P F Tinmore, et al,
As said before, the Hostile Arab Palestinians were
never denied their "rights."
So, Palestinians don't have rights because of special circumstances?
(COMMENT)
The Hostile Arab Palestinian:
Rejected sovereignty as recommended UNSCOP.
Failed in the bid to take by force that which they were unable to acquire through diplomacy.
Successfully exercised their rights in 1950 in the annexation by Jordan.
Failed in the attempt to take by force the Kingdom of Jordan.
Successful in the Declaration of Independence.
The decisions made by the Allied Powers of the Great War, were based on considerations and a concept greater than strict compliance. In this case we are looking at a people and culture that are deserving of "Special Consideration."
Example use in Federal Use beyond Criminal Matters:
Sometimes special circumstances can impact a student’s financial aid situation, including certain living arrangements or family situations that may change during your time at Cornell. This may result in the need to clarify your situation with the Office of Financial Aid, or have adjustments made. Explore the links below for further assistance or specifics that might apply to you.
Several Universities use the concept of Special Consideration. (Examples)
•
Cornell University
•
Duke University
•
Augsburg University
The Jewish people and culture were given special consideration for the need of a safe haven to aid in the preservation and defense of future.
The odd thing about Special Consideration, is that is is a positive attribute. It is not used to deny and award, but to reconsider the award because of circumstances not normally considered.
(ONE LAST THING)
The Palestinians never had or were given the rights to any territory (ever!). The "right to self-determination"
( jus cogens rule) does not mean they have some special award of territory. The "right of Self-determination is all about the formation of a government deriving ‘their just powers from the consent of the governed’ and that ‘whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends.
Restated: The Government of Israel was formed through the just powers derived from the Jewish People governed.
This is a true today, as it was in 1948, with the Mandate became destructive of its ends, and the Jewish People formed a new government.
There was no power or authority that ever actually deprived the Palestinians their right. It is because the Palestinians do not understand what the right of self-determination means that the claim arises.
•
Self-Determination, Oxford Public International Law
Subject(s):
Secession — Sovereignty — Self-determination — Unification
Published under the auspices of the Max Planck Foundation for International Peace and the Rule of Law under the direction of Rüdiger Wolfrum.
Most Respectfully,
R