he did more in that 9 years than your hero has in 18 on a percentage basis, so no, you haven't proven anything other than you're a dipshit. But we already knew that...

 

[Toro]

I like Manning, but Brady was better.

 

[ShootSpeeders]

Football-reference.com has a stat called approximate value which rates a player on everything for his whole career and they put manning at the top followed by favre and rice.

NFL Career Approximate Value Leaders | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Jim Brown is at number 165. Again, he had a short career.

 

[Wyatt earp]

Jim Brown

I've already proved that incorrect. Brownie only played 9 years. Pay attention.

One of the roughest years ever toots. Hell that though S.O.B. was almost thinking about coming out of retirement when Walter was closing in on his record

 

[Lakhota]

Breaking bombshell report claims Peyton Manning is a doper.

 

[ShootSpeeders]

[
I've already proved that incorrect. Brownie only played 9 years. Pay attention.

One of the roughest years ever toots. Hell that though S.O.B. was almost thinking about coming out of retirement when Walter was closing in on his record

He said that but it was all BS. He never planned to go back into the NFL when he was 50!!!

BTW - wasn't it franco harris, not walter payton, who prompted brownie to say he might rejoin the NFL?? Franco was closing in on brown's record and jim always hated franco. Claimed he was a ***** who got yards because of a great offensive line. Brown admired payton because he fought for his yards and didn't mind if walter broke his record.

 

[ShootSpeeders]

Breaking bombshell report claims Peyton Manning is a doper.

BS - peyton is 100% american. He never done nothin' what wasn't all man and all republican and all white.

 

[Unkotare]

The OP is too funny. This conversation ended when Brady won his 4th. There is no serious question now.

 

[Papageorgio]

The OP is too funny. This conversation ended when Brady won his 4th. There is no serious question now.

I think Montana is better than Brady.

 

[Papageorgio]

Breaking bombshell report claims Peyton Manning is a doper.

He took them when he was recovering from surgery and never tested positive. Not much teeth.