How California eco-bureaucrats halted a Pacific Palisades fire safety project to save an endangered shrub

excalibur

Diamond Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2015
Messages
24,076
Reaction score
47,858
Points
2,290
Just so, so California.

And they want billions from us after hey create or exacerbate so much of the disasters they suffer.




California’s eco-bureaucrats halted a wildfire prevention project near the Pacific Palisades to protect an endangered shrub.

It’s just the latest clash between fire safety and conservation in California that is coming under scrutiny following the devastating outbreak of the Palisades Fire — the most devastating blaze in Los Angeles history, which has consumed the very same area.

In 2019, the LA Department of Water and Power (LADWP) began replacing nearly 100-year-old power line poles cutting through Topanga State Park, when the project was halted within days by conservationists outraged that federally endangered Braunton’s milkvetch plants had been trampled during the process.


Thousands of homes and business have been destroyed since the wildfires broke out in Los Angeles a week ago


The goal of the project was to improve fire safety for the Pacific Palisades area by replacing the wooden poles with steel, widening fire-access lanes in the area, and installing wind- and fire-resistant power lines — all after the area was identified as having an “elevated fire risk,” according to the LA Times.

“This project will help ensure power reliability and safety, while helping reduce wildfire threats,” the LADWP said at the time. “These wooden poles were installed between 1933 and 1955 and are now past their useful service life.”

But, after an amateur botanist hiking through the park during the work saw the harm done to some of the park’s Braunton’s milkvetch — a flowering shrub with only a few thousand specimens remaining in the wild — and complained, the project was completely halted, Courthouse News Service reported.

Instead of fire-hardening the park, the city — which the state said had undertaken the work without proper permitting — ended up paying $2 million in fines and was ordered by the California Coastal Commission to reverse the whole project and replant the rare herb.

That work saved about 200 Braunton’s milkvetch plants — almost all of which have now likely been torched in the wildfires that consumed Topanga Canyon, along with nearly 24,000 acres (37 square miles) of some of LA’s most sought-after real estate.

...











 
Just so, so California.

And they want billions from us after hey create or exacerbate so much of the disasters they suffer.


California’s eco-bureaucrats halted a wildfire prevention project near the Pacific Palisades to protect an endangered shrub.
It’s just the latest clash between fire safety and conservation in California that is coming under scrutiny following the devastating outbreak of the Palisades Fire — the most devastating blaze in Los Angeles history, which has consumed the very same area.
In 2019, the LA Department of Water and Power (LADWP) began replacing nearly 100-year-old power line poles cutting through Topanga State Park, when the project was halted within days by conservationists outraged that federally endangered Braunton’s milkvetch plants had been trampled during the process.
Thousands of homes and business have been destroyed since the wildfires broke out in Los Angeles a week ago
The goal of the project was to improve fire safety for the Pacific Palisades area by replacing the wooden poles with steel, widening fire-access lanes in the area, and installing wind- and fire-resistant power lines — all after the area was identified as having an “elevated fire risk,” according to the LA Times.
“This project will help ensure power reliability and safety, while helping reduce wildfire threats,” the LADWP said at the time. “These wooden poles were installed between 1933 and 1955 and are now past their useful service life.”
But, after an amateur botanist hiking through the park during the work saw the harm done to some of the park’s Braunton’s milkvetch — a flowering shrub with only a few thousand specimens remaining in the wild — and complained, the project was completely halted, Courthouse News Service reported.
Instead of fire-hardening the park, the city — which the state said had undertaken the work without proper permitting — ended up paying $2 million in fines and was ordered by the California Coastal Commission to reverse the whole project and replant the rare herb.
That work saved about 200 Braunton’s milkvetch plants — almost all of which have now likely been torched in the wildfires that consumed Topanga Canyon, along with nearly 24,000 acres (37 square miles) of some of LA’s most sought-after real estate.
...












Californians will vote for these same policies again, and the politicians who create them, the very next chance they get.

They can't learn.
 
One of the big arguments against desalination 25 years ago in CA was


it might kills some clams (a desalination plant produces two streams, water purified, and a very salty brine squirted back into the ocean, which might in fact kill a clam or two...)
 
Just so, so California.

And they want billions from us after hey create or exacerbate so much of the disasters they suffer.


California’s eco-bureaucrats halted a wildfire prevention project near the Pacific Palisades to protect an endangered shrub.
It’s just the latest clash between fire safety and conservation in California that is coming under scrutiny following the devastating outbreak of the Palisades Fire — the most devastating blaze in Los Angeles history, which has consumed the very same area.
In 2019, the LA Department of Water and Power (LADWP) began replacing nearly 100-year-old power line poles cutting through Topanga State Park, when the project was halted within days by conservationists outraged that federally endangered Braunton’s milkvetch plants had been trampled during the process.
Thousands of homes and business have been destroyed since the wildfires broke out in Los Angeles a week ago
The goal of the project was to improve fire safety for the Pacific Palisades area by replacing the wooden poles with steel, widening fire-access lanes in the area, and installing wind- and fire-resistant power lines — all after the area was identified as having an “elevated fire risk,” according to the LA Times.
“This project will help ensure power reliability and safety, while helping reduce wildfire threats,” the LADWP said at the time. “These wooden poles were installed between 1933 and 1955 and are now past their useful service life.”
But, after an amateur botanist hiking through the park during the work saw the harm done to some of the park’s Braunton’s milkvetch — a flowering shrub with only a few thousand specimens remaining in the wild — and complained, the project was completely halted, Courthouse News Service reported.
Instead of fire-hardening the park, the city — which the state said had undertaken the work without proper permitting — ended up paying $2 million in fines and was ordered by the California Coastal Commission to reverse the whole project and replant the rare herb.
That work saved about 200 Braunton’s milkvetch plants — almost all of which have now likely been torched in the wildfires that consumed Topanga Canyon, along with nearly 24,000 acres (37 square miles) of some of LA’s most sought-after real estate.
...











I wonder how the shrubs are doing now?
 
One of the big arguments against desalination 25 years ago in CA was


it might kills some clams (a desalination plant produces two streams, water purified, and a very salty brine squirted back into the ocean, which might in fact kill a clam or two...)

Great! I hope the clams are very happy.
 

How California eco-bureaucrats halted a Pacific Palisades fire safety project to save an endangered shrub​


That’s one very important and enormously expensive shrub.
 
Given the resources wasted on a low-rent bait fish I'm not surprised in the least.
Yeah and I heard the Delta Smelt is not even an indigenous species.
 
Just so, so California.

And they want billions from us after hey create or exacerbate so much of the disasters they suffer.


California’s eco-bureaucrats halted a wildfire prevention project near the Pacific Palisades to protect an endangered shrub.
It’s just the latest clash between fire safety and conservation in California that is coming under scrutiny following the devastating outbreak of the Palisades Fire — the most devastating blaze in Los Angeles history, which has consumed the very same area.
In 2019, the LA Department of Water and Power (LADWP) began replacing nearly 100-year-old power line poles cutting through Topanga State Park, when the project was halted within days by conservationists outraged that federally endangered Braunton’s milkvetch plants had been trampled during the process.
Thousands of homes and business have been destroyed since the wildfires broke out in Los Angeles a week ago
The goal of the project was to improve fire safety for the Pacific Palisades area by replacing the wooden poles with steel, widening fire-access lanes in the area, and installing wind- and fire-resistant power lines — all after the area was identified as having an “elevated fire risk,” according to the LA Times.
“This project will help ensure power reliability and safety, while helping reduce wildfire threats,” the LADWP said at the time. “These wooden poles were installed between 1933 and 1955 and are now past their useful service life.”
But, after an amateur botanist hiking through the park during the work saw the harm done to some of the park’s Braunton’s milkvetch — a flowering shrub with only a few thousand specimens remaining in the wild — and complained, the project was completely halted, Courthouse News Service reported.
Instead of fire-hardening the park, the city — which the state said had undertaken the work without proper permitting — ended up paying $2 million in fines and was ordered by the California Coastal Commission to reverse the whole project and replant the rare herb.
That work saved about 200 Braunton’s milkvetch plants — almost all of which have now likely been torched in the wildfires that consumed Topanga Canyon, along with nearly 24,000 acres (37 square miles) of some of LA’s most sought-after real estate.
...











Yeah these Democrats are looking pretty evil. I agree they should fireproof the energy infrastructure but first they need to clean up CA forests that have been left to accumulate fuel for decades. BLM land has the same problem but they are FED and that needs to be dealt with as well because BLM land lack sufficient fire fighting capabilities and that impacts private land adjacent to BLM land. CAL fire can only do so much.

The root of the problem are environmental groups and regulations started by the Sierra Club many decades ago when they kicked the loggers out (who were the only ones on federal land with adequate fire fighting equipment) to 'save' an owl. Subsequently, so-called 'environmental regulations' have metastasized like a bad cancer on our forests. Now their whole thrust is to 'let it burn. because it's 'natural.'
 
Last edited:
Way too many times human interests are put behind the interest of one out of thousands of bugs
 
I wonder how the shrubs are doing now?



That work saved about 200 Braunton’s milkvetch plants — almost all of which have now likely been torched in the wildfires that consumed Topanga Canyon, along with nearly 24,000 acres (37 square miles) of some of LA’s most sought-after real estate.
 

A program to protect a plant called Braunton’s milkvetch (scientific name Astragalus brauntonii) may have had an effect on fire safety in the exact same area where the Palisades fire started.​


This is from the New York Times:

Original: What Caused the Palisades Fire? The Site of the Ignition Point Holds Clues

Archive: https://archive.ph/Fv8d4

This Is Where the Palisades Fire Started

In the hills above Pacific Palisades, there is crime scene tape and scattered debris, clues to what may have caused the initial fire that eventually raged through thousands of structures.

By Thomas Fuller, Mike Baker, Blacki Migliozzi, K.K. Rebecca Lai, and Jonathan Wolfe

January 13, 2025

Along the trail near where the Palisades fire began, The Times found bits of power-line debris, including what appeared to be part of a lightning arrester device. But the nearest overhead power line was about a third of a mile to the north. That line, which curves down from the trail and into the neighborhood,was extensively damaged from fire, but witness photographs show it was still intact soon after the fire began.

The poles along that route have a tumultuous recent history. Many of them date from the 1930s, and the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power initiated a project in 2019 to replace some of them with stronger metal structures.

The project stalled after environmental regulators said the department had damaged 183 small bushes known as Braunton’s milkvetch, an endangered species.

The department agreed in 2020 to pay a fine, and won approval to resume work, saying the project was “essential in regards to our wildfire mitigation plan.” But the project does not appear to have proceeded.

The Times’s review of the ridgetop showed many damaged and fallen utility poles along the trail heading north — an area that was consumed by fire, but not until a day after the blaze began.


And here is the wikipedia article on that plant species:

Astragalus brauntonii - Wikipedia

As a person with an amateur interest in the subject of risk analysis, I find this to to be quite fascinating.

It’s typical for most government policies to have both benefits and risks.

When we consider adopting a new government policy, it’s wise to take into account both the benefits and the risks.

This specific issue is something that may end up being taught in various college courses in the future.
 
One of the big arguments against desalination 25 years ago in CA was


it might kills some clams (a desalination plant produces two streams, water purified, and a very salty brine squirted back into the ocean, which might in fact kill a clam or two...)


Every single house or apartment building that every single environmentalist lives in caused the killing of animals during its construction.
 

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom