DACA Upheld by Supreme Court

[pknopp]

So the president cant just end an unconstiutional EO without good reason.
Nice precedent.

You don't think the fact that the EO is unconstitutional is a good reason?

Who ruled it unconstitutional?

 

[TNHarley]

So the president cant just end an unconstiutional EO without good reason.
Nice precedent.

You don't think the fact that the EO is unconstitutional is a good reason?

Its a moot point to them.

 

[TNHarley]

So the president cant just end an unconstiutional EO without good reason.
Nice precedent.

I wonder why they didn't get to the heart of it? They did the same thing with the bake-the-cake case. They kicked it back on technicalities and didn't touch the real problem with a ten foot pole.

The Constitution, though, does give the President authority to "manage" the agencies under his control, which includes DHS. Obama's EO said to DEFER deportation if certain conditions were met. It didn't make them "legal" or "citizens," just allowed them to work legally and get student loans for college and put their deportation on the back burner.
I'm not sure that's unconstitutional, TN.

Obama himself called it unconstitutional. Then did it anyways.
And he is a "constitutional scholar" remember?

 

[candycorn]

Roberts comes through again.

 

[Preacher]

Another loss for the blobbers.

View attachment 351799

As I always said, the court has a way of moderating itself

Just another perfect example that we will never fix America depending on thugs in robes or in congress but by using our 2nd amendment EXACTLY as our founding fathers explained.

 

[Jitss617]

It’s getting close, the time is getting just about right to protect our borders, protect our heritage, culture, language.

growing up in a city where latinos and other refugees flooded our schools and lowering our wages, and disrespecting our culture my patience is thin.

if we don’t stop this invasion our country is gone.

Supreme Court Rejects Trump Admin's Rescinding of DACA

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Thursday rejected President Donald Trump’s effort to end legal protections for 650,000 young immigrants, a stunning rebuke to the president in the midst of his reelection campaign.

www.breitbart.com

 

[Death-Ninja]

Except we may entertain absolutely no doubts that the Obama blackmailed Roberts, wouldn't have hesitated to overturn any Trump EO under same circumstances! Folks, this week has revealed the hand of Obama's total corruption of the high court, and now we all know precisely why Obama had Scalia murdered! This is a total ******* betrayal of the United States, and the only way out of this is to abolish the federal tyrant altogether, either through an article five convention or force of arms, either way this incarnation of the fed is revealed as utterly fascist and it has to be eliminated!

 

[ThoughtCrimes]

So the president cant just end an unconstiutional EO without good reason.
Nice precedent.

Have you read the decision already? I'm waiting for my copy from SCOTUS Blog still after all these minutes! Five of the Robes evidently don't agree with you in ruling Trump's method to try and end DACA in his chosen manner was "arbitrary and capricious". Gosh, the Orange Clown arbitrary and capricious? Who da thunk it?

 

[Preacher]

It’s getting close, the time is getting just about right to protect our borders, protect our heritage, culture, language.

growing up in a city where latinos and other refugees flooded our schools and lowering our wages, and disrespecting our culture my patience is thin.

if we don’t stop this invasion our country is gone.

Supreme Court Rejects Trump Admin's Rescinding of DACA

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Thursday rejected President Donald Trump’s effort to end legal protections for 650,000 young immigrants, a stunning rebuke to the president in the midst of his reelection campaign.

www.breitbart.com

Its all in the DOI

The Declaration of Independence says we have the right to overthrow the government

The right to overthrow a government remains an important principle to uphold, as it serves as a check on government power. It is a reminder that governments ...

www.learnliberty.org

 

[JLW]

Another civil war thread. They truly are like the herpes virus of USMB.

 

[okfine]

Another loss for the blobbers.

View attachment 351799

As I always said, the court has a way of moderating itself

Just another perfect example that we will never fix America depending on thugs in robes or in congress but by using our 2nd amendment EXACTLY as our founding fathers explained.

Working and going to school. Not sitting around whining. Sounds like a good fix to me.

 

[Sun Devil 92]

It wasn't actually upheld. It was ruled that the administration went about ending it in the wrong way.

Good distinction.

 

[Preacher]

Roberts has to go

That or having 2 leftists at least die or retire so Trump can replace them. 4 more years and I completely expect RBG to die who else?

 

[okfine]

It’s getting close, the time is getting just about right to protect our borders, protect our heritage, culture, language.

growing up in a city where latinos and other refugees flooded our schools and lowering our wages, and disrespecting our culture my patience is thin.

if we don’t stop this invasion our country is gone.

Supreme Court Rejects Trump Admin's Rescinding of DACA

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Thursday rejected President Donald Trump’s effort to end legal protections for 650,000 young immigrants, a stunning rebuke to the president in the midst of his reelection campaign.

www.breitbart.com

Loser.

 

[L.K.Eder]

So the president cant just end an unconstiutional EO without good reason.
Nice precedent.

Have you read the decision already? I'm waiting for my copy from SCOTUS Blog still after all these minutes! Five of the Robes evidently don't agree with you in ruling Trump's method to try and end DACA in his chosen manner was "arbitrary and capricious". Gosh, the Orange Clown arbitrary and capricious? Who da thunk it?

why wait?

Supreme Court of the United States Home

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-587_5ifl.pdf

Roberts slapped Thomas and especially Kavanaugh, lol.

 

[White 6]

This could have gone either way and indeed DACA could and probably will fall at sometime in the future, just not the way trump wanted to kill it, due to the poor work of administration lawyers and trump in they way they wrote and defended their rescission of DACA. But, as I said it really could have gone either way. Could it be, the stinging losses for the trump administration, the last few days are the result of attitudes being generated in the court by trump himself and his antics, statement and style of leadership over the last few months? Kind of like if the Republican Senate is not going to exercise any oversite or control on this moron, we'll remind him he doesn't get to rule by fiat, roughshod over America? Roberts made it clear, DACA is not approved, but the administration must get it's shit together and do the job right or STFU.

 

[pknopp]

So the president cant just end an unconstiutional EO without good reason.
Nice precedent.

I wonder why they didn't get to the heart of it? They did the same thing with the bake-the-cake case. They kicked it back on technicalities and didn't touch the real problem with a ten foot pole.

The Constitution, though, does give the President authority to "manage" the agencies under his control, which includes DHS. Obama's EO said to DEFER deportation if certain conditions were met. It didn't make them "legal" or "citizens," just allowed them to work legally and get student loans for college and put their deportation on the back burner.
I'm not sure that's unconstitutional, TN.

Obama himself called it unconstitutional. Then did it anyways.
And he is a "constitutional scholar" remember?

Obama said he did it based upon prosecutorial discretion.

 

[candycorn]

Another loss for the blobbers.

View attachment 351799

As I always said, the court has a way of moderating itself

Just another perfect example that we will never fix America depending on thugs in robes or in congress but by using our 2nd amendment EXACTLY as our founding fathers explained.

Well, what’s stopping you?

 

[Jitss617]

I know most of you don’t live in the heart of a urban area like I do,, I’m TELLING YOU AMERICAN CULTURE IS GONE, our heritage is laughed at, this anti American culture will only grow... I know before I die I will be smiling,, the time can’t come fast enough. I remain patient and unbelievably firm that I will raise the flag on the tears of millions of defeated anti American democrats. Until that day, let’s all stay focused. God bless

 

[pknopp]

This could have gone either way and indeed DACA could and probably will fall at sometime in the future, just not the way trump wanted to kill it, due to the poor work of administration lawyers and trump in they way they wrote and defended their rescission of DACA. But, as I said it really could have gone either way. Could it be, the stinging losses for the trump administration, the last few days are the result of attitudes being generated in the court by trump himself and his antics, statement and style of leadership over the last few months? Kind of like if the Republican Senate is not going to exercise any oversite or control on this moron, we'll remind him he doesn't get to rule by fiat, roughshod over America? Roberts made it clear, DACA is not approved, but the administration must get it's shit together and do the job right or STFU.

I've wondered this same thing myself. I've wondered if they considered that Trump will never actually pass anything so they are pretty much going to leave the status quo intact.

Just a thought.