Congratulations, PredFan! I've been making my own cheese now for...what, 7 years? I make feta, cheddar, mozzarella (I smoke both cheddar and mozzie), and a tasty Norwegian whey cheese, mysost (or brunost), as well as chevre, cream cheese, and yogurt. I use my own fresh goat milk and have always had the best results. I tried store-bought (pasteurized, processed) milk and had little success making a good cheese with it. Rikki Carroll's book is like a bible around here. Here's a link to one of her webpages. I am also subscribed to her monthly newsletter. Lots of neat information and recipes there.
Cheese Making Workshops with Ricki Carroll and Jamie Eckley
Another helpful website is Steve Shapson.
Cheese Making Equipment & Supplies | The Cheesemaker
I have also ordered lots of needed and helpful cheesemaking supplies from both their on-line stores, as well as many other great sources.
I love your press. It's innovative and works well, it seems. I usually make cheese in three-gallon batches (largest stainless steel pan I can still nest into another). Of course, I am milking 3-4 gallons a day right now, so milk is not in short supply. Not too many people have the resources to raise their own dairy animals, but if you can get some fresh, unprocessed milk (cow or goat works), try that and see if you don't like the results better.
Good luck. I'm looking forward to another cheese-maker on board.