Having coached over 50 rec teams over a 20 year span I had a lot of home schooled kids. My thoughts and experience with them are the majority are far ahead of the public schools in all areas of academic study, especially in math, science and reading. I had a few that were just the opposite. Some parents keep their kids out of the public schools because they believe the kids are being taught things that are opposite what their religion teaches and then go to the extreme on it. I had one kid in particular that was an all star football player. Neighborhood kid with a mother gone nuts on religion. Home "schooled" from an on line course I do not know how got approved here but this is the Bible Belt. "Gary" was a good kid but sheltered and was as dumb as a brick academically because his mother did not really care as long as Gary did not have to go to the evil school and be indoctrinated. Real story was she was sheltering Gary and could care less about his education. Tens of thousands of home schooled kids are this way. Gary eventually got away from his mother as his parents divorced and the father took him. He went to the high school and excelled after a few years on and off the football field. We have had a real problem with their court fights also wanting use after hours of all public school facilities such as sports fields, chemistry lab, libraries, etc. and have won every fight. The lack of social interaction often hurts these kids but I see them as a whole far better educated out of high school than the norm and that, after all is said is done, is the most important thing. Academics is where it is at and even more so now if you do play ball because few colleges and universities want to waste an academic scholarship on someone that will not be eligible the next year.
I would generally agree with that, but the problem with "this kid was home schooled and is stupid" is that, have you been in the public schools? There are just as many, if not more, really really stupid kids in public schools.
I keep going back to when I was in 11th grade, and met a kid from the inner city schools who asked me how to do a basic division problem..... like 5 divided by 2...... ON HIS CALCULATOR. He didn't know to do the division problem on his calculator.
Now we had a few, very few, students like that at my suburban school, but that's why they were 18 and still in 9th grade.
Here we had a kid in 11th grade, who still couldn't do basic division, even WITH a calculator.
So my thinking on the matter is this....
There are three parts to successful education.
1. the individual student.
2. the parents of the student.
3. the education system the student is in.
If the individual student does not have the ability, or simply refuses to engage in learning, nothing else matters.
You take that stupid homeschool kid who refuses to, or is unable to learn, and put him in a public school, all you are doing is dumping millions of dollars into a kid who still won't learn.
I'd rather he be homeschool, and cost the tax payers nothing.
You take that stupid homeschool kid, whose parents don't care about education, and put him in a public school, and all you are doing is dumping millions of dollars into a kids who doesn't care to learn, because his parents don't care to learn.
I've talked about my sister, stay at home mother of 5. After her first, she got those 'early reading books' and spent a whooping 1 hour a day, teaching her son to read. By the time he started school, he was 4 grade levels ahead in reading. To this day, now 6 years later, he's still top of his class in reading.
Just having a mother who is willing to put her career aside (she worked before becoming a housewife), and putting in minimal effort into teaching her kids, has made a MASSIVE impact on their education levels.
So it doesn't surprise me in the slightest that home schooled kids on average out perform their publicly educated peers.