Whether these tiny quakes mean the fault is old and dying or locking and loading for another massive earthquake has sparked a long and lively debate among scientists. A new study suggests recent reports of the "death" of the New Madrid Seismic Zone were premature. Based on statistical computer models, which predict how many aftershocks from the 19th century quakes should hit the region, U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) scientists think the past two centuries of earthquakes suggest the New Madrid Seismic Zone is popping more often than expected. Instead of slowing down, earthquake activity on the Reelfoot Fault continues at a sprightly pace.
A shakemap for the Feb. 7, 1812, New Madrid earthquake, one of four in the 1811-1812 series. The map is based on historical accounts of the shaking.
The findings were published today (Jan. 23) in the journal Science. "I don't agree that this area is dying out," said Morgan Page, lead study author and a geophysicist with the USGS in Pasadena, Calif. "It's not going to go off anytime soon, but we do have evidence that more stress is being built up now. Eventually, that energy will have to be released in a large earthquake."
At rest, or active?
The New Madrid Seismic Zone is a series of ancient faults cutting the Midwest and now hidden beneath the Mississippi River's thick mud. In late 1811 and early 1812, the New Madrid earthquakes struck on the Reelfoot Fault — four big earthquakes and many, many aftershocks emanating from the borders between Missouri, Tennessee and Arkansas. With each temblor estimated at between magnitude 7 and magnitude 8, the seismic energy shook all of eastern North America and destroyed the town of New Madrid, Mo. After the 1811-1812 earthquakes, the Reelfoot Fault could have faded from memory. Faults in the middle of continents, like the New Madrid Seismic Zone, may trigger earthquakes only rarely — every 10,000 years or more. (But this is not always the case; some "intraplate" faults, as these continent-cutting faults are called, can be speedy jackhammers.)
In recent years, a handful of studies claimed the New Madrid was settling down instead of prepping for another round of earthquakes. But the USGS team instead suggests that ongoing earthquakes in the New Madrid Seismic Zone are something new, resulting from the buildup of seismic energy on the faults. "Even though we can't predict earthquakes, we can predict the rates of aftershocks over time," Page explained. The frequency of aftershocks — smaller quakes that follow the big earthquake — decreases with time, known in seismology as Omori's Law. And in the New Madrid Seismic Zone, the aftershocks aren't following Omori's Law.
New quakes, not aftershocks