College playoffs. Who should it be?

[Papageorgio]

The poll we have now was taken before the games on saturday

whoops missed that. Thanks

 

[leftwinger]

FSU should be in because they are 13 and 0. Regardless of injuries or conference.

Then its Ala or Texas....Im a Alabama Guy but Texas beat us....sooo post 4 is it

then Liberty has an argument too at 13-0. Maybe.

 

[Papageorgio]

Goal is not to subjectively go by some estimate of who is best?

You qualify based on your record
How can you put Alabama in over Texas when Texas beat them head to head?

Bama had more top 25 games and wins than Texas. Is a game played in week two have that much weight 10 weeks later?

I would be okay with either team, they both make good cases.

 

[eagle1462010]

then Liberty has an argument too at 13-0. Maybe.

Lol noo. FSU is in a big league conference. How can they be denied being undefeated???

 

[leftwinger]

Goal is not to subjectively go by some estimate of who is best?

You qualify based on your record
How can you put Alabama in over Texas when Texas beat them head to head?

The suits will never leave out an SEC team since the SEC was ranked in the top four all year IMO. I will quit the boards if SEC does not get a slot. Its…..$$$$$$$

 

[rightwinger]

Bama had more top 25 games and wins than Texas. Is a game played in week two have that much weight 10 weeks later?

I would be okay with either team, they both make good cases.

Look at NFL tie breakers for the playoffs

Head to head comes first
Strength of schedule is much lower

 

[rightwinger]

The suits will never leave out an SEC team since the SEC was ranked in the top four all year IMO. I will quit the boards if SEC does not get a slot. Its…..$$$$$$$

If they want SEC to have an automatic bid, they should say so
Otherwise, treat each conference equally

 

[Mac-7]

Now its official

Michigan
Washington
Texas
Alabama

Michigan v Bama

And Texas v Washington

 

[rightwinger]

Now its official

Michigan
Washington
Texas
Alabama

Michigan v Bama

And Texas v Washington

Florida got screwed

 

[leftwinger]

Now its official

Michigan
Washington
Texas
Alabama

Michigan v Bama

And Texas v Washington

if true! I am right again. You’re all welcome In advance.

FSU beat only Clemson who was considered good when they beat them. Even that was false flag. Sorry FSU, good Defense, good coaching. But injuries wiped them out.

 

[Mac-7]

if true! I am right again. You’re all welcome In advance.

Its true

 

[odanny]

Do you realize next year there will be 12 teams? Crazy.

I see a clear path to the championship for Alabama, if they beat Michigan, same goes for Michigan if they outlast a dangerous Alabama team.

I really don't see Washington or Texas in the mix, but anything can happen.

Florida State's defense, wow, best in college football.

 

[JackOfNoTrades]

Whelp, I stand corrected. I thought sure that Bama's loss to Texas would keep it out.
Man, the people at FSU must..be..pissed..

 

[eagle1462010]

Well i didnt expect this

 

[leftwinger]

Milroe on ALA got better and better. Not the same team as when TX beat them up. Of course it took a miracle for ALA to beat AUB lol! AUB who lost to NMSU who lost to (13-0) Liberty.

 

[Mac-7]

Whelp, I stand corrected. I thought sure that Bama's loss to Texas would keep it out.
Man, the people at FSU must..be..pissed..

Too many teams but not enough chairs at the table

 

[Mac-7]

Milroe on ALA got better and better. Not the same team as when TX beat them up. Of course it took a miracle to beat AUB lol! who lost to NMSU who lost to Liberty.

Texas is better now too

 

[Slade3200]

then Liberty has an argument too at 13-0. Maybe.

Liberty has made a case to get into a better league. But you gotta play against the best to make it to the Big Show

 

[eagle1462010]

Milroe on ALA got better and better. Not the same team as when TX beat them up. Of course it took a miracle for ALA to beat AUB lol! AUB who lost to NMSU who lost to (13-0) Liberty.

Georgia had trouble with Auburn, but yes that was a miracle win for Alabama

 

[Slade3200]

The suits will never leave out an SEC team since the SEC was ranked in the top four all year IMO. I will quit the boards if SEC does not get a slot. Its…..$$$$$$$

Ballsy bet and well played