The problem with it is neither trade nor alliances are simple binaries.
Our biggest trade issues are with China and it is less with dumping then with closed markets and intellectual property requirements. Since we aren’t alone in this, it would have made more sense to tackle the biggest trade issue first with an alliance of countries to put more pressure on China. Kinda killed that option though didn’t he?
You don’t just give foreign leaders what they want if it goes against your interests.
Giving Trump what he wants, in the short term, to save the alliance, especially as you guys keep insisting that the deficits don't matter and the jobs losses were caused by automation,
would be in their nation's long term interests.
Come on. You know why they won't do it.
Say it. SAY IT.
What are they and you so terrified of?