Is it ever acceptable to bomb a school or a hospital? (Poll)

[daveman]

I agree. The answer is no. Targets must be of military necessity. Hospitals and schools do not apply.

When the enemy uses protected structures for military purposes, they become targets of military necessity.

 

[daveman]

That is not correct. If the civilian casualties outweigh the military ones, then it cannot be targeted. And there is no way to limit civilian casualties in a hospital or school.

Especially when Hamas won't let the civilians leave.

All this has been pointed out pages ago. Stop posting and start reading.

 

[daveman]

Wrong! Hamas is not doing the shooting, Israel is. And as a member state to the United Nations, Israel is obligated to live by their rules.

So no, the military necessity does not outweigh the civilian casualties. Therefore, it cannot be targeted.

Is it okay to target Israeli hospitals because members of the IDF are patients their?

Does Hamas live up to the UN's rules? Why do you give them a free pass to murder civilians?

 

[ozro]

Wrong! Hamas is not doing the shooting, Israel is. And as a member state to the United Nations, Israel is obligated to live by their rules.

So no, the military necessity does not outweigh the civilian casualties. Therefore, it cannot be targeted.

Is it okay to target Israeli hospitals because members of the IDF are patients their?

Who the **** told you "HAMAS is not doing the shooting"?
That is either pure t ignorance or you do not watch any news

 

[daveman]

the POSTER FOR ISLAM is a picture of YAHYA SINWAR ---mass murderer who knows he is in the cross hairs of the IDF----so he carries his four year old baby ----the kid holding a machine gun.

Yahya Sinwar reportedly hiding in plain sight 'dressed as a woman'​

Good. Pussies SHOULD dress as women.

 

[daveman]

Bullshit. You guys are always taking liberties with our posts, claiming we said things we didn't.

Lying is the tRumpling way.

Maybe you should either write more clearly -- or stop running away from the things you write.

 

[daveman]

A. no it's not.

B. that's a republican thing.

No, the Republican thing is saying, "Ma'am, you should buy a gun and train with it, so when some asshole tries to rape you, you can shoot him until he's no longer a threat."

But you Democrats don't like that. Why do you want people to be victimized?

 

[Carl in Michigan]

Then you have to be angry at Hamas for stealing billions in aid from Gazans.

But...I don't think you are.

by their lack of posts you shall know them

 

[buttercup]

Then you have to be angry at Hamas for stealing billions in aid from Gazans.

But...I don't think you are.

Well you don't know me then, because I am against Hamas or ANYONE who would intentionally kill, steal from or trample all over civilians. I mean, even the thought that I would support something like that is insane, but at least you didn't entirely make an accusation, I can give you credit for that, unlike some other evil folk around here.

 

[daveman]

by their lack of posts you shall know them

Neither gipper nor georgephillip, notably, have condemned Hamas.

So they're okay with murdering Jews.

 

[daveman]

Well you don't know me then, because I am against Hamas or ANYONE who would intentionally kill, steal from or trample all over civilians. I mean, even the thought that I would support something like that is insane, but at least you didn't entirely make an accusation, I can give you credit for that, unlike some other evil folk around here.

Thank you. I appreciate the non-hypocrisy.

 

[Carl in Michigan]

Neither gipper nor georgephillip, notably, have condemned Hamas.

So they're okay with murdering Jews.

They all never expressed shock or outrage by the massacre on October 7th. It didn't bother them at all. They used it to push silly conspiracy theories that Israel did this to their own people.

 

[Carl in Michigan]

Well you don't know me then, because I am against Hamas or ANYONE who would intentionally kill, steal from or trample all over civilians. I mean, even the thought that I would support something like that is insane, but at least you didn't entirely make an accusation, I can give you credit for that, unlike some other evil folk around here.

Where did you ever condemn Hamas at any time near October 7th? You never did. You used that tragedy to push your conspiracy theories. To be honest, your lack of basic compassion shocked me

These hostages STILL languish in SLAVERY and daily abuse. Yet STILL, there is never any expression of compassion or outrage that the Palestinians won't give these people back to the families waiting for them

 

[Slyhunter]

buttercup They DIDN'T work with Hitler to exterminate the Jews? You really want to claim that buttercup

Actually they did.

 

[Carl in Michigan]

Actually they did.

Of course they did.
Jews trying to flee into the Holy Land were shot at.

 

[daveman]

They all never expressed shock or outrage by the massacre on October 7th. It didn't bother them at all. They used it to push silly conspiracy theories that Israel did this to their own people.

Quite simply, they are Nazis.

 

[Stann]

Not one of these people sniveling about Israel defending itself have posted anything condemning Hamas for herding school children over their armories and ammo dumps. Their fake crying over 'The Children' is pure scum baggery and a fraud.

I have said it over and over Hamas is the problem for both the Jews and the people of Gaza.. They are the ones putting everyone else in harm's way. Despicable lot , one and all.

 

[Crepitus]

Maybe you should either write more clearly -- or stop running away from the things you write.

Maybe you tRumplings shouldn't be lying shitsacks.

 

[Crepitus]

No, the Republican thing is saying, "Ma'am, you should buy a gun and train with it, so when some asshole tries to rape you, you can shoot him until he's no longer a threat."

But you Democrats don't like that. Why do you want people to be victimized?

Again, bullshit.

republicans say "SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED" while spraying spittle everywhere.

 

[Picaro]

Who the **** told you "HAMAS is not doing the shooting"?
That is either pure t ignorance or you do not watch any news

They love Hamas, it's trendy and fashionable among left wing dopers and deviants. They aren't ignorant, they're just scum, is all.