Zone1 A question for near death experiencer Robert Marshall?

[DennisPTate]

I have listened to virtually every interview by near death experiencer Robert Marshall that I can find on youtube.

Robert Marshall reports being mentored directly by Jesus for forty three hours and twenty eight minutes.

Robert also had a fifteen minute NDE, and a seventeen minute NDE before his direct meeting with Jesus.

Near death experiencer Robert Marshall does an astonishingly good job of answering questions about heaven or about Jesus.

I have been thinking and thinking and thinking and thinking of a good question for near death experiencer Robert Marshall"

"Mr. Robert Marshall.....
please ask Jesus to tell you what Satan would say......
if Satan was asked if Satan himself has a deep admiration bordering on FEAR....
regarding the off the scale brilliant sense of humour of "Moshiach ben David, Messiah Son of David / Messiah the Passover Lamb?"

....
Here is another one:
"Mr. Robert Marshall...
please ask Jesus what Satan would say if Satan was plainly asked by the ARchangel Michael......"
"Is Jesus your Boss?" ... "Is Jesus YOUR KING?"

.....

Zone1 Post in thread 'Is the Robert Marshall near death experience True, or False?'

Feb 16, 2026

Here is a very different type of interview with near death experiencer Robert Marshall where he answers specific questions about heaven and on the events in the Bible.

44 Hours In Heaven with Robert Marshall | 01/17/2026​

Here is the song that Jesus gave to Robert Marshall in about five minutes and then in about ten minutes he was given the music to this song.

Texas Resilience by Robert Marshall​

44 Hours In Heaven Ministries

Official channel of '44 Hours In Heaven Ministries'. A global evangelistic ministry through public venues and audio/video podcasts.

www.youtube.com

• DennisPTate

Zone1 Thread 'Does Satan work for Jesus?'

Dec 7, 2025

I admit that this question is going to be rather controversial but a pretty powerful case can be presented from The Book of Job as well as from the Christian scriptures that perhaps, Satan is obeying every command that he receives from Jesus, [who apparently has the authority to send people like near death experiencer Robert Marshall back to this earth with a mission that is relevant for all doctors and all nurses and all medical personnel in the USA and Canada and all the world]!

So if Satan is working for Jesus what is his job perhaps rather like?

Well, on one level I believe that...

• DennisPTate
• Replies: 144
• Forum: Clean Debate Zone

• 
• 

 

[Dante]

In my opinion he's a lunatic. Brain Science disputes the NDE being what is claimed. And Near Death? That means not dead

 

[DennisPTate]

In my opinion he's a lunatic. Brain Science disputes the NDE being what is claimed. And Near Death? That means not dead

Thank you for letting me know your opinion on this topic clearly and succinctly.

There are some awfully well informed Psychologists though who would tend to disagree with your overly simplistic opinion on this fascinating topic.

Reports are highly consistent and common: "I understand things so much more" and "My senses all seem heightened." Subjects claim "sudden knowledge and comprehension of complex mathematical theorems." Psychologist Ring has identified a consistent set of value and belief changes. They include:

a greater appreciation for life


o higher self-esteem

o greater compassion for others

o a heightened sense of purpose and self-understanding

o desire to learn

o elevated spirituality

o greater ecological sensitivity and planetary concern

o a feeling of being more intuitive, sometimes psychic.

o He also observes "psychophysical changes," including:


o increased physical sensitivity

o diminished tolerance to light, alcohol, and drugs

o a feeling that their brains have been "altered" to encompass more

o a feeling that they are now using their "whole brain" rather than just a small part.

NDErs undergo radical changes in personality, and their significant others—spouses, friends, relatives—confirm these changes, reports Bruce Greyson, M.D., clinical psychiatrist and associate professor at the University of Connecticut. Like Sappington, he is concerned with what can be learned from such new outlooks on life.

Bright Lights, Big Mystery

Offers a look at near-death experiences-- How they have become psychology's newest cottage industry and questions how real they are.

www.psychologytoday.com

and.....

Psychological Evidence of the Afterlife - Near-Death Experiences and the Afterlife

Near-Death Experiences and the Afterlife discusses about Psychological Evidence of the Afterlife , enjoy all our post about this!

near-death.com

 

[Vibor Blue]

Did you ever get an answer from Robert Marshall? I’ve asked him questions through his website and he has yet to reply. I have also found that his claims of having total recall appear to be false and you know of course that we are to test him.

He says he can recall everything Jesus told him with 100% accuracy. That’s supposedly how he was able to write My Walk with Jesus as a direct word for word transcript of his conversations. So how do we explain this:



He claims in this video at roughly the 1:00:09 timestamp that the earth is 3.6 billion years old

Yet in this video that aired a few months earlier, He says Jesus told him it is 13.3 billion years:



You’ll find it at roughly at the 53:20 timestamp.

 

[SweetSue92]

I have listened to virtually every interview by near death experiencer Robert Marshall that I can find on youtube.

Robert Marshall reports being mentored directly by Jesus for forty three hours and twenty eight minutes.

Robert also had a fifteen minute NDE, and a seventeen minute NDE before his direct meeting with Jesus.

Near death experiencer Robert Marshall does an astonishingly good job of answering questions about heaven or about Jesus.

I have been thinking and thinking and thinking and thinking of a good question for near death experiencer Robert Marshall"

"Mr. Robert Marshall.....
please ask Jesus to tell you what Satan would say......
if Satan was asked if Satan himself has a deep admiration bordering on FEAR....
regarding the off the scale brilliant sense of humour of "Moshiach ben David, Messiah Son of David / Messiah the Passover Lamb?"

....
Here is another one:
"Mr. Robert Marshall...
please ask Jesus what Satan would say if Satan was plainly asked by the ARchangel Michael......"
"Is Jesus your Boss?" ... "Is Jesus YOUR KING?"

.....

Zone1 Post in thread 'Is the Robert Marshall near death experience True, or False?'

Feb 16, 2026

Here is a very different type of interview with near death experiencer Robert Marshall where he answers specific questions about heaven and on the events in the Bible.

44 Hours In Heaven with Robert Marshall | 01/17/2026​

Here is the song that Jesus gave to Robert Marshall in about five minutes and then in about ten minutes he was given the music to this song.

Texas Resilience by Robert Marshall​

44 Hours In Heaven Ministries

Official channel of '44 Hours In Heaven Ministries'. A global evangelistic ministry through public venues and audio/video podcasts.

www.youtube.com

• DennisPTate

Zone1 Thread 'Does Satan work for Jesus?'

Dec 7, 2025

I admit that this question is going to be rather controversial but a pretty powerful case can be presented from The Book of Job as well as from the Christian scriptures that perhaps, Satan is obeying every command that he receives from Jesus, [who apparently has the authority to send people like near death experiencer Robert Marshall back to this earth with a mission that is relevant for all doctors and all nurses and all medical personnel in the USA and Canada and all the world]!

So if Satan is working for Jesus what is his job perhaps rather like?

Well, on one level I believe that...

• DennisPTate
• Replies: 144
• Forum: Clean Debate Zone

• 
• 

IMO you should be really skeptical of NDE and accounts of Jesus. Rely on His Word, not on what random people report about being close to death. There's too much opportunity for wrong and poor teaching there

 

[Vibor Blue]

@SweetSue92
Exactly! It is also too easy for some of them to profit from their stories. It can even cause some to abandon Christ.

 

[Hawkins]

I simply think that you should ask me instead. A death shall involve a resurrection. That's how I felt when I died and returned when I was not yet a person can be deemed a Christian (virtually I never read the Bible besides the first chapter of Genesis and didn't attened any church). I think I know what the process of death is from how it begins till its very last step. Though I can't verify if every such steps are equally applicable to all human individuals, that is, when they die. There are some steps which are common with Jesus' behavior on the cross as recorded in the Bible. I bet that everyone died shall have witnessed and realized that Jesus truly died a human's death.

 

[DennisPTate]

IMO you should be really skeptical of NDE and accounts of Jesus. Rely on His Word, not on what random people report about being close to death. There's too much opportunity for wrong and poor teaching there

True.....
what you say is accurate but.....
I have noticed that Theologians who are VOLUNTEERS tend to have a vastly higher level of what could be termed "Berean Quotient."

To my thinking a Berean Quotient corresponds with a willingness to research a subject and arrive at a logical and rational understanding. I have so far visited a group here in Paris, Ontario, two times, and my impression so far is that their "Berean Quotient" is arguably the highest that I have ever encountered in my sixty six years. I believe that it is no coincidence that their leaders and speakers are all VOLUNTEERS!

Zone1 Thread 'Christadelphians?'

Mar 6, 2026

On Wednesday night I went to a meeting that I thought has got to be a branch of the Worldwide Church of God but no, this was an entirely different church that apparently has over fifty thousand members worldwide.

I noticed immediately that one of the advantages that this church has over the WWCG is that they are NOT non-Prostylitizing as the WWCG used to be. I am impressed that this group actually wants to meet and begin to mentor people who might just be interested in their movement.

Christadelphians are a non-trinitarian, millennialist Christian group founded in the 19th century...

• DennisPTate
• Replies: 10
• Forum: Religion and Ethics

 

[DennisPTate]

@SweetSue92
Exactly! It is also too easy for some of them to profit from their stories. It can even cause some to abandon Christ.

True....
but am I an idiot to suspect that even the truly brilliant Pastor Joel Osteen.....
might find near death experiencer Robert Marshall and his wife rather scary or intimidating?

What if Pastor Joel Osteen did a special meeting on Friday night at his massive church where he had The near death experiencer Robert Marshall giving his testimony......

and then on Saturday Robert Marshall is there again answering question after question after question by the tithe paying members of the Joel Osteen Mega-church?

Could... the members prefer the answers WITH AUTHORITY that Robert Marshall gives even over the brilliant and truly encouraging messages that Pastor Joel gives?

It is a real possibility......
and this is one of the reasons why the board of directors of some Mega-Churches may fear near death experiencer Robert Marshall.....
or near death experiencer Kevin L. Zadai.....
or near death experiencer Howard Storm.....
and the list goes on and on and on and on and on!

Home | 44 Hours In Heaven

www.44hoursinheavenministries.org

Pastor Tony from Houston, Texas FEARs JESUS much more than he fears a disruption to the revenue stream of his church though. I think that Jesus has a special love for courageous Theologians like Pastor Tony.

44 hours in Heaven with Jesus | Robert Marchall | External Website

vssm.vcchouston.org

On January 17th and 18th, 2026, listen to a firsthand account of heaven by Robert Marshall.​

Victory Christian Center is honored to announce a special public appearance by Robert Marshall, the only known individual to give a living, documented testimony of dying and spending 44 hours in Heaven with Jesus. His remarkable story—verified by medical records confirming multiple deaths and prolonged oxygen deprivation—has inspired audiences nationwide and around the world.

Saturday​

Robert will share his extraordinary testimony, discuss his time in Heaven, and answer questions from attendees. Copies of his books and music will be available at the product table.

Saturday, January 17, 2025
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Victory Christian Center
11420 Cutten Road Hosuton, TX 77066
Reserved Seating limited seats available
Reserved Seating: $20 per person
General adminission: FREE
Childcare 3 months - 5 years old:
$7 per child. Limited space available
*Children in reserved seats must have a registration for each child.
Reserved Seats will receive a wristband starting at 8am.

General Admission Opens at 8:30am.
Reserved Seat
Register Now
Register for Childcare
3 Month - 5 years old
Submit a Question
for Q & A

Sunday​

Robert will share his extraordinary testimony and discuss his time in Heaven. Copies of his books and music will be available at the product table.

Sunday, January 18, 2025
10:00 AM Service Only
Victory Christian Center
11420 Cutten Road Hosuton, TX 77066
FREE Admission
Children's Ministries open for ages 3 Months - 5th Grade
*No Youth Ministries: 6th - 12th grade join guardians in the main sanctuary

About Robert Marshall​

On May 19, 2024, Robert Marshall died three times in the ICU after experiencing suffocation, acute hypoxic respiratory failure, drowning in his own blood, and cardiac arrest. His brain and organs were deprived of oxygen for approximately 90 minutes, leaving him clinically brain-dead. During these periods of death, Robert repeatedly found himself in Heaven, walking with Jesus—who taught him about Scripture, Heaven, and His kingdom in ways beyond earthly understanding.

On May 23, 2024, Jesus performed a miracle: Robert’s life was fully restored. His brain and organs returned to normal function, leaving physicians astonished. Robert awakened as if he had never died—yet his medical documentation affirms that he had.

Following his return, Jesus commanded Robert to share everything he saw, learned, and experienced. As recorded in Chapter 10 of Robert’s first book, 44 Hours In Heaven, Jesus instructed him:

“You will worship Me in Truth and Spirit, and you will do as I command you”.
“You will share how and why you were given life again”.
“You will share with anybody, anytime, anyplace that I put in your path”
“ You will answer any questions from anybody, anytime, anyplace who asks.”

Since then, Robert has dedicated his life to fulfilling this command through personal appearances, radio and Gospel TV interviews, podcasts, seminars, school visits, church services, revivals, and conferences around the country and the world. He also writes, arranges, and produces Christian music inspired by the words and music Jesus gives him.

A Story Told Through Two Powerful Books​

Robert’s testimony is detailed in his two published works:

• 44 HOURS IN HEAVEN — A firsthand account of his deaths, his time in Heaven, what he witnessed there, his encounters and conversations with Jesus, and the miracle that restored him to life. The book also shares the emotional journey of his wife, Carol, as she prayed and believed even after receiving word that he had died.

• 44 HOURS IN HEAVEN: MY WALK WITH JESUS — A cinematic, immersive transcript of Robert’s direct conversations and teachings received from Jesus. Written as though a camera follows their steps, this book invites readers into the vivid beauty, light, and reality of Heaven as Robert experienced it. It is not an argument, but a testimony—an encounter with revelation, hope, and the glory of the place Jesus has prepared.

About Robert Marshall & 44 Hours In Heaven Ministries​

Through 44 Hours In Heaven Ministries, a (501) (c3) non-profit, Robert Marshall continues the blessing as Jesus commanded him: to tell his story to “anybody, anytime, anyplace.” His ministry brings messages of hope, Heaven’s reality, and the love of Jesus to audiences of all ages and backgrounds.

 

[DennisPTate]

I simply think that you should ask me instead. A death shall involve a resurrection. That's how I felt when I died and returned when I was not yet a person can be deemed a Christian (virtually I never read the Bible besides the first chapter of Genesis and didn't attened any church). I think I know what the process of death is from how it begins till its very last step. Though I can't verify if every such steps are equally applicable to all human individuals, that is, when they die. There are some steps which are common with Jesus' behavior on the cross as recorded in the Bible. I bet that everyone died shall have witnessed and realized that Jesus truly died a human's death.

Wow!

You have a lot in common with the many former Atheists who had one of those near death experiences and returned to this earth with a mission to reach out with a message about what they had been shown.

Former Atheist Mellen Benedict, does an amazing job of explaining how finding his consciousness outside of his body, really shocked him, but they when he sees a point of light that came closer and became a Being of Light, Mellen Benedict decides to ask question after question after question to this Being of Light, and all of his questions are answered brilliantly.

1. About Mellen-Thomas Benedict​

In 1982 Mellen-Thomas Benedict (died 2017) suffered from terminal brain cancer and died; but miraculously lived to tell about it. While showing no vital signs for 90 minutes, Benedict had perhaps the most transcendental near-death experience (NDE) ever documented. While on the Other Side, Benedict journeyed through various afterlife realms and was given access to Universal Intelligence by which he was allowed to absorb a tremendous amount of spiritual and scientific knowledge including the nature of reincarnation. Benedict’s enthusiastic curiosity during his NDE took him far into the remote depths of existence – and even beyond – into the energetic void of nothingness behind the Big Bang. He was shown in holographic detail the evolution of both Mother Earth (“Gaia”) and humanity and experienced the cosmology of our soul’s connection with Gaia. He was given knowledge about humanity’s role in the Universe including a beautiful vision of humanity’s future for the next 400 years. Deepak Chopra, in his book “Life after Death: The Burden of Proof,” recounts Benedict’s journey at length and says, “Mellen is an encyclopedia of the afterlife.” In the view of the webmaster of this site, on this web page you will read the most inspirational NDE ever documented.

Mellen-Thomas Benedict - Near-Death Experiences and the Afterlife

Near-Death Experiences and the Afterlife profiles Mellen-Thomas Benedict . Did you enjoy reading this post, we have more!

near-death.com

 

[DennisPTate]

Did you ever get an answer from Robert Marshall? I’ve asked him questions through his website and he has yet to reply. I have also found that his claims of having total recall appear to be false and you know of course that we are to test him.

He says he can recall everything Jesus told him with 100% accuracy. That’s supposedly how he was able to write My Walk with Jesus as a direct word for word transcript of his conversations. So how do we explain this:



He claims in this video at roughly the 1:00:09 timestamp that the earth is 3.6 billion years old

Yet in this video that aired a few months earlier, He says Jesus told him it is 13.3 billion years:



You’ll find it at roughly at the 53:20 timestamp.

Those are good questions. I will try to get back into these again. I do remember him saying that the "earth" was three point six billion years old and the number of 13.3 billion, is interesting to me because even Stephen Hawking Ph. D. gave the number of thirteen point seven two billion years in the past for the time of that major "Big Bang" event.

I never get bored of what Robert Marshall gives as answers for questions. He answers a lot of questions on his podcasts and it can be a job to dig through them to get to specific answers to somebody's exact questions.

 

[Hawkins]

Wow!

You have a lot in common with the many former Atheists who had one of those near death experiences and returned to this earth with a mission to reach out with a message about what they had been shown.

Former Atheist Mellen Benedict, does an amazing job of explaining how finding his consciousness outside of his body, really shocked him, but they when he sees a point of light that came closer and became a Being of Light, Mellen Benedict decides to ask question after question after question to this Being of Light, and all of his questions are answered brilliantly.

Basically, after death can see the same reality as we see but in a rather completely dimmed environment. I was in the dead bed in the hospital. I continued to see Hades after beting resurrected back. Paul actually sets an example of what it is. Paul saw the Third Heaven not during his NDE but after. The description is, "Whether it was in the body or out of the body I do not know—God knows."

What significant is not the part during the NDE but after being resurrected. The soul doesn't seem to "combine" well with the body that you continue to see scenes of Hades (somehow in Paul's case he saw the Third Heaven) that you can't determine (especial no science back then) whether the experience is in body or out of body (as a result of soul not sticking completely with the body).

In a natural resurrection, one shall see Hades (as a result of soul till "seeing"). In Paul's case, he's intendedly brought to another space, not Hades. Reality overlaps with another space which the Jews referred to as the Third Heaven or Abraham's Bosom.

During the NDE then, all I saw is the same exact environment when I died. It's the same environment when I was resurrected. I didn't go anywhere (no trips to heaven or hell). The only difference is the lighting. It's a sunshine afternoon (I knew this only after being resurrected), but I was like lying on the bed at night. I knew that it's my last moment so I sided my head towards left. The same posture maintained. I "woke up" with face towards the left. The only difference is, I saw natural light. Back then I didn't even think of the term "resurrection", I simply told the 1 out of 4 doctors that, "Our Lord saved me back". Guess what, that doctor was scared.

Then things (about Hades) continued to happen in front of me and all other doctors and nurses (I don't lack eyewitnesses). However, it's just like Paul was in Damascus, only I (my soul) can see things but not they (some of them were scared). One doctor said to another doctor, "you shall believe all these as at that point (of death) you might well see the same."

In a nutshell, a resurrection is all about what happen after the NDE, not during it. It's in a status that one's soul still not yet fully combines with his body, which is, 2 Cor 12:2, "Whether it was in the body or out of the body I do not know—God knows.".

 

[DennisPTate]

Basically, after death can see the same reality as we see but in a rather completely dimmed environment. I was in the dead bed in the hospital. I continued to see Hades after beting resurrected back. Paul actually sets an example of what it is. Paul saw the Third Heaven not during his NDE but after. The description is, "Whether it was in the body or out of the body I do not know—God knows."

What significant is not the part during the NDE but after being resurrected. The soul doesn't seem to "combine" well with the body that you continue to see scenes of Hades (somehow in Paul's case he saw the Third Heaven) that you can't determine (especial no science back then) whether the experience is in body or out of body (as a result of soul not sticking completely with the body).

In a natural resurrection, one shall see Hades (as a result of soul till "seeing"). In Paul's case, he's intendedly brought to another space, not Hades. Reality overlaps with another space which the Jews referred to as the Third Heaven or Abraham's Bosom.

During the NDE then, all I saw is the same exact environment when I died. It's the same environment when I was resurrected. I didn't go anywhere (no trips to heaven or hell). The only difference is the lighting. It's a sunshine afternoon (I knew this only after being resurrected), but I was like lying on the bed at night. I knew that it's my last moment so I sided my head towards left. The same posture maintained. I "woke up" with face towards the left. The only difference is, I saw natural light. Back then I didn't even think of the term "resurrection", I simply told the 1 out of 4 doctors that, "Our Lord saved me back". Guess what, that doctor was scared.

Then things (about Hades) continued to happen in front of me and all other doctors and nurses (I don't lack eyewitnesses). However, it's just like Paul was in Damascus, only I (my soul) can see things but not they (some of them were scared). One doctor said to another doctor, "you shall believe all these as at that point (of death) you might well see the same."

In a nutshell, a resurrection is all about what happen after the NDE, not during it. It's in a status that one's soul still not yet fully combines with his body, which is, 2 Cor 12:2, "Whether it was in the body or out of the body I do not know—God knows.".

Wow!!!!!!

It seems to me that all near death experiencers return to this four dimensional space and time continuum with a message for all of the rest of us.

Here is an online book by 2024 near death experiencer Robert Marshall that to my thinking, puts him into the same league as some of the best writers on Sprituality on earth, but before his NDE Robert Marshall could not have written so much as one paragraph of this truly brilliant book.

My Walk With Jesus audio | 44 Hours In Heaven

www.44hoursinheavenministries.org