Father off ISIS bride sues Trump administration cites possible loophole

[Kondor3]

Yeah but the U.S. is not her home. She isn't a citizen and the U.S. has no responsibility for her welfare.

Can somebody essplain how somebody born in New Jersey is not a US citizen?

TIA.

Dunno. Was she born within a diplomatic compound? Does her father's former diplomatic status at the time of birth impact her status?

 

[Kondor3]

If she is a citizen, then she is guilty of making war against the United States, and giving aid and comfort to the enemy.

The US Constitution calls that treason.

A capital offense.

----------

On second thought, let her back in.

We haven't had a public hanging in quite a while.

We can sell tickets.

And popcorn, and soft drinks, and SnoCaps and Raisinettes and nachos and...

 

[Crepitus]

If she is a US citizen then what she did is the very definition of treason.

If she not a citizen then why are we even talking about this?

 

[WillPower]

Dunno. Was she born within a diplomatic compound? Does her father's former diplomatic status at the time of birth impact her status?

There is some chatter about his, and consequently her status on the day she was born....doesn't matter because the State Dept has ruled she's never been a citizen and they're the deciders. She called on Americans to kill each other from Syria and wants to be forgiven? somebody get a rope.

 

[WillPower]

If she is a citizen, then she is guilty of making war against the United States, and giving aid and comfort to the enemy.

The US Constitution calls that treason.

A capital offense.

----------

On second thought, let her back in.

We haven't had a public hanging in quite a while.

We can sell tickets.

And popcorn, and soft drinks, and SnoCaps and Raisinettes and nachos and...

Raisonettes....mmmmmm.....

 

[B. Kidd]

She's only a naturalized citizen if the US could claim full jurisdiction over her upon birth. If another country can/could claim her allegiance or some semblance of jurisdiction over her, then no, she's not.

This actually was adjudicated US vs Wan Kim Ark, unlike the case of children of illegal immigrants who were born here which has not yet been adjudicated.

You may want to check that. I was born in Germany to a US service member. My understanding was that I had dual citizenship. Both valid

Your understanding of that is wrong, as usual.

 

[Crixus]

Her father was a diplomat which makes her ineligible.

I don't know how accurate that is. There were some reports that whatever the circumstances were...he was no longer a diplomate when she was born in this country.

Bottom line...if she's a citizen, she gets the same treatment that John Walker Lindh got. 20 years in jail.

Don't know why she would want that...

I would take it if I were her I n a heart beat. Say what you want about what she is. Religion and politics aside she is a mother who likely doesn’t want her kid or her to be killed. I don’t blame her a bit for trying. And I would be open to letting her come back as long as she go’s to prision first. Allot.

 

[John Shaw]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

 

[bripat9643]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

I thought all you leftwingers celebrated "diversity."

 

[Erinwltr]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

I thought all you leftwingers celebrated "diversity."

Is JS a leftwinger?

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

Man, that is really hardcore. Sad.

Have you not received the latest Orange POTUS memo/tweet? Socialism and Venezuela are the new Boogeyman. ISIS, 911, and Terrorism are the old Bad Guy. That was W and C schtick. The new letters to the terror soup are DJT.

Get with the program folks! Fall in line and watch Fox news and absorb Hannity until you become gloriously Orange and Redeemed!

 

[Mindful]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

Similar case in the UK; the girl in question, at present languishing in a Syrian refugee camp, having recently given birth. Wants to return to Britain to raise that kid, but has had her citizenship rescinded by the Home Office.

She wasn't fazed atall by seeing chopped off heads in bins.

 

[Marion Morrison]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

Similar case in the UK; the girl in question, at present languishing in a Syrian refugee camp, having recently given birth. Wants to return to Britain to raise that kid, but has had her citizenship rescinded by the Home Office.

She wasn't fazed atall by seeing chopped off heads in bins.

They can stay in whatever shithole country they went to.

 

[Mindful]

Here are some more:

'I broke no laws there': Canadian ISIS fighter wants help to return home

 

[Marion Morrison]

Here are some more:

'I broke no laws there': Canadian ISIS fighter wants help to return home

Faggot Trudeau will probably let her back.

 

[bullwinkle]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

I feel no pity for this kid and feel she forfeit her citizenship. I agree with the Trump admin on this one. But beyond denial of return, I can't wish her the horrors you describe.

 

[Mindful]

 

[Marion Morrison]

Here are some more:

'I broke no laws there': Canadian ISIS fighter wants help to return home

Faggot Trudeau will probably let her back. We need a northern border wall, too.

 

[kyzr]

They need to officially strip her of her US citizenship and indict her for treason. CAIR can't help her if she has no rights.

 

[22lcidw]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

I thought all you leftwingers celebrated "diversity."

Is JS a leftwinger?

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

Man, that is really hardcore. Sad.

Have you not received the latest Orange POTUS memo/tweet? Socialism and Venezuela are the new Boogeyman. ISIS, 911, and Terrorism are the old Bad Guy. That was W and C schtick. The new letters to the terror soup are DJT.

Get with the program folks! Fall in line and watch Fox news and absorb Hannity until you become gloriously Orange and Redeemed!

FOX gets a few million watching their top rated programs. Add all of the progressive socialist shills and their programs and subtle messages to in your face propaganda what do you get fifty million or more people at least watching every day? And I am being kind.The absorbing is done by you. You are weak as to buy in on something that has happened over and over in human history.

 

[TNHarley]

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

I thought all you leftwingers celebrated "diversity."

Is JS a leftwinger?

The fight over whether ISIS recruit Hoda Muthana is a US citizen, explained

It is a story I've heard about here and there, and find interesting.

I think she should be brought back, tried, and thrown in prison. Once she gets out, I would hope my fellow Americans would make her "disappear". only to turn up rotting in a ditch somewhere. These ISIS freaks need to understand that there is no mercy or forgiveness for them in the West. They certainly had no mercy for the Christians and Yazidis they came across.

Man, that is really hardcore. Sad.

Have you not received the latest Orange POTUS memo/tweet? Socialism and Venezuela are the new Boogeyman. ISIS, 911, and Terrorism are the old Bad Guy. That was W and C schtick. The new letters to the terror soup are DJT.

Get with the program folks! Fall in line and watch Fox news and absorb Hannity until you become gloriously Orange and Redeemed!

Sounds like you fell right in line with CNN.