Federal District Court judge Orders Return of El Salvador Citizen from El Salvador

[kyzr]

The gobshite's fawning cult doesn't understand why he is not above the law.

​

The federal judge overseeing the wrongful deportation case of Kilmar Abrego Garcia said she will order expedited discovery in order to "apply the law to the facts."​

​

"The Supreme Court has spoken," U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis told the parties during a hearing in Maryland on Tuesday, five days after the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed her ruling that the government "facilitate" Abrego Garcia's return from an El Salvador prison.​

​

"You made your jurisdictional arguments, you made your venue arguments," Judge Xinis told the Justice Department attorneys. "You made your arguments on the merits. You lost.​

Its not that simple. The USSC told the district judge he's not the district that has jurisdiction over Garcia, and that the district judge can't infringe on presidential authority.
If Garcia gets a hearing date, i.e. "due process", he gets deported until then.

 

[schmidlap]

Its not that simple. The USSC told the district judge he's not the district that has jurisdiction over Garcia, and that the district judge can't infringe on presidential authority.
If Garcia gets a hearing date, i.e. "due process", he gets deported until then.

The Supreme Court, in a unanimous ruling, ordered the Trump regime to facilitate the release of the man it had improperly deported and is paying El Salvador to keep imprisoned.

 

[schmidlap]

Its not that simple. The USSC told the district judge he's not the district that has jurisdiction over Garcia, and that the district judge can't infringe on presidential authority.
If Garcia gets a hearing date, i.e. "due process", he gets deported until then.

The conservative Supreme Court, to the chagrin of Trumpy xenophobes, appears to be a stickler for "due process."

Apparently, they are in favor of the U.S.Constitution and, specifically, the 14th Amendment being respected.

The U.S. Supreme Court on Saturday temporarily barred the Trump administration from deporting a group of Venezuelan migrants it accused of being gang members and was seeking to remove under a rarely used wartime law.​

The court issued the order after the men's lawyers asked it to intervene on an emergency basis, saying they faced imminent deportation without the judicial review the justices previously ordered.

"The Government is directed not to remove any member of the putative class of detainees from the United States until further order of this Court," the justices said...​

​

 

[whitehall]

"Return" of a person who was in the U.S. illegally? Was it intended as an oxymoron or is moron the official mindset of the TDS left these days?

 

[kyzr]

The Supreme Court, in a unanimous ruling, ordered the Trump regime to facilitate the release of the man it had improperly deported and is paying El Salvador to keep imprisoned.

True. Facilitate means ask for his release. At the press conference Bukele said he is not releasing him.
He is a citizen of El Salvador, and he is in El Salvador, end of story.

 

[kyzr]

The conservative Supreme Court, to the chagrin of Trumpy xenophobes, appears to be a stickler for "due process."
Apparently, they are in favor of the U.S.Constitution and, specifically, the 14th Amendment being respected.

The U.S. Supreme Court on Saturday temporarily barred the Trump administration from deporting a group of Venezuelan migrants it accused of being gang members and was seeking to remove under a rarely used wartime law.​

The court issued the order after the men's lawyers asked it to intervene on an emergency basis, saying they faced imminent deportation without the judicial review the justices previously ordered.​

"The Government is directed not to remove any member of the putative class of detainees from the United States until further order of this Court," the justices said...​

True. So I would drop off a bunch of gang bangers at the USSC until they approved the use of the AEA.
Either Trump deports them via the Remain in Mexico policy, and risk the return of gang bangers, or Trump tells Homan and Bondi to slow down and risk more needless American deaths due to the USSC allowing violent criminals to roam the USA.

 

[WEATHER53]

True. Facilitate means ask for his release. At the press conference Bukele said he is not releasing him.
He is a citizen of El Salvador, and he is in El Salvador, end of story.

It’s not even an actual asking. All it means is don’t get in the way if the country chooses to release him. Our arrogant on the dole judges feel they control that country’s decisions

 

[schmidlap]

True. Facilitate means ask for his release. At the press conference Bukele said he is not releasing him.
He is a citizen of El Salvador, and he is in El Salvador, end of story.

Why do you need to make that up?

The court did not order Trump to ask for the release of the the man it had mistakenly deported and is paying a totalitarian regime to keep in prison.

facilitate: to help bring (something) about

 

[WEATHER53]

Why do you need to make that up?

The court did not order Trump to ask for the release of the the man it had mistakenly deported and is paying a totalitarian regime to keep in prison.

facilitate: to help bring (something) about

Facilitate does not mean to initiate

 

[kyzr]

Why do you need to make that up?
The court did not order Trump to ask for the release of the the man it had mistakenly deported and is paying a totalitarian regime to keep in prison.
facilitate: to help bring (something) about

That is not what "facilitate" means, google it, it means: "To make easy or easier."

The "mistake" was deporting Garcia to El Salvador, which the deportation order said would endanger him from rival gangs, but Garcia is safe in prison. Garcia is a citizen of El Salvador, he is home, and he is staying there. He could have been deported anywhere else and it would have been fine per the deportation order.

 

[schmidlap]

That is not what "facilitate" means, google it, it means: "To make easy or easier."

The "mistake" was deporting Garcia to El Salvador, which the deportation order said would endanger him from rival gangs, but Garcia is safe in prison. Garcia is a citizen of El Salvador, he is home, and he is staying there. He could have been deported anywhere else and it would have been fine per the deportation order.

If you need to believe that the Supreme Court ruled that Trump must merely "ask" the dictator he is paying to keep Garcia imprisoned to release him, the man Trump wrongly deported without due process (who has no criminal record anywhere) that is what you will claim, apparently.

 

[WEATHER53]

If you need to believe that the Supreme Court ruled that Trump must merely "ask" the dictator he is paying to keep Garcia imprisoned to release him, the man Trump wrongly deported without due process (who has no criminal record anywhere) that is what you will claim, apparently.

Your accusation is zero explanation

 

[kyzr]

If you need to believe that the Supreme Court ruled that Trump must merely "ask" the dictator he is paying to keep Garcia imprisoned to release him, the man Trump wrongly deported without due process (who has no criminal record anywhere) that is what you will claim, apparently.

Abrego Garcia is MS-13 and a wife beater, he is also in the US illegally. He had his hearing, and was scheduled to be deported, just not to El Salvador. But he is a citizen of El Salvador, he is where he belongs.

DOJ plans to appeal Abrego Garcia ruling, releases documents it says tie him to gang

The Justice Department has released two documents that were used to allegedly tie wrongly deported Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the MS-13 gang.

abcnews.go.com

DHS Assistant Secretary of Public Affairs Tricia McLaughlin told ABC News' Jay O'Brien on Tuesday that Abrego Garcia's deportation to El Salvador was the result of a "clerical error" and that "he should have been sent to a detention center in Mexico, Nicaragua, Egypt."

 

[WEATHER53]

Abrego Garcia is MS-13 and a wife beater, he is also in the US illegally. He had his hearing, and was scheduled to be deported, just not to El Salvador. But he is a citizen of El Salvador, he is where he belongs.

DOJ plans to appeal Abrego Garcia ruling, releases documents it says tie him to gang

The Justice Department has released two documents that were used to allegedly tie wrongly deported Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the MS-13 gang.

abcnews.go.com

DHS Assistant Secretary of Public Affairs Tricia McLaughlin told ABC News' Jay O'Brien on Tuesday that Abrego Garcia's deportation to El Salvador was the result of a "clerical error" and that "he should have been sent to a detention center in Mexico, Nicaragua, Egypt."

So have an insipid USA flunky judge order him sent to Mexico Nicaragua or Egypt

 

[schmidlap]

Your accusation is zero explanation

Your accusation is zero explanation

I make no "accusations."

I respect the rule of law, and the conservative Supreme Court's unanimous ruling that Trump should facilitate the release of the man wrongly deported whom Trump is paying a dictator to keep imprisoned.

 

[schmidlap]

Abrego Garcia is MS-13 and a wife beater, he is also in the US illegally... [orl]

Tell your lies to the Supreme Court.

Trump is a convicted felon. Garcia is not.

 

[struth]

If you need to believe that the Supreme Court ruled that Trump must merely "ask" the dictator he is paying to keep Garcia imprisoned to release him, the man Trump wrongly deported without due process (who has no criminal record anywhere) that is what you will claim, apparently.

I agree he didn’t even have to ask. Just make easier and he has said he has a plane ready to pick him up and bring him back to a detention center to deport him again

 

[kyzr]

Tell your lies to the Supreme Court.
Trump is a convicted felon. Garcia is not.

What lie?
Read the link.
Garcia is in his home country, where he belongs, he is a citizen of El Salvador, he is not allowed into the US, says a judge.
DHS Assistant Secretary of Public Affairs Tricia McLaughlin told ABC News' Jay O'Brien on Tuesday that Abrego Garcia's deportation to El Salvador was the result of a "clerical error" and that "he should have been sent to a detention center in Mexico, Nicaragua, Egypt."

Trump's bullshit "lawfare" felonies will be thrown out any day now.

 

[schmidlap]

I agree he didn’t even have to ask. Just make easier and he has said he has a plane ready to pick him up and bring him back to a detention center to deport him again

• • 

    Due Process and the Abrego Garcia Case

    One hardly had to be Nostradamus to have predicted, as I did soon after Trump was sworn in, that the day was fast approaching when President Trump would

    reason.com
  • A 2019 court order expressly prohibits Abrego Garcia's removal to El Salvador because he faced a "clear probability of future persecution" there and had "demonstrated that El Salvadoran authorities were and would be unable or unwilling to protect him."
  • In March, 2025 without any notice or a warrant, ICE agents seized him, placed him on a plane, and transported him to an El Salvadoran prison (the "Center for Terrorism Confinement," (CECOT)).
  • Abrego Garcia has not been charged with any crime. No warrants have been issued against him or his property.
  • The government has asserted ... that he is a member of MS-13...
  • The government, however, has provided no evidence, to a grand jury or to a magistrate or to any third party, that it is true.
• 
  
• If Trump corrects his admitted mistake in deporting a man with no criminal record, he can then charge him with whatever he can present evidence to document.

Trump must comply with the law. He is not above it.

 

[struth]

• • 

    Due Process and the Abrego Garcia Case

    One hardly had to be Nostradamus to have predicted, as I did soon after Trump was sworn in, that the day was fast approaching when President Trump would

    reason.com
  • A 2019 court order expressly prohibits Abrego Garcia's removal to El Salvador because he faced a "clear probability of future persecution" there and had "demonstrated that El Salvadoran authorities were and would be unable or unwilling to protect him."
  • In March, 2025 without any notice or a warrant, ICE agents seized him, placed him on a plane, and transported him to an El Salvadoran prison (the "Center for Terrorism Confinement," (CECOT)).
  • Abrego Garcia has not been charged with any crime. No warrants have been issued against him or his property.
  • The government has asserted ... that he is a member of MS-13...
  • The government, however, has provided no evidence, to a grand jury or to a magistrate or to any third party, that it is true.
• 
  
• If Trump corrects his admitted mistake in deporting a man with no criminal record, he can then charge him with whatever he can present evidence to document.

Trump must comply with the law. He is not above it.

He is, he’s facilitated his return.

Moreover, Garcia status changed once his gang became a terrorist organization